- Legal Basis
- §§ 3, 5, 6 BÄO
- Sentencing Range
- Suspension or revocation of the Approbation (licence to practise medicine)
- Summary
- Revocation or suspension of the medical licence for unworthiness or unreliability.
Revocation of the licence to practise medicine (Approbation) is the most severe professional-law measure against a doctor, because without an Approbation the profession may not be practised. Under the Federal Medical Practitioners Act (Bundesärzteordnung, BÄO), the Approbation must be revoked if the doctor subsequently becomes unworthy or unreliable to practise (Section 5(2) BÄO). The authority may order its suspension, among other cases, while criminal proceedings are pending or where the doctor is no longer medically fit (Section 6 BÄO). Since revocation often follows a criminal conviction, the criminal defence and the defence in the licensing proceedings should be coordinated from the outset.
Approbation, revocation and suspension: how the BÄO works
The Approbation is the state permission to practise as a doctor. Its requirements are set out in Section 3 BÄO. Besides completed medical training, the doctor must not have engaged in conduct showing that he or she is unworthy or unreliable to practise, and must be medically fit to practise. If one of these requirements later ceases to be met, two measures are possible:
- Revocation of the Approbation (Section 5(2) BÄO): if the doctor subsequently becomes unworthy or unreliable, the authority must revoke the Approbation; it has no discretion. If medical fitness is lacking, it may revoke. Revocation is permanent in nature.
- Suspension of the Approbation (Section 6 BÄO): the authority may order suspension where criminal proceedings have been opened against the doctor on suspicion of an offence that may show unworthiness or unreliability. Further grounds include lack of medical fitness, refusal to undergo a medical examination where there are doubts about fitness, and insufficient knowledge of German. Suspension is temporary and must be lifted once its conditions no longer apply. While it lasts, the doctor may not practise.
The competent body is the licensing authority of the respective federal state. In North Rhine-Westphalia (NRW) this is the competent district government (Bezirksregierung); there are five of them (Arnsberg, Detmold, Düsseldorf, Cologne and Münster). Their decisions can be challenged before the administrative courts.
When is a doctor “unworthy” or “unreliable”?
A doctor is unworthy where serious misconduct has damaged the standing and trust the medical profession depends on so badly that continued practice appears untenable. The trigger is often a serious criminal offence, such as large-scale billing fraud, sexual or violent offences, or grave breaches of the rules on narcotics.
Unreliability, by contrast, is based on a forecast. It exists where past conduct offers no assurance that the doctor will practise properly in future. Both are indeterminate legal concepts which the administrative courts review in full. How they apply in a particular case is often open to argument.
The close link with the criminal proceedings
In practice, revocation frequently follows a criminal conviction. Whether there is a conviction, for which offence and with what sentence shapes the later assessment of worthiness and reliability. The authority and the administrative court may as a rule adopt the findings of a final judgment or penalty order. A defence that looks only at the sentence in the criminal case overlooks this knock-on effect.
Strategy and options
Setting the course in the criminal proceedings
Because the licensing authority builds on the criminal findings, we also direct the defence in the criminal proceedings towards the professional consequences. The aim may be a discontinuation, a lesser charge, or an outcome that does not support a finding of unworthiness. A confession therefore needs careful consideration as well.
Contesting unworthiness and the forecast
Not every conviction establishes unworthiness. We show how closely the offence is connected with medical practice, how long ago it occurred, whether it was a one-off and how the doctor has behaved since. This allows the assumption of unworthiness or of a negative reliability forecast to be challenged.
Discretion for suspension, proportionality for revocation
When revoking for unworthiness or unreliability, the authority has no discretion. Proportionality is considered there as part of the question whether the threshold of unworthiness has been reached at all. Suspension is different: the authority must exercise its discretion and weigh whether the measure is necessary or whether less drastic means would suffice. Errors in that weighing make the decision open to challenge.
Interim relief
Suspension and revocation are often ordered with immediate effect. The doctor must then stop practising at once, even if he or she brings an action against the decision. In such cases we apply to the administrative court to restore the suspensive effect (Section 80(5) of the Code of Administrative Court Procedure, VwGO). During a suspension the authority may allow another doctor to continue running the practice (Section 6(4) BÄO).
Prospect of re-issue
Even after revocation, the Approbation can be granted again once the grounds have ceased to exist. As a rule this requires a longer period without any complaints. We also assist doctors through this process.
Frequently asked questions
Do I automatically lose my Approbation if I am convicted?
No. Revocation requires unworthiness or unreliability, and the licensing authority decides this in separate proceedings. Not every conviction is sufficient.
What is the difference between suspension and revocation?
Suspension is temporary and bridges, for example, the period of pending criminal proceedings. Revocation is permanent in nature and ends professional practice.
Can I get my Approbation back later?
Yes, once the grounds for revocation have ceased to exist. The authority will regularly require the doctor to have proved himself or herself over a longer period.
Nationwide representation
We represent doctors throughout Germany in licensing proceedings, from suspension through revocation to re-issue, and coordinate this defence with the criminal proceedings. Related topics: billing fraud and corruption in healthcare and professional court for the healthcare professions.
This overview is general in nature and does not replace advice in an individual case. Decisive are the Federal Medical Practitioners Act and the decision of the competent licensing authority.
What to do now
Emergency help: Police summons: how to respond, Penalty order: check the deadline
Court: Proceedings at Bonn Local Court
Emergency help: Summons, House search, Detention
Local defense: Criminal defense attorney in Bonn, Cologne, All offences
Written by attorney Philip Bafteh, criminal defense attorney in Bonn. Philip Bafteh publishes regularly on criminal and commercial law and defends accused persons in investigative and trial proceedings.
More about the attorney →Last updated: November 2026
Free Initial Assessment
Have you received a summons or are you under investigation? Call us. The first assessment by phone is free for up to 10 minutes.
+49 228 504 463 36