- Legal Basis
- § 81 Abs. 5 SGB V
- Sentencing Range
- Warning, reprimand, fine up to €50,000, suspension of licence up to 2 years
- Summary
- Disciplinary measures of the SHI association for breaches of contract-physician duties.
Contract physicians who breach their contract-physician duties must expect disciplinary proceedings by their Association of Statutory Health Insurance Physicians (Kassenärztliche Vereinigung, KV), for example the KV Nordrhein. The legal basis is Section 81(5) of Book V of the Social Code (SGB V). The measures range from a warning and a reprimand to a fine of up to €50,000 and suspension of the licence for up to two years. We represent doctors throughout Germany in these proceedings.
What are disciplinary proceedings of the KV?
Contract physicians are members of the Association of SHI Physicians and are subject to its disciplinary authority. The legal basis is Section 81(5) SGB V in conjunction with the disciplinary regulations of the respective KV. Disciplinary proceedings are not criminal proceedings. Their purpose is to ensure proper contract-physician care. Depending on the statutes, the KV’s disciplinary committee decides on the measure by way of an administrative act.
North Rhine-Westphalia (NRW) has two Associations of SHI Physicians: the KV Nordrhein for the administrative districts of Düsseldorf and Cologne, and the KV Westfalen-Lippe based in Dortmund. Each has its own disciplinary regulations; we use the KV Nordrhein as an example here.
When are disciplinary measures imposed?
The trigger is a culpable breach of contract-physician duties. Typical occasions are:
- breaches of the efficiency requirement and persistent inefficiency,
- breaches of the duties of presence, emergency service or arranging cover,
- breaches of billing rules and documentation duties,
- disregard of guidelines of the Federal Joint Committee (G-BA) or of requirements set by the KV,
- breaches of duties to cooperate with and provide information to the KV.
Which measures are possible?
Section 81(5) SGB V contains an exhaustive catalogue which the association’s statutes may neither restrict nor extend. Depending on the seriousness of the misconduct, the following come into consideration:
- a warning as the mildest measure,
- a reprimand,
- a fine of up to €50,000 (the ceiling was raised from €10,000 in 2015),
- suspension of the licence or of contract-physician participation for up to two years.
Several measures may be combined. Suspension of the licence weighs heaviest: it temporarily excludes the doctor entirely from contract-physician care and thus from a large part of his or her income.
Distinction: disciplinary proceedings, review procedures and withdrawal of the licence
Disciplinary proceedings must be distinguished from related proceedings. The efficiency review (Section 106 SGB V) and the billing and plausibility review (Section 106d SGB V) aim at reducing fees and reclaiming payments, not at a disciplinary measure. Withdrawal of the licence under Section 95(6) SGB V is the harsher response to gross breaches of duty; the admission committee decides on it. In practice these proceedings often run side by side and influence one another. We therefore consider them together from the outset.
Procedure and legal protection
The proceedings usually begin with a hearing. The disciplinary committee decides by way of a formal decision. There is no objection procedure (fourth sentence of Section 81(5) SGB V); an action against the disciplinary decision must be brought directly before the social court. The time limit for the action is one month. We therefore inspect the file early and observe the deadline.
Strategy and options
Examining the breach of duty and fault
We examine whether a contract-physician duty was actually breached and whether this was culpable. Especially with allegations of inefficiency or billing errors, the standards are complex. Not every irregularity justifies a disciplinary measure.
Ensuring proportionality
The measure must be proportionate. We work towards a milder measure instead of suspension of the licence, or a reduced fine, and bring out mitigating circumstances and changes already made in the practice.
Using procedural errors
A missing or inadequate hearing, defective reasoning and errors of discretion make the decision open to challenge. We examine the administrative act for such errors.
Protecting the practice’s livelihood
Suspension of the licence threatens the economic basis of the practice. If the KV orders immediate enforcement, we apply to the social court for interim relief and look for transitional arrangements for the practice.
Links with professional and criminal law
The same facts can at the same time concern the medical chamber and the public prosecutor. We coordinate the defence across all proceedings.
Prospects and risks
Because the measures are subject to the principle of proportionality and the catalogue is exhaustive, there is room to work towards a milder measure. In cases of persistent or serious breaches, especially in connection with billing manipulation, suspension of the licence is a real risk, and the next step can be withdrawal of the licence.
Frequently asked questions
Are disciplinary proceedings of the KV criminal proceedings?
No. They are separate proceedings under contract-physician law. They can, however, run alongside criminal proceedings and professional-court proceedings of the chamber.
How high can the fine be?
Up to €50,000. Suspension of the licence, which can be ordered in addition to the fine, usually weighs more heavily.
Can I challenge the measure?
Yes, directly by bringing an action before the social court within one month.
Nationwide representation
We represent contract physicians throughout Germany in disciplinary proceedings of the Associations of SHI Physicians, from the hearing and the proceedings before the disciplinary committee to the action before the social court. Related topics: withdrawal of the contract-physician licence (Section 95 SGB V) and billing fraud and corruption in healthcare.
This overview is general in nature and does not replace advice in an individual case. Decisive are Section 81(5) SGB V and the disciplinary regulations of the respective Association of SHI Physicians.
What to do now
Emergency help: Police summons: how to respond, Penalty order: check the deadline
Court: Proceedings at Bonn Local Court
Emergency help: Summons, House search, Detention
Local defense: Criminal defense attorney in Bonn, Cologne, All offences
Written by attorney Philip Bafteh, criminal defense attorney in Bonn. Philip Bafteh publishes regularly on criminal and commercial law and defends accused persons in investigative and trial proceedings.
More about the attorney →Last updated: November 2026
Free Initial Assessment
Have you received a summons or are you under investigation? Call us. The first assessment by phone is free for up to 10 minutes.
+49 228 504 463 36