Billing Fraud and Corruption in Healthcare: criminal defence in Bonn

Legal Basis
§§ 263, 299a, 299b, 300 StGB
Sentencing Range
Imprisonment of up to five years or a fine (Section 263 StGB); imprisonment of up to three years or a fine (Sections 299a, 299b StGB)
Summary
Billing fraud and corruption in healthcare with professional-law consequences.

Billing fraud (Section 263 of the German Criminal Code, StGB) and corruption in healthcare (Sections 299a, 299b StGB) are among the allegations with the most serious consequences for doctors. Fraud carries up to five years’ imprisonment and corruption up to three years, with higher ranges in particularly serious cases. On top of this, doctors risk losing their contract-physician licence and their licence to practise medicine (Approbation). An early defence coordinated across all proceedings therefore keeps both liberty and professional livelihood in view.

Billing fraud (Section 263 StGB)

Billing fraud is committed where a doctor deceives the Association of Statutory Health Insurance Physicians (KV), a health insurance fund or, in private billing, patients about facts relevant to billing, causing financial loss. Typical allegations are billing for services not rendered or not rendered personally, charging fee items that cannot be billed, and breaches of the requirement of personal performance. The penalty is imprisonment of up to five years or a fine. In particularly serious cases (Section 263(3) StGB), for example commercial conduct or a loss of great magnitude, the range is six months to ten years. Because individual bills add up over many quarters, the alleged loss, and with it the potential sentence, quickly reaches considerable levels.

Corruption in healthcare (Sections 299a, 299b StGB)

Since June 2016, taking and giving bribes in healthcare have been separate criminal offences. Section 299a StGB covers taking bribes: a member of a healthcare profession demands, accepts the promise of or accepts an advantage in return for unfairly favouring another person in competition, for example when prescribing medicines or medical aids or when referring patients. Section 299b StGB covers the mirror image, the person giving the advantage, for example from industry or pharmacies. The penalty for each is imprisonment of up to three years or a fine.

In particularly serious cases (Section 300 StGB), for example where the advantage is of great magnitude or the offender acts commercially or as a member of a gang, the range rises to three months to five years. Sensitive areas in practice are cooperation agreements, participation models, referral fees and dealings with pharmacies, medical supply stores or laboratories. The line between permissible cooperation and a criminal inducement is often a fine one.

In North Rhine-Westphalia (NRW), such allegations are usually investigated by the specialised public prosecution offices for economic crime. The Associations of SHI Physicians of Nordrhein and Westfalen-Lippe also maintain units for combating misconduct in healthcare (Section 81a of Book V of the Social Code, SGB V), which pass suspected cases on to the public prosecutor.

One set of facts, several proceedings

The same facts regularly trigger several proceedings here. Besides the criminal case, the doctor faces withdrawal of the contract-physician licence for gross breach of duty and revocation of the Approbation for unworthiness. Often disciplinary proceedings of the KV and professional-court proceedings of the chamber are added. The criminal findings affect all of these proceedings. How the criminal case ends therefore often also decides the doctor’s professional future.

Strategy and options

Defending early and in a coordinated way

From the outset we defend with all proceedings in view. Anything stated or admitted in the criminal proceedings can directly endanger the contract-physician licence and the Approbation. We therefore decide whether and how the client makes a statement only after inspecting the file.

Examining billing allegations in detail

Billing fraud is usually investigated by analysing large volumes of data. We check how individual fee items were assigned, how the fee schedules (EBM and GOÄ) are to be interpreted and whether services were rendered personally. This shows whether the alleged loss actually exists in that amount and whether intent can be proven.

Classifying cooperation arrangements

Under Sections 299a and 299b StGB, the question is whether the preference in competition is unfair. We work out whether there is a permissible, transparent cooperation or a criminal inducement. This distinction leaves the defence considerable room.

Making good the loss

Repayment and restitution reduce the sentence. At the same time they support the arguments against withdrawal of the licence and a finding of unworthiness. Where possible, we aim for a discontinuation or a lesser charge.

Dealing with searches and seizures

These proceedings often begin with a search of the practice and the seizure of patient records and IT. We examine whether these measures were lawful and make sure that confidentiality towards uninvolved patients is preserved. A search is frequently followed by an asset freeze; the fee accounts are then blocked while staff and rent continue to be due.

Prospects and risks

Both in billing fraud cases (calculation of the loss, intent) and in corruption cases (distinguishing permissible cooperation) there are genuine starting points for the defence. A defence coordinated early on can limit the professional consequences. Where there is systematic false billing or clear payment for referrals, however, imprisonment, withdrawal of the licence and revocation of the Approbation can all follow at once.

Frequently asked questions

When does cooperation with a pharmacy or laboratory become a criminal offence?

Transparent cooperation in which services and remuneration are in reasonable proportion is permitted. It becomes a criminal offence when an advantage is granted for unfairly steering patients or prescriptions. The boundary is fluid and should be checked in advance.

Does a billing error already lead to a conviction?

No. Fraud requires intent and financial loss. Negligent billing errors are not fraud, but can have fee-related consequences such as repayment claims.

Can I keep my Approbation despite a conviction?

That is possible. Revocation requires unworthiness or unreliability and a separate assessment by the authority. The nature and extent of the offence and the level of the sentence carry great weight in that assessment, which is one more reason to keep them in view during the criminal proceedings.

Nationwide representation

We defend doctors throughout Germany against allegations of billing fraud and corruption in healthcare, in the criminal proceedings and with a view to the contract-physician licence, the Approbation and chamber proceedings. Related topic: professional court for the healthcare professions.

This overview is general in nature and does not replace advice in an individual case.

Attorney Philip Bafteh

Written by attorney Philip Bafteh, criminal defense attorney in Bonn. Philip Bafteh publishes regularly on criminal and commercial law and defends accused persons in investigative and trial proceedings.

More about the attorney →

Last updated: November 2026

Free Initial Assessment

Have you received a summons or are you under investigation? Call us. The first assessment by phone is free for up to 10 minutes.

+49 228 504 463 36