Withdrawal of Statutory Health Insurance Accreditation: criminal defence in Bonn

Legal Basis
§ 95 Abs. 6 SGB V
Sentencing Range
Full withdrawal of the licence, or withdrawal of half or a quarter of it
Summary
Withdrawal of the contract-physician licence, mainly for a gross breach of contract-physician duties.

Withdrawal of the contract-physician licence (Zulassung) under Section 95(6) of Book V of the Social Code (SGB V) is the harshest response available in contract-physician law. It ends participation in the care of statutory health insurance patients and as a rule deprives the practice of most of its income. In practice the main ground is a gross breach of contract-physician duties. The admission committee decides on withdrawal, and on appeal the appeals committee; after that, legal recourse lies to the social courts. We defend doctors in these proceedings.

What does withdrawal of the licence mean?

The licence entitles and obliges the doctor to treat statutory health insurance patients and to bill through the Association of SHI Physicians (KV). Under the first sentence of Section 95(6) SGB V, it must be withdrawn if its requirements are not or no longer met, if the doctor does not take up or no longer carries on the activity, or if he or she grossly breaches contract-physician duties. Withdrawal is not a punishment. Its purpose is to protect the functioning of contract-physician care. For those affected, their livelihood is nonetheless at stake.

When is a breach “gross”?

A breach is gross if it has damaged the trust between the doctor and the institutions of contract-physician care so lastingly that they can no longer reasonably be expected to continue working with the doctor. Typical situations are:

  • systematic false billing and billing for services not rendered,
  • serious, repeated breaches of billing and documentation duties,
  • persistent inefficiency despite earlier measures,
  • substantial breaches of core duties of care such as presence or emergency service.

The committees decide on the basis of an overall assessment. This includes the question whether the doctor has restored trust through good conduct up to the last administrative decision, that is, up to the decision of the appeals committee.

Procedure and legal protection

At first instance the admission committee decides. The doctor and the other parties to the proceedings can appeal its decision to the appeals committee; the appeal has suspensive effect (Section 96(4) SGB V). The doctor can challenge the decision of the appeals committee before the social court, and on further appeal the state social court decides. In North Rhine-Westphalia (NRW) the admission and appeals committees are based at the KV Nordrhein and the KV Westfalen-Lippe; the appellate court is the State Social Court of NRW.

If the appeals committee orders immediate enforcement, participation in care ends at once, although the main proceedings are still pending.

Distinction from disciplinary proceedings and efficiency reviews

Less drastic are the disciplinary proceedings of the KV (Section 81 SGB V), which can extend to suspension of the licence, and the efficiency review with fee reductions and recourse claims. Such proceedings often precede a withdrawal, and their results feed into the overall assessment.

Strategy and options

Challenging grossness and the overall assessment

Not every breach of duty is gross. We examine whether the relationship of trust really cannot be restored, and we put individual incidents into context instead of letting them be condensed into an overall picture.

Proving good conduct

Because the relevant point in time is the last administrative decision, what has changed since the allegation counts: corrected procedures in the practice, quarters without objections, repayments. We document this for the appeals committee.

Partial instead of full withdrawal

If there is a gross breach of duty, the licence must be withdrawn. The committee has no discretion to refrain from withdrawal altogether. It can, however, decide to withdraw half or a quarter of the licence instead of the whole (second sentence of Section 95(6) SGB V). We set out why such a partial withdrawal is sufficient and challenge errors in that decision.

Interim relief against immediate enforcement

Against immediate enforcement we apply to the social court to restore the suspensive effect (Section 86b(1) of the Social Courts Act, SGG). This is the only way for the practice to continue operating for the time being while the proceedings are pending.

Coordination with criminal and Approbation proceedings

Billing allegations often lead to criminal proceedings and put the licence to practise medicine (Approbation) at risk. Criminal findings feed directly into the assessment under contract-physician law. That is why we coordinate the defence across all proceedings.

Prospects and risks

The requirements for a gross breach are high. With documented good conduct and a careful response to each individual allegation, withdrawal can in some cases be averted or limited to part of the licence. Where systematic false billing is proven, on the other hand, full withdrawal is a realistic scenario, often accompanied by criminal proceedings and revocation of the Approbation.

Frequently asked questions

If I lose my licence, do I also lose my Approbation?

Not automatically. The contract-physician licence and the Approbation (Federal Medical Practitioners Act) belong to different areas of law. The same facts can, however, trigger both proceedings.

Can I keep working while I challenge the decision?

As long as the appeal to the appeals committee or an action against its decision is pending, the suspensive effect generally applies. If immediate enforcement has been ordered, an urgent application is needed to continue working for the time being.

Can I get the licence back later?

A new licence is possible in principle once the grounds for withdrawal have ceased to exist. In practice this requires a longer period without any objections.

Nationwide representation

We defend contract physicians throughout Germany in withdrawal proceedings, before the admission and appeals committees, in interim relief proceedings and before the social courts. Related topics: billing fraud and corruption in healthcare and revocation and suspension of the Approbation.

This overview is general in nature and does not replace advice in an individual case. Decisive are Section 95 SGB V and the decisions of the competent committees.

Attorney Philip Bafteh

Written by attorney Philip Bafteh, criminal defense attorney in Bonn. Philip Bafteh publishes regularly on criminal and commercial law and defends accused persons in investigative and trial proceedings.

More about the attorney →

Last updated: November 2026

Free Initial Assessment

Have you received a summons or are you under investigation? Call us. The first assessment by phone is free for up to 10 minutes.

+49 228 504 463 36