Professional Tribunals for Health Professions: criminal defence in Bonn

Legal Basis
§§ 58e, 59 ff. HeilBerG NRW
Sentencing Range
Reprimand with a fine of up to €10,000; in professional-court proceedings a fine of up to €100,000 (HeilBerG NRW)
Summary
Sanctioning of professional-duty breaches by the chamber (reprimand) and the professional court.

Doctors, dentists, pharmacists and psychotherapists are subject to the professional supervision of their chamber. Minor breaches of professional duties are sanctioned by the chamber board with a reprimand, which under Section 58e of the NRW Healthcare Professions Act (HeilBerG NRW) it may combine with an administrative fine of up to €10,000. Those affected can apply for a review by the professional court within one month. Serious breaches lead to formal professional-court proceedings, which in the most extreme case can end with a finding that the person is unworthy to practise the profession. We represent members of the healthcare professions throughout Germany in both types of proceedings.

The system of professional sanctions in the healthcare professions

Practice in the academic healthcare professions is governed by the healthcare professions and chamber acts of the federal states and by the professional codes of the chambers. The system is similar throughout Germany; we explain it using the example of North Rhine-Westphalia (HeilBerG NRW). Breaches of professional duties can be sanctioned, for example breaches of medical confidentiality, of the rules on advertising and cooperation, of documentation or continuing-education duties, or of the requirement to provide objective information. The law provides for a graduated system:

  • a formal warning (Abmahnung) by the president of the chamber (Section 58e(6) HeilBerG NRW) as the mildest response,
  • a reprimand (Rüge) by the chamber board (Section 58e HeilBerG NRW) as the intermediate step,
  • formal professional-court proceedings (Sections 59 et seq. HeilBerG NRW) before the professional court for the healthcare professions for more serious breaches.

The reprimand by the chamber board (Section 58e HeilBerG NRW)

The chamber board may reprimand members for a professional offence where fault is minor and an application to open professional-court proceedings does not appear necessary (Section 58e(1) HeilBerG NRW). The reprimand may be combined with an administrative fine of up to €10,000 (Section 58e(3)). In addition, or on its own, the reprimand may carry the condition to attend a specified quality-assurance training course at the member’s own expense.

A reprimand is more than a formality. It officially establishes a professional offence, goes on record and can be taken into account against the person concerned in later proceedings. Anyone who accepts it allows that finding to become final.

Application for review by the professional court

Members can apply for a decision of the professional court within one month of service of the reprimand (Section 58e(4) HeilBerG NRW), in writing or by declaration recorded at the professional court for the healthcare professions. If the decision lacks proper instructions on the available remedy, the time limit only starts once the chamber has provided them.

The rules of formal professional-court proceedings apply accordingly to the review (Section 58e(5)). The decision must be set aside insofar as the application is well founded. The proceedings are discontinued if the chamber board withdraws the reprimand, the application is withdrawn or there is a procedural bar. Often this is the first time an independent body looks at the allegation. The court can set the reprimand aside in whole or in part.

Formal professional-court proceedings

For more serious or repeated breaches, the chamber board applies to open professional-court proceedings. Each federal state has its own professional courts for the healthcare professions. In North Rhine-Westphalia they are attached to the administrative courts of Cologne (Nordrhein) and Münster (Westfalen-Lippe) (Section 61(1) HeilBerG NRW). Appeals go to the State Professional Court for the Healthcare Professions at the Higher Administrative Court in Münster (Section 61(2)). At first instance a chamber of one professional judge presiding and two lay members from the accused person’s profession decides (Section 62(1)).

Section 60 HeilBerG NRW lists the following professional-court measures: a reprimand (Verweis), withdrawal of the right to stand for election to the chamber’s bodies, attendance at a specified training course at one’s own expense, a fine of up to €100,000 and, as the most severe measure, a finding of unworthiness to practise the profession. In special cases publication of the decision may also be ordered. A finding of unworthiness can pave the way to revocation of the licence to practise medicine (Approbation).

Strategy and options

Meeting the deadline

The one-month period for the review is short. We first check service and the instructions on remedies, since errors there postpone the start of the period. We file the application before the deadline expires and submit the grounds after inspecting the file.

Disputing the professional offence and fault

Not every allegation holds up. We check whether a professional duty was breached at all, whether the facts are proven and whether there is fault. Especially in matters of advertising, cooperation and billing, the legal position is often less clear than the decision suggests.

Challenging the amount of the fine

Even if there was a breach, the amount of the fine must be measured against the standard of minor fault. We bring out mitigating circumstances and work towards a reduction or a reprimand without a fine.

Keeping criminal and Approbation law in view

Professional proceedings often run alongside criminal or administrative-offence proceedings or a threatened revocation of the Approbation. An ill-considered statement in one set of proceedings can cause harm in another. We therefore keep all proceedings in view at the same time.

Avoiding escalation

The aim is usually to keep the matter at the reprimand stage and avoid formal professional-court proceedings. An objective statement to the chamber board supported by reliable documents is the most likely way to achieve this.

Which professions are covered?

The professional jurisdiction for the healthcare professions covers the chamber professions, in particular doctors, dentists, pharmacists, psychotherapists and veterinarians. North Rhine-Westphalia has two medical chambers: the Ärztekammer Nordrhein based in Düsseldorf and the Ärztekammer Westfalen-Lippe based in Münster. Special rules apply to members who are civil servants; a reprimand is excluded for them insofar as they have breached their duties as civil servants.

Frequently asked questions

Do I simply have to accept a reprimand?

No. You can apply for a review by the professional court within one month of receiving the decision. If you miss the deadline, the reprimand becomes final.

Is a reprimand the same as a criminal penalty?

No. A reprimand is a professional-law measure of the chamber, not a criminal sentence. It can, however, be combined with a fine and have professional consequences.

What is the worst that can happen?

In formal professional-court proceedings, the range extends to a fine of up to €100,000 and a finding of unworthiness, which can lead to revocation of the Approbation.

Nationwide representation

We represent doctors and other healthcare professionals throughout Germany in review proceedings and in formal proceedings before the professional courts for the healthcare professions of the federal states, from meeting the deadline and inspecting the file to the hearing. Related topics: disciplinary proceedings of the Association of SHI Physicians and revocation and suspension of the Approbation.

This overview is general in nature and does not replace advice in an individual case. Professional law for the healthcare professions is state law; the section references follow the example of North Rhine-Westphalia, but the system is comparable in the other federal states.

Attorney Philip Bafteh

Written by attorney Philip Bafteh, criminal defense attorney in Bonn. Philip Bafteh publishes regularly on criminal and commercial law and defends accused persons in investigative and trial proceedings.

More about the attorney →

Last updated: November 2026

Free Initial Assessment

Have you received a summons or are you under investigation? Call us. The first assessment by phone is free for up to 10 minutes.

+49 228 504 463 36