Theft with Force to Retain Stolen Goods: criminal defence in Bonn

Legal Basis
§ 252 StGB
Sentencing Range
Imprisonment of not less than one year (as Section 249(1)), six months to five years in less serious cases
Summary
Using force against a person, or threatening imminent danger to life or limb, after being caught in the act of theft in order to keep the stolen property

Someone takes goods from a shop, the store detective stops them just past the till, there is a scuffle and the detective is pushed aside. At that moment a minor offence that would often end with a fine or a discontinuation becomes a serious one: theft with force to retain stolen goods (räuberischer Theft) under Section 252 of the German Criminal Code (StGB), which is punished in the same way as robbery. We defend people accused of this offence in Bonn and the surrounding region, and our first step is to check whether the narrow requirements of the provision are actually met.

What Section 252 StGB covers

Section 252 applies to a person who has already completed a theft and then uses force or threats in order to keep what was taken. The wording is short: whoever, when caught in the act of theft, uses force against a person or threatens imminent danger to life or limb in order to retain possession of the stolen property is to be punished as a robber. Violence used after the taking is thus treated in the same way as violence used to take something.

The difference from robbery (Robbery) under Section 249 lies in the order of events. In a robbery, force is the means of taking the item. In theft with force, the item has already been taken and the force serves to hold on to it. Both offences share the same high sentencing range.

Typical situations

Most cases arise from shoplifting. A store detective or an employee holds on to the suspect after the checkout, and the suspect pulls free, shoves, lashes out or makes threats. Other cases involve a pickpocket who is chased and caught by the victim, or a burglar who is surprised by the occupier. Many suspects are young people, in which case the youth court (Jugendgericht) decides and the sanctions of the Youth Courts Act apply.

Anyone who catches a shoplifter in the act may detain them until the police arrive (Section 127(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, StPO). Being held by a store detective is therefore usually lawful, and a suspect can rarely rely on self-defence (Notwehr). The position is different if the detective goes clearly beyond what is necessary.

The elements of the offence

A completed theft

The theft must have been completed. If it went no further than an attempt, Section 252 does not apply, and depending on what happened, bodily harm or coercion alongside attempted theft may be considered instead. With small items slipped into clothing or a bag, however, the courts treat the theft as completed while the person is still inside the shop, before reaching the till.

Caught in the act

“In the act” (auf frischer Tat) requires a close connection in time and place with the theft. If the person has already got away with the goods and is confronted only later, Section 252 no longer applies. Being caught means being noticed. According to the case law, it is also enough if the person pre-empts discovery, for instance by attacking an approaching employee before being spoken to.

Force against a person or a qualified threat

The offence requires force against a person or a threat of imminent danger to life or limb. A hard shove, a blow or violently tearing free from a firm grip can be sufficient. Whether merely twisting away or pulling free with little effort is enough depends on the individual case, and in many proceedings this question decides the outcome. Threatening damage to property or a counter-complaint does not meet the threshold.

Intent to keep the goods or simply to escape

The person must act in order to retain possession of the stolen goods (Besitzerhaltungsabsicht). Someone who only pulls free to get away and avoid arrest acts with the intention of escaping. If the goods were dropped or no longer mattered at that moment, the required intent is missing. It is sufficient, however, if keeping the goods was one of several motives.

The court has to infer this state of mind from outward circumstances. Did the suspect keep hold of the goods during the scuffle? Were they dropped or handed back? Did the suspect run off empty-handed? In practice, this is the most important starting point for the defence.

Legal basis and penalties

Because the offender is punished “as a robber”, the range of Section 249(1) applies: imprisonment of not less than one year. Theft with force is therefore a serious criminal offence (Verbrechen), and an attempt is punishable. In less serious cases (minder schwerer Fall) the penalty under Section 249(2) is imprisonment from six months to five years. A less serious case may be considered where the force was slight, no one was injured and the goods were of little value.

Through this reference, the aggravated forms of robbery also apply. If the offender carries a weapon or another dangerous object, Section 250(1) provides for imprisonment of not less than three years, and if it is used, not less than five years under Section 250(2). A pocket knife in a jacket pocket can therefore raise the sentencing range considerably, even if it was never taken out. If the offender causes another person’s death at least through gross negligence, Section 251 applies, with life imprisonment or imprisonment of not less than ten years. Our article on aggravated robbery under Section 250 StGB explains these forms in more detail.

Distinguishing shoplifting and robbery

Without force against a person and without a qualified threat, the case remains one of theft under Section 242 StGB. Where shoplifting involves goods of low value, such proceedings often end with a discontinuation or a fine. The gap between the two charges is the gap between a less serious offence (Vergehen) and a felony with a minimum sentence of one year, which is why it is worth reconstructing exactly what happened at the till or the exit.

If force is already used to obtain the item, the offence is robbery. Someone who snatches a phone from a sales assistant’s hand and pushes them away in the process commits robbery, not theft with force. For the basic sentencing range this makes no difference, but it does matter when the individual elements are examined.

How proceedings begin and unfold

Usually the store detective or the shop manager calls the police. Officers establish identities, take statements from staff and ask for CCTV footage. Suspects without a fixed address in Germany may be arrested and brought before the remand judge. If you are arrested, our page on arrest sets out what to do.

The public prosecutor’s office (Staatsanwaltschaft) in Bonn then decides whether to charge theft with force or only theft and bodily harm. A penalty order (Penalty Order) is not available for a felony. If Section 252 is charged, the case will normally be heard by the court with lay judges (Schöffengericht) at the Bonn Local Court (Amtsgericht Bonn). If a prison sentence of more than four years is expected, the Bonn Regional Court (Landgericht Bonn) has jurisdiction.

Court-appointed defence

Because theft with force is a felony, defence is mandatory under Section 140(1) no. 2 StPO. This applies even if the court ultimately finds a less serious case. The accused may name a lawyer of their choice, who is then appointed as court-appointed defence counsel (Court-Appointed Defense Lawyer). This step is best taken before saying anything to the police.

Defence strategies

Everything starts with access to the case file. The key material is the statement of the store detective and any other witnesses, CCTV footage from the shop and, where relevant, medical certificates. Footage quite often tells a different story from the complaint, for example a scuffle in which the suspect clearly only wanted to get away, or goods that were already lying on the floor.

The legal questions follow from this. Had the theft been completed? Was there still a close connection with the theft? Did the physical contact reach the threshold of force against a person? Above all, was the suspect trying to keep the goods or only to avoid being detained? If the intent to keep the goods cannot be proved, what usually remains is theft, possibly together with bodily harm, which is a less serious offence with a very different sentencing range.

If the charge cannot be avoided, the focus shifts to a less serious case and a sentence that can be suspended on probation. An apology, compensation or victim-offender mediation (Täter-Opfer-Ausgleich) can count in mitigation. Such steps should be taken through your defence lawyer rather than on your own initiative.

Further consequences

A prison sentence of more than three months appears on the certificate of conduct (Führungszeugnis), even if it is suspended. Special rules apply to juveniles and young adults. Retailers usually issue a ban from the premises and frequently claim costs in civil law. For civil servants, a conviction for an intentional offence with a prison sentence of at least one year ends their civil service status by operation of law (Section 24 of the Civil Servants Status Act, BeamtStG), and that threshold is exactly the minimum sentence under Section 252.

If you are not a German citizen

If your German is not good enough, you are entitled to an interpreter free of charge, including for discussions with your defence lawyer (Section 187 of the Courts Constitution Act, GVG). If you have no fixed address in Germany, the prosecution may require a security payment and the appointment of a person authorised to accept service on your behalf (Sections 127a and 132 StPO). Because theft with force is a felony, however, suspects without a fixed residence face a real risk of pre-trial detention (Pre-Trial Detention). A conviction for a violent offence can affect a residence permit, a visa or a later application for naturalisation. Our page on visas, residence and criminal proceedings explains how these questions interact.

Frequently asked questions

I only pulled myself free. Is that already theft with force?

Not automatically. It depends on how much force you used and whether you were trying to keep the goods. Someone who pulls free to run away and leaves the goods behind will generally not fall under Section 252.

Does the value of the goods matter?

Not for the offence itself. Even where the goods are of little value, the minimum sentence of one year applies. A low value can, however, support a finding of a less serious case.

Will I get a court-appointed defense lawyer?

Yes. A felony charge makes defence mandatory under Section 140(1) no. 2 StPO, and you can choose the lawyer yourself.

Will I go to prison?

Not necessarily. Prison sentences of up to two years can be suspended on probation. Whether that happens depends on the facts, any previous convictions and your conduct after the offence.

If you are accused of theft with force, call us on +49 228 504 463 36. The first call of up to 10 minutes is free of charge.

This page gives general information and does not replace advice on your individual case.

Attorney Philip Bafteh

Written by attorney Philip Bafteh, criminal defense attorney in Bonn. Philip Bafteh publishes regularly on criminal and commercial law and defends accused persons in investigative and trial proceedings.

More about the attorney →

Last updated: November 2026

Free Initial Assessment

Have you received a summons or are you under investigation? Call us. The first assessment by phone is free for up to 10 minutes.

+49 228 504 463 36