- Legal Basis
- § 231 StGB
- Sentencing Range
- Imprisonment of up to three years or a fine (subsection 1)
- Summary
- Taking part in a brawl or in an attack by several people that results in a person's death or in grievous bodily harm
An argument outside a pub, in a club or after a party gets out of hand, and at the end someone is lying on the ground with serious injuries. Who threw which punch often cannot be established. Section 231 of the German Criminal Code (StGB) was written for exactly this situation: taking part in the brawl is itself an offence if it led to a serious outcome. We defend people accused of participation in a brawl (Beteiligung an einer Schlägerei) in Bonn and the surrounding region, and the first thing we check is whether the requirements of this unusual provision are met at all.
What Section 231 StGB covers
The provision responds to a problem of proof. In group fights it is often impossible to show who caused the fatal or serious injury. At the same time, brawls are dangerous for everyone involved and for bystanders. The law therefore punishes anyone who takes part in a brawl or in an attack carried out by several people if the brawl or attack causes a person’s death or grievous bodily harm within the meaning of Section 226 StGB.
A brawl (Schlägerei) is a confrontation involving mutual physical violence in which at least three people actively take part. An attack by several people (Angriff mehrerer) exists where at least two people act together with hostile intent against another person’s body. A participant is someone who is present and contributes physically or psychologically, by hitting, holding someone down, or egging the others on and backing them up. Someone who only watches is not a participant.
The serious outcome as an objective condition of liability
Without a death or grievous bodily harm, there is no liability under Section 231. Grievous bodily harm means the consequences listed in Section 226 StGB, for example loss of sight in one eye, loss or permanent loss of use of an important limb, considerable permanent disfigurement or paralysis. A cut, a broken nose or concussion will generally not be enough, however distressing they are for the injured person.
The serious outcome is what German law calls an objective condition of liability (objektive Bedingung der Strafbarkeit). It must have been caused by the brawl or attack, but not necessarily by the individual accused. Intent or negligence with regard to that outcome is not required. This is what makes the provision so harsh: someone who only threw a light punch can be convicted because of a serious injury that a third person inflicted. According to the case law, it may even be enough that the person left the brawl before the serious outcome occurred. The injured person may be a bystander or one of the participants.
On the other hand, the serious outcome must be established with certainty and must actually stem from the brawl. Whether an injury is permanent within the meaning of Section 226 can often only be assessed medically after several months. This is one point where the defence can engage, for example by putting its own questions to the forensic medical expert.
Legal basis and penalties
Participation in a brawl carries imprisonment of up to three years or a fine. It is a less serious offence (Vergehen), and an attempt is not punishable. Under Section 231(2), a person who took part in the brawl or attack is not liable if he or she cannot be blamed for taking part.
Participation without blame (subsection 2)
Subsection 2 mainly protects people who are drawn into the confrontation. Typical examples are the person attacked who defends himself in self-defence (Notwehr), someone who comes to the aid of a person being attacked, and someone who tries to separate the participants. They cannot be blamed for taking part. The courts look at the person’s participation as a whole. Anyone who initially acts lawfully but then carries on fighting beyond what is needed for defence can no longer rely on subsection 2.
Relationship to Sections 223 and 224 StGB
Section 231 applies alongside the assault offences. If it can be proved that a participant hit or kicked someone, he will also be prosecuted for bodily harm under Section 223, or for dangerous bodily harm under Section 224 if he acted jointly with others or used a dangerous object. In group fights the allegation of joint commission is never far away. If the serious outcome itself can be attributed to the participant, grievous bodily harm under Section 226 or, if the victim died, bodily harm resulting in death under Section 227 come into question, and these carry much heavier sentences. In practice, investigations therefore usually cover several offences at once. Section 231 remains as a fallback where the accused’s own contribution to the serious outcome cannot be proved.
Typical situations
Common cases include fights between groups in nightlife areas, outside clubs, at bus and tram stops, at funfairs and during carnival. Alcohol is often involved. If intoxication is so severe that criminal responsibility is in doubt, the intoxication offence (Vollrausch) under Section 323a StGB may apply. Other cases involve disputes between acquaintances, family rows with several people involved or clashes between groups of football supporters. If a larger crowd gets drawn in, investigators will also consider breach of the public peace.
How proceedings begin and unfold
The police usually arrive at a confused scene. They take personal details, question witnesses and secure any CCTV footage or mobile phone videos. In Bonn, the Bonn police headquarters (Polizeipräsidium Bonn) investigates. Where someone’s life is in danger or a person has died, the investigation will usually start as a homicide inquiry, and arrests and pre-trial detention (Pre-Trial Detention) are possible.
The evidence in brawl cases is typically difficult. Witnesses saw events from different angles, often after drinking and in a state of great agitation. Their accounts contradict each other, and they are frequently participants themselves with interests of their own. In addition, there is the pattern of injuries, forensic medical reports and traces on clothing and shoes.
Once the investigation is complete, the public prosecutor’s office (Staatsanwaltschaft) in Bonn decides whether to drop the case, apply for a penalty order (Penalty Order) or bring charges. If the case is limited to Section 231, the Bonn Local Court (Amtsgericht Bonn) will normally hear it. If grievous bodily harm, bodily harm resulting in death or a homicide offence is charged as well, the court with lay judges (Schöffengericht) or the Bonn Regional Court (Landgericht Bonn) may have jurisdiction, depending on the charge and the expected sentence.
Defence strategies
The first question is whether there was a brawl or an attack by several people at all. If only two people were fighting and others merely looked on, Section 231 does not apply. The second question concerns the client’s own role. Was he present and did he take part, or did he only stand by, try to calm things down or pull a friend out of the crowd?
Then there is the serious outcome. Is the injury really permanent within the meaning of Section 226, and does it stem from the brawl or from something that happened before or afterwards? In cases of self-defence or defence of others, it is necessary to establish carefully who attacked whom and how events developed. Our glossary explains the principles of self-defence.
Until the file is available, suspects should not make any statement. After brawls in particular, people often try to clear themselves with an early account and, without meaning to, provide the very proof that they were present and involved. Agreeing with others involved on what “really happened” is risky as well.
Further consequences
Injured parties often claim damages and compensation for pain and suffering, either in civil proceedings or within the criminal case through the adhesion procedure (Adhäsionsverfahren). Victim-offender mediation (Täter-Opfer-Ausgleich) or making amends can reduce the sentence. A fine of no more than 90 daily rates is generally not shown on a certificate of conduct (Führungszeugnis), provided there is no other entry. For civil servants and soldiers, a conviction for a violent offence can lead to disciplinary proceedings. Firearms licences may also be affected.
If you are not a German citizen
If your German is not good enough, you are entitled to an interpreter free of charge, including for discussions with your defence lawyer (Section 187 of the Courts Constitution Act, GVG). If you have no fixed address in Germany, the prosecution may require a security payment and the appointment of a person authorised to accept service of documents on your behalf (Sections 127a and 132 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, StPO). Where someone was seriously injured, the risk of pre-trial detention is higher for suspects without a fixed residence. A conviction for a violent offence can also affect your residence permit, visa or a later application for naturalisation. Our page on visas, residence and criminal proceedings explains how these questions interact.
Frequently asked questions
I did not seriously injure anyone. Can I still be convicted?
Yes. Under Section 231 it is enough that you took part in the brawl and that someone was killed or seriously injured as a result of it. Who caused the injury does not matter for this offence.
What if I was only defending myself?
Someone who fends off an attack or helps another person under attack may not be liable under Section 231(2). The question is whether your participation as a whole was justified and whether defence turned into fighting of your own.
Is a broken nose a serious outcome?
As a rule, no. The provision refers to death or the permanent consequences listed in Section 226, such as loss of sight in one eye, considerable permanent disfigurement or paralysis.
Am I a participant if I only watched?
No. Only someone who takes part physically or actively backs up the others is a participant. Watching is not enough.
If you are accused of participation in a brawl, call us on +49 228 504 463 36. The first call of up to 10 minutes is free of charge.
This page gives general information and does not replace advice on your individual case.
What to do now
Emergency help: Pre-trial detention: act fast, Police summons: how to respond
Court: Proceedings at Bonn Local Court
Emergency help: Summons, House search, Detention
Local defense: Criminal defense attorney in Bonn, Cologne, All offences
Written by attorney Philip Bafteh, criminal defense attorney in Bonn. Philip Bafteh publishes regularly on criminal and commercial law and defends accused persons in investigative and trial proceedings.
More about the attorney →Last updated: November 2026
Free Initial Assessment
Have you received a summons or are you under investigation? Call us. The first assessment by phone is free for up to 10 minutes.
+49 228 504 463 36