Failure to pay maintenance (Section 170 StGB): the police questionnaire

The letter comes from the police, often months after the maintenance advance office (Unterhaltsvorschusskasse) sent its last demand for payment. Inside is a written questionnaire (Anhörungsbogen) concerning failure to pay maintenance, with boxes for occupation, employer, monthly net income, maintenance payments and an empty space for a ‘statement on the matter’. Many people fill it in conscientiously, enclose their payslips and explain why they could not pay. That is understandable. In cases under Section 170 of the German Criminal Code (Strafgesetzbuch, StGB), however, it is often the step that turns a weak suspicion into a documented allegation. What Section 170 StGB requires, when someone is able to pay and how a dismissal against payment works is explained on our page on failure to pay maintenance (Section 170 StGB). This article deals only with the questionnaire and what comes before it.

What you must disclose and what you need not

The only mandatory details concern your identity. Under Section 111 of the Regulatory Offences Act (OWiG) you must correctly state your first name, surname and birth name, place and date of birth, marital status, occupation, place of residence, address and nationality. Nothing more. Your employer, your income, maintenance payments and everything else relating to the allegation concern the matter itself. You do not have to say anything about it, either in writing or in an interview.

Nor are you obliged to return the questionnaire. There is no statutory deadline. If there is no reply, the police pass the file to the public prosecutor, who then decides without your input. If you instruct defence counsel, have them inform the police. Counsel will apply for access to the file and respond once they know its contents. More on the questionnaire in general in our glossary.

Why the income question cuts both ways here

For most allegations the questionnaire asks about income in order to set the amount of a daily rate (Tagessatz). If you give no details, the court may estimate your income (Section 40(3) StGB). Many people therefore prefer to state a low income to keep a possible fine small.

Under Section 170 StGB, however, income is also the core of the allegation. Only someone who was able to pay, or could have been with reasonable effort, commits the offence. Every statement about income during the relevant period is therefore also a statement about whether you could pay. Anyone who writes that he earned 1,900 euros net but had to service loans gives the prosecutor the figure needed to establish ability to pay. Whether loan repayments take priority over child maintenance is a legal question that is often answered against the person paying.

Then there is the time period. The questionnaire usually asks about current income. The allegation, though, concerns a past period, sometimes several years. A figure for today’s salary is easily read in the file as evidence about the past, even though the situation back then was quite different.

Typical statements that do harm

From case files we know a number of explanations that are well meant and achieve the opposite:

  • ‘I’ll pay again once I’m allowed to see my child.’ Maintenance and contact are not legally linked. The sentence proves that payment was deliberately withheld.
  • ‘I had some jobs in between, but only small ones.’ This admits income of unknown amount. The prosecutor will ask.
  • ‘I knew I had to pay, but I couldn’t.’ The first half proves intent with regard to the maintenance obligation.
  • ‘My new partner earns well.’ Under family law this can affect ability to pay, and it raises questions nobody would have asked without it.

If what you say in the questionnaire contradicts earlier statements to the youth welfare office (Jugendamt) or the family court, there is an additional problem. Anyone who stated too low an income there in order to pay less exposes himself to suspicion of fraud.

Information requested by the maintenance advance office

The maintenance advance office has often requested information before the complaint was made. The parent with whom the child does not live is in principle obliged to provide it under Section 6(1) of the Maintenance Advance Act (Unterhaltsvorschussgesetz, UVG). In particular, that parent must show that he or she is meeting the heightened maintenance obligation towards a minor. Less well known is Section 6(3) UVG: questions whose answers would expose you to the risk of criminal prosecution may be refused. Once the office announces a criminal complaint, or has already made one, this becomes an important point.

In these cases the prosecutor regularly requests the maintenance advance office’s file. Whatever you wrote there, the prosecutor reads too. The office can also ask employers, social benefit agencies and the tax office for information and, under certain conditions, have account data retrieved (Section 6(2), (5) and (6) UVG). Remaining silent does not keep all information out. It does prevent you from supplying the incriminating interpretation yourself.

What makes sense instead

As a rule we recommend returning the questionnaire with your personal details only, or having defence counsel answer it. After access to the case file we know which period is alleged, what income data the prosecutor already has and which calculation the complaint relies on. Only then do we decide whether a written statement makes sense and what it should contain.

Use the time until then. Collect documents for the whole period: decisions from the job centre or the employment agency, sick notes, notices of dismissal, job applications and rejections, bank statements showing all maintenance payments. And if at all possible, start paying regularly again, even a small amount. For a later dismissal under Section 153a of the Code of Criminal Procedure (StPO), what counts most is whether payments will be made in future. An instalment agreement with the maintenance advance office can help. It should not, however, contain any statements about the past beyond what is necessary.

If a penalty order arrives instead

If the questionnaire goes unanswered, the prosecutor quite often applies for a penalty order (Penalty Order). Ability to pay is then frequently inferred solely from the maintenance order or the maintenance advance office’s calculation. You can lodge an objection within two weeks of service (Section 410 StPO). In maintenance cases an objection often has good prospects, because the criminal court must establish ability to pay for itself. More in our article on objecting to a penalty order.

If you are not a German citizen

Maintenance obligations under German law also apply if you or your child are foreign nationals and the child lives in Germany. If you have moved abroad, the maintenance advance office can still pursue its claim and the criminal case can continue; the prosecutor may require you to appoint a person in Germany to accept service (Section 132 StPO). The questionnaire is in German, and you are entitled to an interpreter free of charge in any interview or hearing. A conviction is reported to the immigration office; a dismissal against payment is not a conviction. More in our article on criminal proceedings and your residence status.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to return the questionnaire at all?

No, there is no obligation. If you do return it, only your personal details are mandatory, including your occupation. You do not have to write anything about the allegation.

May I refuse to give information to the maintenance advance office?

In principle you are obliged to provide it. Under Section 6(3) UVG you may, however, refuse to answer questions that would expose you to the risk of criminal prosecution. How far that goes should be checked in your individual case.

Should I enclose my payslips?

Not without checking. Payslips can help if your income was below the amount you are entitled to keep for yourself. They can equally prove that you were able to pay. That can only be judged once it is clear which period is alleged.

You can reach us on +49 228 504 463 36. This article gives general information and does not replace advice on your individual case.

Share this post:

Helpful pages

Attorney Philip Bafteh

Written by attorney Philip Bafteh, criminal defense attorney in Bonn. Philip Bafteh publishes regularly on criminal and commercial law and defends accused persons in investigative and trial proceedings.

More about the attorney →

Last updated: July 2026

Questions about this topic?

If you are personally affected or need legal advice, please get in touch. An initial phone consultation of up to 10 minutes is free of charge.

Contact