Failure to Pay Maintenance: criminal defence in Bonn

Legal Basis
§ 170 StGB
Sentencing Range
Up to 3 years imprisonment or a fine (subsection 1), up to 5 years or a fine (subsection 2)
Summary
Evading a statutory maintenance obligation so that the entitled person's basic needs are at risk, or would be at risk without help from others.

Many parents who owe maintenance only realise that their arrears can have criminal consequences when a police summons arrives. Section 170 of the German Criminal Code (Strafgesetzbuch, StGB) makes it an offence to evade a statutory maintenance obligation. The report frequently comes not from the other parent but from a public body that has stepped in to cover the missing payments. We defend people in these proceedings in Bonn and the surrounding area and coordinate the defence with any maintenance case pending before the family court (Familiengericht).

What Section 170 StGB requires

Under Section 170(1) StGB, a person commits an offence if they evade a statutory maintenance obligation so that the basic needs of the person entitled are at risk, or would be at risk without help from others. The penalty is imprisonment of up to three years or a fine. No criminal complaint (Strafantrag) is needed; the public prosecutor (Staatsanwaltschaft) investigates of its own motion.

A statutory maintenance obligation

This means obligations arising directly from statute, above all towards children (Sections 1601 et seq. of the Civil Code, BGB), towards spouses and former spouses, and under Section 1615l BGB towards an unmarried parent who looks after the couple’s child. Maintenance agreed purely by contract is not enough. Whether there is an enforceable maintenance order is not decisive for criminal liability. Equally, such an order does not bind the criminal court: it must establish for itself whether the obligation existed and how much was owed.

Ability to pay

Only someone who could pay can evade payment. Liability therefore requires that the person was able to pay, or would have been with reasonable effort. Towards minor children, Section 1603(2) BGB requires parents to use all available means equally for themselves and their children. That includes a duty to look for adequately paid work, known as the obligation to earn (Erwerbsobliegenheit). Someone who turns down reasonable work or gives up a job without good reason can evade their obligation even if they in fact have no income.

Risk to basic needs

The basic needs of the entitled person must be at risk, or would be at risk without help from others. Many prosecutions rely on the second alternative. If the advance maintenance office (Unterhaltsvorschusskasse) pays, the job centre provides basic income support (Grundsicherungsgeld) or grandparents step in, the child’s needs are covered. The conduct remains punishable nonetheless, because those needs would be at risk without that help.

Intent

Only intentional conduct is punishable. The accused must at least have considered it possible that they owed maintenance and were able to pay. Someone who did not know they were a father, for instance, does not evade the obligation intentionally.

Maintenance for a pregnant woman (subsection 2)

Section 170(2) StGB deals with a special case. Anyone who owes maintenance to a pregnant woman, withholds it in a reprehensible manner and thereby causes the pregnancy to be terminated faces imprisonment of up to five years or a fine. There must be a causal link between withholding the maintenance and the termination, and the withholding must be reprehensible. Both have to be specifically proven.

How proceedings start

If one parent does not pay child maintenance, the other parent will often apply for advance maintenance payments (Unterhaltsvorschuss) from the youth welfare office (Jugendamt). Once these are paid, the child’s maintenance claim passes to the federal state up to the amount paid (Section 7 of the Advance Maintenance Act, UVG). The advance maintenance office then asks the parent to disclose income and assets and to pay. If that produces no result, it not infrequently files a criminal complaint. The job centre acts in a similar way: where it pays Grundsicherungsgeld to the child or the caring parent, maintenance claims pass to it under Section 33 of Book II of the Social Code (SGB II).

The complaint goes to the Bonn public prosecutor’s office. It will usually request the advance maintenance office’s records, such as decisions, payment statements and correspondence, and investigate the accused’s income, for example through employers, the pension insurance fund or account enquiries. The accused receives a police summons (Police Summons) or a questionnaire (Anhörungsbogen). The case quite often ends with a penalty order (Penalty Order) from the Bonn Local Court (Amtsgericht Bonn), against which an objection can be lodged within two weeks. If there is a trial, it is usually before a single criminal judge.

Prosecution becomes time-barred after five years (Section 78(3) no. 4 StGB). Because the evasion continues over a period of time, the prevailing view is that the limitation period only begins once that state of affairs ends.

Defence approaches

Ability to pay during the relevant period

The most important line of defence is usually ability to pay. The prosecution has to show for every month of the period alleged that the accused was able to pay. Illness, unemployment, prior debts or maintenance owed to other children reduce that ability. Family court calculations often work with notional income. In criminal proceedings that is not automatically sufficient. The criminal court must itself establish what income the accused could actually have earned, given their training, health and the state of the labour market.

Obligation to earn and job applications

Anyone who was unemployed should be able to show that they made serious efforts to find work. Applications and rejections, certificates from the employment agency or the job centre, medical certificates and evidence of further training all belong in the defence file. The more complete these records are, the harder it is to maintain that the accused avoided work.

Proof of payment

The arrears stated in the complaint do not always match the payments actually made. Payments made directly to the child or the other parent, agreed payments in kind, sums recovered through garnishment or payments to the advance maintenance office are not always fully recorded. Bank statements and transfer records for the entire period are therefore part of the defence.

Until the file has been inspected, the accused should say nothing about the allegation. Even a written statement to the advance maintenance office can later turn up in the criminal file.

Dismissal in return for payment

Section 153a(1), second sentence, no. 4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (StPO) expressly provides for a condition requiring the accused to meet maintenance obligations in a set amount. The deadline for this is at most one year. A condition to make good the damage is also possible, for example paying the arrears to the advance maintenance office in instalments. Once the conditions are met, the offence can no longer be prosecuted as a misdemeanour, and nothing is entered in the Federal Central Criminal Register. More on this on our page on discontinuation of proceedings and in the glossary under dismissal subject to conditions.

What matters most to the prosecutor is whether regular payments will be made in future. Anyone who resumes regular payments before first contact with the prosecutor, even if only in part, improves their position. If a suspended prison sentence is imposed, the court can direct the person to meet their maintenance obligations (Section 56c(2) no. 5 StGB). Breaching that direction can lead to the suspension being revoked.

The link with family court proceedings

Criminal and maintenance proceedings often run side by side. The family court decides how much maintenance is owed and for what period; the criminal court decides whether the accused evaded it in a punishable way. Neither court is bound by the other. What is said about income in the family proceedings can, however, end up in the criminal file, and vice versa. Statements in one set of proceedings should therefore be made with the other in mind. Where needed, we liaise with the lawyer handling the family case.

An application to vary the maintenance order because income has fallen does not automatically have retrospective effect in the criminal case. It can, however, indicate that the ability to pay was limited during the period in question. An instalment agreement with the advance maintenance office can also be used in the criminal proceedings.

Further consequences

A fine of no more than 90 daily rates does not appear on the certificate of conduct (Führungszeugnis) if it is the first entry, although it is recorded in the Federal Central Criminal Register. Anyone with previous convictions must expect an entry, and repeated convictions can lead to a prison sentence. The fine comes on top of the arrears, which remain owing and can be enforced through the civil courts. If the fine is not paid, imprisonment in default (Ersatzfreiheitsstrafe) may follow; since 2024 one day corresponds to two daily rates.

If you are not a German citizen

If your German is not good enough to follow the proceedings, you are entitled to an interpreter free of charge (Section 187 of the Courts Constitution Act, GVG), including for key documents. If you have no permanent address in Germany, the prosecution may ask for security (Sicherheitsleistung) and for you to appoint an agent to receive documents (Zustellungsbevollmächtigter) under Sections 127a and 132 StPO. A conviction can affect your residence status; see our page on visas, residence and criminal proceedings. Maintenance obligations owed under German law remain in place even if you live abroad.

Frequently asked questions

Am I committing an offence if I cannot pay maintenance because I am unemployed?

Not if you genuinely could not pay and made serious efforts to find work. Someone who turns down reasonable work, on the other hand, can commit the offence even without any income.

My child receives advance maintenance payments. Does that not mean their needs are covered?

It does, but that is no protection against prosecution. The statute expressly covers cases where basic needs are not at risk only because others have helped.

Is it enough to pay the arrears now?

Payment does not remove criminal liability retrospectively. It is, however, often the basis for dismissal under Section 153a StPO and it counts in sentencing.

Do I have to attend a police summons?

As an accused person, you are not obliged to attend the police interview or to make a statement. A written statement through a defence lawyer after inspecting the file is usually the better course.

If you have received a summons, a questionnaire or a penalty order for failure to pay maintenance, you can reach us on +49 228 504 463 36. An initial call of up to 10 minutes is free of charge.

This page gives general information and does not replace advice on your individual case.

Attorney Philip Bafteh

Written by attorney Philip Bafteh, criminal defense attorney in Bonn. Philip Bafteh publishes regularly on criminal and commercial law and defends accused persons in investigative and trial proceedings.

More about the attorney →

Last updated: November 2026

Free Initial Assessment

Have you received a summons or are you under investigation? Call us. The first assessment by phone is free for up to 10 minutes.

+49 228 504 463 36