Smuggling of Migrants: criminal defence in Bonn

Legal Basis
§§ 96, 97 AufenthG
Sentencing Range
Imprisonment of six months to ten years; in less serious cases up to five years or a fine (Section 96(1))
Summary
Inciting or assisting a foreign national's unlawful entry for a benefit, repeatedly or for several persons, or their unlawful stay for financial gain

A check on the motorway, at a station or at the airport, and passengers in the car without valid papers: this is how many cases of smuggling of migrants (Einschleusen von Ausländern) under Sections 96 and 97 of the German Residence Act (AufenthG) begin. For the driver, the check often ends with arrest by the Federal Police (Bundespolizei) and an appearance before a custody judge. The penalties are high, and anyone who is not a German citizen also risks their own right to stay. We defend people accused of this offence in Bonn and the surrounding region, including clients in custody, and from the outset we examine what investigators can actually prove.

What the offence covers

These provisions do not punish the foreign national who enters or stays unlawfully. That person’s liability is governed by Section 95 AufenthG; see our page on Residence Act offences. Section 96 targets the person who incites or assists them. What would ordinarily be mere participation in someone else’s offence becomes, under additional conditions, a separate and much more heavily punished offence.

Section 96(1), first sentence, covers two main groups:

  • Inciting or assisting unlawful entry, meaning entry without the required passport or residence title (Section 95(1) no. 3) or in breach of an entry and residence ban (Section 95(2) no. 1(a)). In addition, the helper must receive or be promised a benefit for it, or act repeatedly or for the benefit of several foreign nationals (no. 1).
  • Inciting or assisting unlawful residence, certain other breaches, or obtaining a residence title by giving false information. Here the helper must always receive or be promised a financial benefit (no. 2).

The benefit for assisting entry need not be money. Any improvement in the helper’s position to which they have no entitlement is enough. Under the second sentence of Section 96(1), it also makes no difference whether the person smuggled has committed an intentional unlawful act themselves. Someone who helps refugees, who are not themselves punishable because they are seeking asylum, can therefore still commit the offence. Section 96(4) extends the provision to unlawful entry into other EU member states, Schengen states and the United Kingdom, although for repeated or multiple assistance only where entry is by land.

Legal basis and penalties

Smuggling under Section 96(1) AufenthG is punishable by imprisonment of six months to ten years, or up to five years or a fine in less serious cases. Attempts are punishable (subsection 3).

Under Section 96(2), the minimum sentence is one year’s imprisonment if the offender acts on a commercial basis or as a member of a gang, carries a firearm during an unlawful entry or carries another weapon in order to use it, exposes the people being smuggled to life-threatening, inhuman or degrading treatment or the risk of serious harm to health, for example by transporting them in an overcrowded cargo space, or tries to evade a police check by driving in a grossly dangerous and reckless manner and thereby endangers others. The same applies where, in cases under no. 1, an unaccompanied, unmarried minor is helped to enter. These cases are felonies (Verbrechen).

Section 97 AufenthG contains the most serious forms. If smuggling causes another person’s death, the minimum sentence is five years; if death is caused at least recklessly, the penalty is life imprisonment or not less than ten years. Acting commercially as a member of a gang carries a minimum of three years. In less serious cases of these two variants, the minimum is one year.

Under Section 96(5) and Section 97(4), Section 74a StGB applies. Vehicles and other instruments of the offence can therefore, under certain conditions, be confiscated even if they belong to a third party, such as the registered keeper or a hire company. The limitation period for the basic offence is ten years.

Typical situations

Family members

Many cases involve people who want to bring relatives to Germany: a brother who was refused a visa, or parents waiting with acquaintances in a neighbouring country. The Residence Act has no exemption for relatives. Someone who brings a single relative across the border on one occasion and without any benefit does not commit the offence under Section 96(1) no. 1, however. What remains is aiding unlawful entry under Section 95, with a much lower penalty range. If several family members are brought together, such as a wife and children, the requirement of acting “for the benefit of several foreign nationals” is met even without any payment. Family and humanitarian motives must then be taken into account when deciding whether the case is less serious and when setting the sentence.

Drivers and transport

The allegation is very often directed at drivers. Some were recruited through social media or acquaintances for individual trips and are paid a fixed sum per journey. Others say they simply gave people a lift in return for petrol money without knowing anything about their papers. The key issue is intent: the driver must at least have considered it possible, and accepted, that the passengers lacked the required documents. Investigators rely on phone data, chat histories, payments, the route and the circumstances of the journey, such as passengers hidden in the vehicle or the absence of luggage.

Visas, invitations and sham arrangements

Anyone who, for payment, arranges false employment contracts, invitations, formal obligations to cover living costs (Verpflichtungserklärungen) or proof of accommodation so that a foreign national obtains a residence title may also be prosecuted under Section 96(1) no. 2. An allegation of forgery is often added.

Investigations by the Federal Police

In these cases the investigating authority is usually the Federal Police, which is responsible for border protection, federal railway premises and airports. In larger cases it works with police forces in other countries. Smuggling under Section 96(1), (2) and (4) and Section 97 is listed in Section 100a of the Code of Criminal Procedure (StPO), so telephone surveillance may be ordered where there is sufficient suspicion. The driver’s phone is routinely seized and analysed.

The Federal Police pass the case to the competent public prosecutor’s office (Staatsanwaltschaft). After an arrest at Cologne/Bonn Airport or at a land border, this is not always the office in Bonn. Depending on the expected sentence, charges are brought before a single judge or the lay judges’ court (Schöffengericht) at the Local Court (Amtsgericht) or before a criminal division of the Regional Court (Landgericht); in the Bonn district, that means the Bonn Local Court or the Bonn Regional Court.

Custody and court-appointed counsel

Anyone provisionally arrested at a check must be brought before a judge no later than the day after the arrest. Where the accused has no fixed residence in Germany, courts often assume a risk of absconding and issue an arrest warrant. Pre-trial detention (Pre-Trial Detention) is then subject to the principle of proportionality, and the grounds must be reviewed regularly. Less intrusive measures such as reporting conditions or a security payment can replace detention.

Once the accused is brought before a custody judge, defence by a lawyer is mandatory under Section 140(1) no. 4 StPO. The same applies if a felony is alleged or if the trial is expected before the lay judges’ court or the Regional Court. You can name a lawyer you trust to be appointed as your court-appointed defence counsel (Court-Appointed Defense Lawyer). It is advisable to do so before the court chooses someone for you.

Defence strategies

Intent is often at the centre of the case. Did the driver know the passengers had no papers? What was agreed before the journey, and what do the chats really show? A second line concerns the aggravating features. Whether a benefit was agreed, whether a mere share of fuel costs counts, whether several trips can be proved and whether there was a gang or commercial activity determines the sentencing range, the question of custody and which court hears the case.

The underlying act must also be examined: did the passengers really lack a valid residence title or visa, and which entry into which country is at issue? In family cases, establishing a less serious case is frequently decisive. Statements to the Federal Police should only be made after the file has been inspected, however much pressure the situation after an arrest creates.

If you are not a German citizen

For accused persons without German citizenship, the consequences are often more serious than the sentence itself. Under Section 54(2) no. 3 AufenthG, there is a serious public interest in expulsion (Ausweisungsinteresse) as soon as someone has committed or attempted an offence under Section 96 or 97 as principal or accomplice. A conviction is not required for this. A final conviction under Sections 96 or 97 to at least one year’s imprisonment or youth custody makes that interest particularly serious under Section 54(1) no. 1c. Renewing a residence permit or obtaining naturalisation becomes considerably more difficult. For EU citizens, stricter conditions apply before freedom of movement can be withdrawn, but it is not ruled out. Our page on visas, residence and criminal proceedings explains how the two areas interact.

You are entitled to an interpreter free of charge throughout the proceedings, including for meetings with your defence lawyer (Section 187 of the Courts Constitution Act, GVG). If you have no fixed address in Germany, you will usually have to appoint a person authorised to accept court documents on your behalf (Section 132 StPO). Because smuggling normally carries a prison sentence, the security payment procedure under Section 127a StPO, which only applies where no custodial sentence is expected, will rarely be available. Criminal defence and immigration advice should be coordinated from the start.

Frequently asked questions

I only brought my brother across the border. Is that smuggling?

Helping a single person once, without any benefit, is generally not smuggling under Section 96. It is still a punishable act of aiding unlawful entry. Taking several people with you meets the definition even without payment.

I did not know my passengers had no papers. What happens now?

Without intent there is no offence. Whether investigators assume intent depends on the circumstances of the journey and the data on your phone. Do not make any statement until your defence lawyer has seen the file.

Can my car be confiscated?

Yes. The vehicle is an instrument of the offence and can be confiscated, and under the conditions of Section 74a StGB even if it belongs to someone else.

Will I get a court-appointed defense lawyer?

Yes, if you are brought before a custody judge, if a felony is alleged or if the trial will take place before the lay judges’ court or the Regional Court. You can name the lawyer yourself.

If a family member has been arrested after a check, or you have received a summons from the Federal Police, call us on +49 228 504 463 36, also at night and at weekends. The first call of up to 10 minutes is free of charge.

This page gives general information and does not replace advice on your individual case.

Attorney Philip Bafteh

Written by attorney Philip Bafteh, criminal defense attorney in Bonn. Philip Bafteh publishes regularly on criminal and commercial law and defends accused persons in investigative and trial proceedings.

More about the attorney →

Last updated: November 2026

Free Initial Assessment

Have you received a summons or are you under investigation? Call us. The first assessment by phone is free for up to 10 minutes.

+49 228 504 463 36