Secret Audio Recordings: criminal defence in Bonn

Legal Basis
§ 201 StGB
Sentencing Range
Imprisonment of up to three years or a fine (subsections 1 and 2)
Summary
Recording another person's privately spoken words without authorisation, or using, passing on or publicly disclosing such a recording

A meeting with your manager, an argument with your partner, a police stop: a smartphone can record any of them in seconds. Secretly recording what someone else says can, however, lead to criminal proceedings for violating the confidentiality of the spoken word (Verletzung der Vertraulichkeit des Wortes) under Section 201 of the German Criminal Code (StGB). Often the allegation only surfaces once the recording is forwarded, produced in court or posted online. We defend people accused of this offence in Bonn and the surrounding region, and the first thing we check is whether the conversation was protected at all.

What Section 201 StGB protects

The provision protects a person’s right to decide whether their words reach only the person they are talking to or are preserved on a recording. Anyone speaking should be able to rely on their words being fleeting. Whether the content is secret, embarrassing or entirely trivial makes no difference.

The law protects words that are “not spoken publicly” (nichtöffentlich gesprochenes Wort). A statement is not public if it is not addressed to an open, indeterminate audience. A one-to-one conversation in an office, a phone call or a meeting in a small group will usually qualify. A speech at a rally or a talk open to anyone will not. One point surprises many people: taking part in the conversation does not entitle you to record it. The offence is aimed precisely at the participant who turns a passing remark into a permanent recording.

Only recording “without authorisation” (unbefugt) is an offence. The most common authorisation is consent. If you say openly that you are recording and the other person carries on talking, you can often rely on implied consent, although this depends on the circumstances.

The different forms of the offence

Section 201(1) no. 1 covers making the recording itself, which today almost always means using a phone. Under subsection (1) no. 2 it is equally an offence to use such a recording or make it available to a third party. Playing a secret recording to others, forwarding it by messenger or posting it in a group chat can therefore be punishable even if you did not make it yourself.

Subsection (2) adds two further variants. Under no. 1, it is an offence to listen in on words not intended for you using a listening device, such as a bug, a repurposed baby monitor or spyware installed on someone else’s phone. Under no. 2, it is an offence to disclose publicly, word for word or in substance, a conversation that was recorded or overheard without authorisation, for example on social media. This variant only applies if the disclosure is capable of harming another person’s legitimate interests, and it is not unlawful if made to safeguard an overriding public interest.

Video without sound is not covered by Section 201. Photographs and silent footage may fall under other provisions such as Section 201a StGB or the Art Copyright Act (KUG); see our page on the right to one’s own image. If a phone films with sound, however, the spoken words are recorded too.

Typical situations

Meetings with an employer

Appraisals, disciplinary meetings and the handing over of a dismissal letter are frequently recorded so that the employee has evidence later. The employer usually finds out when the recording is mentioned in unfair dismissal proceedings or starts circulating among colleagues. Besides the criminal case, summary dismissal is then often on the table, because a secret recording goes to the heart of the employment relationship.

Disputes with a partner or ex-partner

During separations and disputes over contact with children, phone calls and arguments are recorded to prove threats or insults. The motive is understandable, but the recording may still be an offence. Whether it can be justified in the particular case is discussed below.

Recording the police

Many people film police stops on their phones, usually with sound. Whether officers’ words during an operation count as not spoken publicly is disputed, and the case law is not consistent. Relevant factors include where the operation takes place, whether bystanders can hear, and whether the officers are addressing the person concerned or talking among themselves. An operation on an open street in front of onlookers points more strongly against confidentiality than a conversation in a flat or inside a patrol car. In practice, officers often seize the phone on the spot. If someone physically resists, an allegation of resisting law enforcement officers may follow as well.

Voice memos and automatic call recording

Phones record at the touch of a button, and some apps record every call automatically. Only intentional conduct is punishable. If you did not know the recording function was running, you lacked intent. That explanation must, however, be consistent with the technical data, because investigators will examine the device.

Legal basis and penalties

Offences under Section 201(1) and (2) are punishable by imprisonment of up to three years or a fine. If the offender is a public official (Amtsträger) or a person specially entrusted with public service duties, subsection (3) raises the maximum to five years or a fine. Attempts are punishable under subsection (4). The limitation period for prosecution is five years.

Criminal complaint required

Under Section 205(1) StGB, offences under Section 201(1) and (2) are prosecuted only if the person affected files a criminal complaint (Strafantrag). Unlike some neighbouring offences, the prosecution cannot override this requirement by declaring a special public interest. The complaint must be made within three months of the person learning of the offence and the identity of the offender (Section 77b StGB), and it can be withdrawn at any point until the case is finally concluded. The requirement does not apply to officials under subsection (3).

Confiscation of the device

Section 201(5) allows the court to confiscate recording media and listening devices used by the offender or an accomplice. Because Section 74a StGB applies, confiscation can in certain circumstances extend to items owned by a third party. In practice, this usually means the smartphone. Whether confiscating an entire phone is proportionate when the file could simply be deleted is one of the points we raise.

Justification: self-defence situations and lack of evidence

Not every secret recording is a crime. A recording may be justified where someone is in a situation comparable to self-defence, for instance because they are being blackmailed or threatened and cannot secure evidence in any other way. The legal basis is then mainly necessity under Section 34 StGB (rechtfertigender Notstand). The threshold is high. There must be a present danger to a significant legal interest, and recording must be a necessary and proportionate response.

A general wish to have evidence for a future dispute is normally not enough. Difficulty proving your case in an employment or family dispute will usually not justify the intrusion on its own either. Repeated threatening calls or demands with menaces may be a different matter. Your reasons for recording should be discussed with your defence lawyer first, not explained spontaneously to the police.

Use of recordings in civil and employment proceedings

Whether a secret recording can be used as evidence before a labour court (Arbeitsgericht), a family court or a civil court is a separate question. The courts weigh the recorded person’s personality rights against the interest in proving the facts. Often the recording is excluded; in exceptional cases it is admitted. Anyone who produces a recording is also providing proof of their own offence, which should be considered beforehand.

How proceedings begin and unfold

Most cases start with a report by the person who was recorded, often combined with the criminal complaint. During police operations, officers may take the phone there and then. You can challenge the seizure (Sicherstellung, Beschlagnahme). A police summons or a written questionnaire usually follows. As a suspect (Beschuldigter), you are not obliged to say anything.

The file is then sent to the public prosecutor’s office (Staatsanwaltschaft) in Bonn. Many cases under Section 201 end without a trial, for example by being dropped under Section 153 or 153a of the Code of Criminal Procedure (StPO). If a penalty order (Penalty Order) is issued or charges are brought, the case is heard by the Bonn Local Court (Amtsgericht Bonn).

Defence strategies

The first question is whether the words were spoken non-publicly at all. For police operations in public, conversations in front of a larger audience or a call on speakerphone with others present, there are often good arguments that they were not.

Consent, intent and possible justification are further points of attack. On the formal side, we check whether a valid complaint was filed in time by the person entitled to do so. This matters particularly where a recording only surfaces months later. It is also often impossible to establish with certainty who made or forwarded a file.

Deleting the recording voluntarily, or agreeing not to reclaim a storage device, can help resolve the case. Such steps should form part of a coordinated defence and should not be taken before the file has been inspected.

Further consequences

A fine of no more than 90 daily rates is generally not shown on a certificate of conduct (Führungszeugnis) if there is no other entry. In employment law, secretly recording a meeting can lead to dismissal. Civil claims for an injunction and, after publication, for damages may also arise. Civil servants face possible disciplinary proceedings.

If you are not a German citizen

If you do not speak sufficient German, you are entitled to an interpreter free of charge, including for consultations with your defence lawyer (Section 187 of the Courts Constitution Act, GVG). If you have no fixed address in Germany, the prosecution may ask for a security payment and require you to appoint someone authorised to accept court documents on your behalf (Sections 127a and 132 StPO). A conviction can also affect a residence permit or an application for naturalisation. Our page on visas, residence and criminal proceedings explains how the two interact.

Frequently asked questions

Can I record a phone call I am taking part in?

Not without the other person’s consent. Section 201 protects people specifically against recording by the person they are speaking to. An exception is possible only where the recording is justified.

Is it an offence to film the police?

Silent video is not covered by Section 201. For footage with sound, it is disputed whether officers’ words are spoken non-publicly. Courts have taken different views depending on the circumstances of the operation.

May I forward a voice message someone sent me?

As a rule, this is not an offence under Section 201, because the sender made the recording themselves, so it was not produced without authorisation. Depending on the content, however, passing it on may infringe personality rights or fall under other provisions.

Will I get my seized phone back?

That depends on the stage of the proceedings. Return becomes possible once the data have been secured or the recording has been deleted. Confiscation of the device is possible but not mandatory.

If you are accused of making a secret recording or your phone has been seized, call us on +49 228 504 463 36. The first call of up to 10 minutes is free of charge.

This page gives general information and does not replace advice on your individual case.

Attorney Philip Bafteh

Written by attorney Philip Bafteh, criminal defense attorney in Bonn. Philip Bafteh publishes regularly on criminal and commercial law and defends accused persons in investigative and trial proceedings.

More about the attorney →

Last updated: November 2026

Free Initial Assessment

Have you received a summons or are you under investigation? Call us. The first assessment by phone is free for up to 10 minutes.

+49 228 504 463 36