Goods Credit Fraud and Fake Shops (Section 263 StGB): Liability and Defence

Proceedings usually start with a complaint from an online retailer or a payment service provider. Goods were ordered on account, delivered to a parcel locker or someone else’s address, and never paid for. Or the other way round: customers paid in advance in an online shop, the goods never arrived, and the money went to an account in your name. In both scenarios the public prosecutor investigates fraud (Fraud) under Section 263 of the German Criminal Code (Strafgesetzbuch, StGB), often in collective proceedings covering dozens of individual offences. The difference between an unpaid invoice and a criminal offence almost always lies in what the person ordering knew at the moment of ordering. The basics of the offence are covered in our article on fraud proceedings.

What is goods credit fraud?

Goods credit fraud (Warenkreditbetrug) means ordering goods on account, on instalments or otherwise without immediate payment while already knowing that you cannot or will not pay. The deception lies in the order itself. Anyone who places an order implicitly declares that they will pay the price when it falls due. German lawyers call this fraud on conclusion of the contract (Eingehungsbetrug): the loss occurs as soon as the contract is concluded and the goods are delivered, because the retailer’s claim to payment is economically worthless.

Not every unpaid invoice is therefore fraud. Someone who intended and was able to pay when ordering and later ran into difficulties through losing a job, illness or unexpected expenses has not committed fraud. They owe the money under civil law, nothing more. Investigators do, however, often infer intent from the outset from the number of orders, false names or differing delivery addresses.

Variants involving other people’s identities are common: orders in the name of neighbours, relatives or invented persons, delivery to parcel lockers or so-called drop addresses, resale of the goods through classified ad portals. Anyone using another person’s payment data may also be prosecuted for computer fraud under Section 263a StGB. Setting up a customer account in someone else’s name is sometimes treated as forgery of data intended to provide proof (Fälschung beweiserheblicher Daten) under Section 269 StGB.

Fake shops: fraud in online retail

With fake shops the roles are reversed. A professionally designed shop offers branded goods, electronics or firewood at attractive prices, demands payment in advance by bank transfer and never delivers. After a few weeks the site disappears. The people behind it are often abroad. In Germany, investigations then focus mainly on those in whose names the receiving accounts are held, or on people who registered domains or forwarded parcels.

These so-called financial agents (Finanzagenten), often called money mules, were frequently recruited themselves, for instance through job adverts for “payment processing from home” or through acquaintances offering a few hundred euros for the use of an account. Whether they are liable for aiding fraud depends on what they knew. Even where no intent to defraud can be proved, an allegation of reckless money laundering (Section 261(6) StGB) frequently remains. Recklessness means closing one’s mind, in a grossly negligent way, to the fact that the money comes from offences. Courts are quick to find this where unusually high commissions were paid for simple account transactions.

Penalties and aggravating circumstances

Fraud carries imprisonment of up to five years or a fine. In especially serious cases the range is six months to ten years (Section 263(3) StGB). One of the standard examples is acting on a commercial basis: anyone who intends to obtain a continuing source of income of some duration through repeated offences acts commercially, and does so from the very first offence. In goods credit fraud involving many orders, prosecutors almost always assume this. Another standard example is a loss of great magnitude, from around 50,000 euros. Anyone acting commercially as a member of a gang commits a serious criminal offence (Verbrechen) under Section 263(5) StGB with a minimum sentence of one year. A discontinuation under Section 153a of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Strafprozessordnung, StPO) is then ruled out.

As a rule each order is a separate offence. Forty orders therefore mean forty individual sentences, from which an aggregate sentence (Gesamtstrafe) is formed. On top of that comes confiscation of the value of the proceeds under Sections 73 and 73c StGB. The state can recover the total value of the goods or money obtained from the convicted person, even if none of it is left.

Defence strategy

Disputing intent at the time of ordering

What matters is what the accused knew and intended at the moment of ordering. Given their income, could they expect to pay the invoice? Were there part payments, instalment arrangements, correspondence with the retailer? We reconstruct the financial situation at the time of ordering from bank statements and payslips. Part payments are strong evidence against intent to defraud.

Challenging commercial and gang activity

A finding of commercial activity shifts the sentencing range considerably. It requires an intention to make a profit through repeated offences, which must be specifically established. A gang requires at least three people who have joined together to commit offences on a continuing basis. Mere cooperation in an individual case is not enough. In proceedings against financial agents in particular, gang membership often cannot be proved.

Reparation and victim-offender mediation

Making good the loss improves your position at every stage of the proceedings. Under Section 46a StGB the court can reduce the sentence or, in some circumstances, dispense with punishment altogether. Where the losses are manageable, a discontinuation against payment to the injured parties is realistic. We contact the retailers or their debt collection agencies and document the payments for the file.

Clarifying the role played

Someone who merely made an account available or accepted parcels is not the principal offender in the fraud. Whether they were an aider or merely acted recklessly makes a big difference to the sentence. We establish what the client actually knew, how they were recruited and what explanations they were given. Chat histories with those giving the instructions are often exculpatory.

File inspection and digital traces

Investigators rely on order data, IP addresses, device identifiers, delivery addresses and bank statements. This data is not always conclusive. An IP address leads to a connection, not to a person. A Wi-Fi network used by several flatmates, or a customer account to which several people had access, weakens the evidence. We examine which orders can really be attributed to the client. Not infrequently, parts of the allegations fall away as a result.

How proceedings end

For first offenders with few orders and a manageable loss, proceedings frequently end in a discontinuation or a penalty order (Penalty Order) imposing a fine. Where there are series with a high total loss and commercial activity, a prison sentence is in prospect; for first offenders it is usually suspended if it does not exceed two years. Anyone with relevant previous convictions or currently on probation must expect the sentence to be enforced. There is a risk of pre-trial detention where there is no fixed address or links abroad suggest a risk of flight.

Consequences of a conviction

Alongside the sentence come confiscation of the value of the proceeds and civil claims by the retailers, often with collection costs and interest. Claims arising from an intentional tort can be excluded from the discharge of residual debt in insolvency proceedings (Section 302 of the Insolvency Code) if the creditor registers them accordingly. A fine of more than 90 daily units (Tagessätze) appears in the certificate of conduct (Führungszeugnis), and a lower fine does too if there is another entry in the register. That causes problems when applying for jobs in retail, finance or the public sector.

If you are not a German citizen

International students and new arrivals are often approached with offers to receive payments or parcels for a fee; this is exactly how many financial agents are recruited. Prosecutors and courts inform the immigration authority of proceedings and convictions, and a conviction for fraud or money laundering can establish an interest in expulsion and affect the extension of a residence permit. A discontinuation is not a conviction. You are entitled to an interpreter free of charge (Section 187 of the Courts Constitution Act, GVG). If you do not live in Germany, the prosecutor may require you to provide security for the expected fine and costs and to appoint a person in Germany to accept service on your behalf (Sections 127a and 132 StPO). More in our article on criminal proceedings and your residence status.

Frequently asked questions

I could not pay an invoice. Is that already fraud?

No. Fraud requires that you already knew when ordering that you could not or would not pay. Later payment difficulties are a civil law matter.

I only made my account available. Am I liable?

Possibly for aiding fraud or for reckless money laundering. That depends on what you knew or should have recognised. Say nothing about the allegation until the file has been reviewed. On the related phenomenon of telephone scammers, see our article on grandchild scams and shock calls (Section 263 StGB).

Is it worth paying for the loss now?

Yes. Payment does not undo the offence, but it has a marked effect on the outcome and can make a discontinuation possible.

Legal representation in Bonn

We defend clients in proceedings for goods credit fraud, fake shops and money laundering before the local courts and the regional court in Bonn and throughout Germany. You can reach us on +49 228 504 463 36. This article gives general information and does not replace advice on your individual case.

Share this post:

Helpful pages

Attorney Philip Bafteh

Written by attorney Philip Bafteh, criminal defense attorney in Bonn. Philip Bafteh publishes regularly on criminal and commercial law and defends accused persons in investigative and trial proceedings.

More about the attorney →

Last updated: July 2026

Questions about this topic?

If you are personally affected or need legal advice, please get in touch. An initial phone consultation of up to 10 minutes is free of charge.

Contact