Appealing a German Penalty Order: Process, Deadline and Risks

A German penalty order (Penalty Order) can be challenged with a simple letter. The remedy is called an objection (Einspruch), and it is often referred to in English as an appeal. Filing it is easy; deciding whether and how to pursue it is not. An objection reopens the whole case. The court can acquit, discontinue, confirm the order or, in some cases, impose a higher sentence. Below we go through the deadline, the procedure after filing and the points we look at before advising a client to pursue or drop an objection.

The yellow envelope and the deadline

The yellow envelope signals formal service with a certificate of delivery (Zustellungsurkunde). The date written on it by the postal worker is the day of service, even if the letter was only placed in your mailbox or left at the post office for collection. The two-week deadline starts on that day, not when you open the envelope. Keep the envelope. It is the only record you have of the service date, and we need it to check the deadline.

What Is a Penalty Order (Penalty Order)?

A penalty order is a conviction issued in writing, without a trial, on the application of the public prosecutor (§§ 407 et seq. StPO). It is only available for less serious offenses (Vergehen). The judge decides on the basis of the file alone, usually without having heard the accused. If no objection is filed, the penalty order has the same effect as a final judgment, including the entry in the Federal Central Register.

What Penalties Can a Penalty Order Impose?

A penalty order can impose a fine in daily rates, a warning with sentence reserved, a driving ban of up to six months, withdrawal of the driving licence with a ban of up to two years, confiscation, and in certain cases a ban on keeping animals. If the accused has a defense lawyer, a prison sentence of up to one year suspended on probation is also possible (§ 407(2) StPO). Unconditional imprisonment cannot be imposed by penalty order.

The Two-Week Deadline for Appeal

The objection must be filed within two weeks of service (§ 410(1) StPO), in writing or orally on record at the registry of the local court that issued the order. It must be in German. Reasons are not required, and it is usually better not to give any at this stage. The deadline runs from the date of formal service, which is written on the yellow envelope, even if you were away. If the deadline is missed through no fault of your own, you can apply for restoration of the status quo ante within one week after the obstacle ceases, stating and substantiating the reasons. An email is not a valid objection; a fax or a letter signed by hand, or a submission by a lawyer via the electronic legal mailbox, is.

What Happens After Filing an Appeal?

After the objection, the court schedules a trial (§ 411(1) StPO). The penalty order now functions as the indictment. At the trial the evidence is heard: witnesses, documents, expert reports. You may be represented by a defense lawyer with a written power of attorney (§ 411(2) StPO), so your personal attendance is often not necessary unless the court orders it. If neither you nor an authorised lawyer appears, the objection is dismissed without a hearing on the merits (§ 412 StPO), and the penalty order becomes final.

Before the trial, there is room for negotiation. Prosecutors and courts frequently agree to a discontinuance under § 153 or § 153a StPO once the defense has pointed out weaknesses in the evidence or mitigating circumstances. Many objections end this way without a trial.

When an Appeal Is Advisable

An objection makes sense if you dispute the allegation and the evidence is weak; if there are legal arguments, for example that the conduct is not punishable or that a required criminal complaint is missing; if a discontinuance appears achievable; if the fine exceeds 90 daily rates and would therefore appear on your certificate of good conduct; if your income was estimated too high; or if the penalty order has consequences for your residence status, profession or driving licence that justify a closer look.

When an Appeal May Be Risky

The court is not bound by the penalty order (§ 411(4) StPO). Unlike an appeal against a judgment, there is no protection against a worse outcome. If the trial reveals aggravating circumstances, the sentence can be higher than in the penalty order. A trial also costs more in court fees if you are convicted, and it is public. In clear cases with an appropriate sentence, accepting the penalty order may be the better choice. That decision should be made after reviewing the file, not before.

Review the File Before Deciding

Only a defense lawyer has full access to the case file (§ 147 StPO). The penalty order itself only summarises the allegation. The file shows what the witnesses actually said, whether there are contradictions, whether procedural rules were followed and how the prosecutor calculated the fine. We therefore file the objection immediately to protect the deadline, request the file, and then advise on whether to pursue, limit or withdraw it. The objection can be withdrawn until the judgment at first instance, after the trial has begun only with the prosecutor’s consent (§ 411(3) StPO).

Limiting the Scope of an Appeal

An objection can be limited to specific points, for example to the amount of each daily rate or to the driving ban (§ 410(2) StPO). The rest of the penalty order then becomes final. If the objection is limited to the amount of the daily rates, the court can decide by written order without a trial, provided the accused, defense counsel and prosecutor agree (§ 411(1) StPO). This is the most efficient route if you accept the allegation but your income was set too high. A limited objection also avoids the risk of a higher number of daily rates.

Impact on Foreign Nationals

For foreign nationals a penalty order can affect residence permits, naturalisation, visa applications and professional licences. Immigration authorities are informed of convictions. Under the Nationality Act, fines of up to 90 daily rates are generally disregarded for naturalisation, higher ones are not. A conviction can also establish an interest in expulsion. The penalty order itself says nothing about these consequences. They have to be checked separately, ideally before the objection deadline expires.

You have a right to a translation of the essential parts of the penalty order if you do not understand German. If you live abroad, the prosecutor may have required you to appoint someone in Germany to accept service on your behalf (§ 132 StPO); the deadline then runs from service on that person, and you may not even have seen the document. Contact them immediately.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the fine go up after an objection?

Yes, if the objection is not limited. In practice this is rare but possible.

Do I have to travel to Germany for the trial?

Not necessarily. A lawyer with written power of attorney can represent you, unless the court orders your personal appearance.

Can I object and then pay anyway?

You can withdraw the objection, and the penalty order then becomes final with the original sanctions.

What if I cannot pay?

Instalments can be agreed with the enforcement authority. Unpaid fines are converted into default imprisonment, one day for every two daily rates, which can usually be avoided by community service.

You can reach us at +49 228 504 463 36. This information is general and does not replace advice in an individual case.

Share this post:

Helpful pages

Attorney Philip Bafteh

Written by attorney Philip Bafteh, criminal defense attorney in Bonn. Philip Bafteh publishes regularly on criminal and commercial law and defends accused persons in investigative and trial proceedings.

More about the attorney →

Last updated: November 2026

Questions about this topic?

If you are personally affected or need legal advice, please get in touch. An initial phone consultation of up to 10 minutes is free of charge.

Contact