Anyone stopped by a store detective in a department store or supermarket usually goes through the same routine. Their personal details are taken, a report is written, they are banned from the store, they receive a demand for a “capture fee” (Fangprämie), and a few weeks later a letter arrives from the police. In criminal law, shoplifting (Ladendiebstahl) is theft under § 242 StGB, punishable by imprisonment of up to five years or a fine. For first-time offenders and goods of low value, the case often ends without a conviction. That is easier to achieve if nobody signs anything rash in the first few days. We defend suspects in Bonn, Cologne and the Rhein-Sieg district.

What happens in the shop and what you sign there

A store detective may hold you under § 127(1) StPO until the police have recorded your personal details. You are under no obligation to answer questions in the back office or to sign a prepared form (“I admit taking the following goods …”). An acknowledgement of debt for the capture fee is often waiting there as well. Towards the police, you only have to give your personal details. A defence lawyer can comment on the allegation in writing later, once the file is available. What suspects must and need not say is explained on our page on suspects’ rights.

When the theft is complete

According to the case law, someone who puts goods in their jacket pocket or their own rucksack has already established new custody while still in the shop. The theft is then complete, even if the checkout is still ahead. Things can look different if the goods were lying openly in the trolley or an item was not scanned at a self-service checkout. Then the questions are attempt, mistake and intent. A scanning error is not theft, and whether it really was one often only becomes clear from video footage and the till records.

Not every allegation arising in a shop is theft. Swapping price labels can lead to proceedings for fraud (Fraud, § 263 StGB) and forgery of documents (Forgery, § 267 StGB). Hiding goods in other packaging and paying only for the packaging, on the other hand, is still theft according to the prevailing view. The correct classification determines the possible sentence and the chances of having the case dropped.

Criminal complaint for goods of low value (§ 248a StGB)

If the goods are of low value, theft is prosecuted under § 248a StGB only if a criminal complaint (Strafantrag) is filed or there is a special public interest in prosecution. Most courts draw the line somewhere between about 25 and 50 euros. Large retail chains file the complaint routinely, and for repeat offenders the public prosecutor usually affirms the public interest without further ado. § 248a StGB is therefore rarely a way out, but it is a good argument for dropping the case.

When shoplifting becomes something more serious

Two situations turn a minor allegation into a serious case. The first is the pocket knife in your trousers. Anyone who carries a dangerous instrument while committing theft commits theft with weapons (Theft mit Waffen, § 244(1) no. 1(a) StGB), punishable by six months to ten years’ imprisonment. According to the case law of the Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof), an ordinary pocket knife can be enough, even if nobody ever thought of using it.

The second is running away after being stopped. Anyone who pushes the detective away in order to keep the goods may be guilty of theft with force to retain stolen goods (räuberischer Theft, § 252 StGB). This is a serious criminal offence (Verbrechen) with a minimum sentence of one year. In both cases, dropping the case is hardly an option any more, and the defence has to challenge the findings on what actually happened from an early stage.

How cases end in the Bonn area

The investigation is usually conducted by the Bonn public prosecutor’s office (Staatsanwaltschaft Bonn). If the case goes to court, the local court (Amtsgericht) in Bonn, Siegburg, Königswinter, Euskirchen or Rheinbach is responsible, depending on where the offence took place. Possible outcomes include dropping the case for lack of sufficient suspicion (§ 170(2) StPO), because guilt is minor (§ 153 StPO) or in return for a payment (§ 153a StPO). Repeat offences are often dealt with by a penalty order (Penalty Order); details are on our page on penalty orders for theft. If someone is caught in the act and the evidence is straightforward, the public prosecutor can also apply for an accelerated procedure. For juveniles, and often for young adults under 21, the rules of juvenile criminal law apply.

We apply for access to the file, check the video footage, the report and the value of the goods, and then talk to the public prosecutor about dropping the case. We only submit a statement on the facts if, on the basis of the file, it will help.

If you are not a German citizen

Tourists, exchange students and other visitors are dealt with under the same rules, but some points differ. If you have no permanent address in Germany, you may be required to provide a security deposit (Sicherheitsleistung) for the expected fine and costs and to name a person living in the district of the competent court who is authorised to accept documents for you (Zustellungsbevollmächtigter, §§ 127a, 132 StPO). If you do not comply, items you are carrying can be seized. If you do not understand what is being asked of you, insist on an interpreter: in police questioning and in court one is provided free of charge (§ 187 GVG). If you are taken into custody, you can ask for your consulate to be informed (Article 36 of the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations). For people living in Germany on a visa or residence permit, a conviction for theft may also have consequences under residence law; see our page on visa and residence in criminal proceedings.

Capture fee, store ban and certificate of good conduct

The capture fee is a civil-law claim by the shop and separate from the criminal proceedings. The courts generally accept it if the amount is reasonable; nobody has to pay flat-rate processing fees or excessive sums without having them checked. Whether paying makes sense is something we coordinate with the defence strategy, because a payment can count as compensation in the criminal proceedings. A store ban usually applies to all branches of a chain. Ignoring it risks further proceedings for trespass (Hausfriedensbruch).

A first conviction to no more than 90 daily rates (Tagessätze) does not appear in the standard certificate of good conduct (Führungszeugnis), provided no other sentence is entered in the Federal Central Criminal Register (Bundeszentralregister) (§ 32(2) no. 5 BZRG). It is still recorded in the register itself. This matters for civil servants and trainee civil servants, because their employer is informed about criminal proceedings. More on this on our page on entries in the certificate of good conduct.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to pay the capture fee?

That is a question of civil law. Whether the claim is justified and reasonable should be checked before you pay or sign an acknowledgement.

Can the case be dropped?

For first-time offenders and goods of low value, dismissal under § 153 or § 153a StPO is often possible. With repeat offences it becomes more difficult.

Will I have a criminal record after a penalty order?

A final penalty order is entered in the Federal Central Criminal Register. A first fine of no more than 90 daily rates does not, however, appear in the certificate of good conduct.

Should I make a statement to the police?

As a suspect, you do not have to say anything about the allegation. The sensible first step is for a defence lawyer to inspect the file.

Further reading: theft (§ 242 StGB), emergency help in criminal proceedings, police summons as a suspect, penalty orders in Bonn, court-appointed defence lawyer in Bonn, criminal offences.

Received a police summons, a questionnaire (Anhörungsbogen) or a penalty order for shoplifting? Use our contact form or call us on +49 228 504 463 36. The first assessment by phone is free of charge for up to 10 minutes.

This page gives general information and does not replace advice on your individual case.