“The public prosecutor’s office intends to provisionally dismiss the proceedings under § 153a StPO subject to payment of 600 euros. You are given the opportunity to declare your consent within two weeks.” For many suspects, a letter like this is the best news in the entire case. The case ends without a judgment, without a trial and without an entry in the Federal Central Criminal Register (Bundeszentralregister). Even so, it is worth looking at the offer carefully before you sign. We advise suspects in Bonn, Cologne and the Rhein-Sieg district on whether, and on what terms, dismissal subject to conditions (Einstellung gegen Auflage) under § 153a of the Code of Criminal Procedure (StPO) makes sense. An overview of all the ways in which proceedings can be dropped is on our page on discontinuation of proceedings.

Requirements

§ 153a StPO applies only to less serious offences (Vergehen), meaning offences with a minimum penalty of less than one year’s imprisonment. The conditions must be suitable to remove the public interest in prosecution, and the gravity of the guilt must not stand in the way. Before charges are brought, the public prosecutor decides, as a rule with the consent of the court. For minor offences without an increased minimum penalty and with only slight consequences, the prosecutor does not need that consent for most types of condition. Once charges have been brought, the court can dismiss the case itself if the prosecutor and the accused agree (§ 153a(2) StPO). This remains possible right into the trial.

There is no dismissal under § 153a StPO without the suspect’s consent. A confession, on the other hand, is not required. The presumption of innocence continues to apply.

Which conditions are possible

The law lists the following conditions and instructions as examples. For each of them, the prosecutor sets a deadline:

  • making good the damage, paying a sum of money to a charitable organisation or to the state treasury, other community service, victim-offender mediation (Täter-Opfer-Ausgleich) and attending a driver improvement or driving aptitude course: no more than six months,
  • meeting maintenance obligations, attending a social skills training course and following a therapy instruction: no more than one year.

The deadline can be extended once by three months. While it runs, the limitation period is suspended (§ 153a(3) StPO). In practice, a payment is the most common condition. The amount depends on the allegation and on your income; there is no fixed table. Payment in instalments is common and can be agreed.

What dismissal achieves and what it does not

Once the suspect has fulfilled the conditions, the act can no longer be prosecuted as a Vergehen. There is no judgment, no previous conviction and no entry in the Federal Central Criminal Register or on the certificate of good conduct (Führungszeugnis). The dismissal is, however, stored in the Central Public Prosecutors’ Register of Proceedings (Zentrales Staatsanwaltschaftliches Verfahrensregister, § 492 StPO). In any later case, prosecutors and courts can see there that proceedings were dismissed before. That makes a second dismissal under § 153a StPO harder to obtain.

Two further points surprise many people. First, the suspect bears their own lawyer’s fees; the state does not reimburse them after a dismissal under § 153a StPO (§ 467(5) StPO). Second, the dismissal binds neither civil courts nor administrative authorities. An injured party can still claim damages, and a public employer, an immigration office or a firearms authority can form its own view of the facts.

When we advise against consenting

Dismissal subject to conditions is a compromise. It makes sense when the evidence carries a real risk and a conviction would be a realistic prospect. If the suspicion is weak, it often does not: then dismissal for lack of sufficient suspicion under § 170(2) StPO is the right goal, with no payment and no record of a “dismissal subject to conditions”. Whether that goal is achievable can only be judged after inspecting the file. We therefore read the file before any consent is given, however tempting the offer sounds.

Conversely, it can be worth suggesting a dismissal yourself. The prosecutor does not offer it of their own accord in every suitable case. A letter from the defence setting out the circumstances of the act, any compensation already paid or the personal consequences a conviction would have can tip the balance. The amount of the payment is open to negotiation.

If the condition is not fulfilled

Anyone who does not pay, or does not pay on time, loses the dismissal. The proceedings continue, and partial payments already made are not refunded. If you can see that you will not be able to pay, apply for an extension or for a change to the instalments before the deadline expires.

If you are not a German citizen

For foreign nationals, a dismissal under § 153a StPO is often a good outcome, because it leaves no conviction for the immigration office to rely on. As explained above, though, the immigration authorities can still learn of the proceedings and assess the facts for themselves. If you are about to apply for an extension of your residence permit, a settlement permit or naturalisation, tell us before you consent, so that we can take this into account. Our page on visa and residence in criminal proceedings has more on this. Do not sign a consent form you do not fully understand. We will go through the prosecutor’s letter with you in English, and the payment can usually be made from abroad by bank transfer.

Frequently asked questions

Is a dismissal under § 153a StPO a conviction?

No. There is no judgment, no previous conviction and no entry on the certificate of good conduct.

Do I have to consent to the condition?

Yes, dismissal is not possible without your consent. You can refuse; the proceedings then continue.

Is consenting an admission of guilt?

No. § 153a StPO does not require a confession, and the presumption of innocence remains in place.

When is an acquittal or a dismissal without conditions the better route?

When the evidence is weak. Whether it is only becomes clear from the file.

Further reading: Glossary: dismissal subject to conditions, Emergency help in criminal proceedings, Police summons as a suspect, Penalty order in Bonn, Court-appointed defence lawyer in Bonn, Criminal offences.

Have you received an offer of dismissal, or would you like to know whether a dismissal is achievable in your case? Use our contact form or call us on +49 228 504 463 36. The first assessment by phone is free of charge for up to 10 minutes.

This page gives general information and does not replace advice on your individual case.