The figures are getting worse, the bank cancels the credit line, and the managing director, often a salaried outside director, wants nothing more to do with the looming collapse. He resigns and has himself removed from the commercial register. Or the shareholders dismiss him because they want to “sort it out themselves”. Months later insolvency proceedings are opened, and the prosecutor asks who filed too late. Whether stepping down protected him depends above all on timing.
The offence, the penalties and the question of when insolvency or over-indebtedness occurs are explained on our page on delayed insolvency filing (Section 15a InsO). In short, the managing directors of a GmbH must file for insolvency without culpable delay once the company is unable to pay its debts or over-indebted, at the latest after three or six weeks respectively. Anyone who intentionally fails to do so faces up to three years’ imprisonment or a fine, and up to one year where the failure is negligent.
Leaving before the crisis
The duty to file applies only to those who are members of the management body when the company becomes insolvent. Someone who left effectively before the company became unable to pay or over-indebted had no duty and cannot have breached it. In such cases everything depends on the date of the crisis. Insolvency administrators like to set that date early in their reports, because doing so strengthens their liability claims. If the date assumed by the administrator falls before your departure, that is precisely the date the defence has to challenge.
Leaving during the crisis
If the company was already insolvent, a later resignation does not change the past. The petition had to be filed without culpable delay. The three weeks for inability to pay and six weeks for over-indebtedness are maximum periods that may be used only for serious attempts at restructuring. Someone who carries on for another month after the company became unable to pay and then resigns has already missed the deadline. The offence has been committed. Leaving ends the duty for the future, but not the responsibility for the period before.
If, on the other hand, the managing director resigns while the period is still running, the position is more open. Whether he can be blamed then depends on whether he delayed culpably, for instance because it was clear from the outset that restructuring was hopeless. In that case he should have acted at once.
Is the resignation valid at all?
A managing director can in principle resign at any time. The declaration must reach the shareholders. Registration in the commercial register is not required for it to take effect and serves only as evidence. In certain situations, however, courts have treated a resignation as an abuse of rights and therefore void, above all where the sole shareholder and managing director resigns during the crisis without appointing a successor and thereby deliberately leaves the company unable to act. Anyone in that position should not rely on a single letter to escape responsibility.
Without management, the shareholders must act
If the GmbH has no managing director after the departure, it is without management (führungslos). For that case Section 15a(3) of the Insolvency Code provides that every shareholder is obliged to file for insolvency, unless they are unaware of the inability to pay and the over-indebtedness, or of the lack of management. This duty carries the same criminal penalty as the managing director’s (Section 15a(4) InsO).
That comes as a surprise to many shareholders, particularly in family companies and with minority stakes. Someone who knows that the only managing director has gone, and also knows that the company is no longer paying its bills, cannot fall back on having been “just a shareholder”. Only lack of knowledge provides a defence. Whether a shareholder knew is a question of fact that is often thinly evidenced in the file: who read which emails, who received the reminders, who attended which shareholders’ meeting?
The successor as a front man
Sometimes a new managing director is appointed after the resignation, merely to “wind down” the company and often without any insight into it. For the prosecution this has two consequences. The newly appointed formal managing director is under a duty to file, even if he only lends his name. And whoever continues to run the business in the background, authorising payments and negotiating with suppliers, can remain under a duty to file as a de facto managing director (faktischer Geschäftsführer), even though he no longer appears in the commercial register. Resignation protects only those who actually leave.
Dismissal by the shareholders
The same principles apply where the managing director is dismissed. He remains responsible for the period up to dismissal. If during that time he had reason to recognise the insolvency and did nothing, the allegation can apply to him. Someone dismissed against his will after pressing for a filing should be able to prove exactly that, for example through emails, minutes or a draft petition.
Keep the civil consequences in view
Alongside the criminal case there is civil liability. Under Section 15b InsO the managing director is liable for payments made from company assets after the company became insolvent. Here too, leaving ends liability only for the future. A settlement with the insolvency administrator can count as compensation for the damage in the criminal case. That is why we look at both sides together.
In the same proceedings the prosecution usually also examines bankruptcy offences and the withholding of social security contributions. We have a separate article on the most common bankruptcy allegation, the late balance sheet: bankruptcy offence for a late balance sheet. On social security contributions: withholding social security contributions.
What we do
We apply for access to the file and start by setting three dates side by side: the date on which the company is said to have become insolvent according to the report, the date on which your resignation or dismissal took effect, and the date on which you could have recognised the crisis. Using bank statements, lists of open items and your correspondence from that period, we examine whether the onset of the crisis can be moved. For shareholders we examine what they actually knew. Information you gave the insolvency administrator may not be used against you in criminal proceedings without your consent (Section 97(1) sentence 3 InsO). The aim is often a discontinuance, which, unlike a conviction for an intentional offence, does not trigger the five-year bar on future directorships under Section 6(2) of the Limited Liability Companies Act.
If you are not a German citizen
Foreign investors and managing directors who live abroad are frequently affected, especially where they hold a German GmbH through a holding structure. The duty to file applies regardless of nationality and place of residence. If you live outside Germany, you may be asked to name a person in Germany authorised to accept service on your behalf, and deadlines will then run from service on that person. A conviction can affect a residence permit linked to self-employment. More in our article on criminal proceedings and your residence status.
Frequently asked questions
Is it enough to register my resignation with the commercial register?
The resignation takes effect when it reaches the shareholders, and the registration merely records it. It does not operate retrospectively. For the period in which you were managing director and the company was already insolvent, the allegation remains possible.
I am only a minority shareholder. Do I really have to file for insolvency?
If the GmbH no longer has a managing director and you know both that it is without management and that it is unable to pay or over-indebted, yes. The duty does not depend on the size of your stake.
When does the allegation become time-barred if I left long ago?
The limitation period is five years. For offences of omission such as delayed insolvency filing, it generally starts only when the duty to act ends, for example when your departure takes effect or when someone else files the petition.
You can reach us on +49 228 504 463 36.
This information is general in nature and does not replace advice in an individual case.
Questions about this topic?
If you are personally affected or need legal advice, please get in touch. An initial phone consultation of up to 10 minutes is free of charge.
Contact