Bankruptcy Offence (§ 283 StGB): Liable for a Late Balance Sheet?

The GmbH is insolvent, the insolvency administrator has written his report, and a few months later the former managing director receives a letter from the public prosecutor. He did not move assets and did not favour any creditors. What he is accused of is something he regarded as a formality: the balance sheets for the last two years were not drawn up, or were drawn up late. This is one of the most common allegations in insolvency criminal proceedings, and it is easier to prove than any transfer of assets, because it turns only on deadlines.

What the bankruptcy offence (Bankruptcy Fraud) covers overall, which acts are included and which penalties apply is explained on our page on bankruptcy offences (Section 283 StGB). In two sentences: Section 283 StGB punishes certain acts during a financial crisis with imprisonment of up to five years or a fine, including breaches of bookkeeping and accounting duties. This is only punishable if payments are actually suspended, insolvency proceedings are opened or the petition is rejected for lack of assets (Section 283(6) StGB).

Two provisions for the same omission

A late balance sheet can fall under two provisions. Section 283(1) no. 7(b) StGB covers anyone who, contrary to commercial law, fails to draw up the balance sheet within the prescribed time during a crisis, meaning at a time of over-indebtedness or of imminent or actual insolvency. The penalty is up to five years.

If the deadline fell before the crisis began, Section 283b(1) no. 3(b) StGB, breach of bookkeeping duties (Verletzung der Buchführungspflicht), remains. It does not require a crisis, but it does require the same objective condition of punishability (Section 283b(3) StGB). The penalty is up to two years’ imprisonment or a fine, and up to one year for negligence. Which provision applies therefore depends on when the crisis began. That is what these cases are most often fought over.

Which deadline applies

For a GmbH, management must draw up the annual financial statements within the first three months of the following financial year. Small corporations may take longer if that is consistent with orderly business practice, but no more than six months (Section 264(1) of the Commercial Code, HGB). Where the financial year is the calendar year, the balance sheet of a small GmbH for 2024 must therefore be drawn up by 30 June 2025 at the latest. Sole traders have no fixed period in months. They must draw up the balance sheet within the time consistent with orderly business practice (Section 243(3) HGB). How long that is depends on the circumstances. In a crisis it tends to be measured tightly.

Two misunderstandings are common. First, the issue is the drawing up by management, not the approval by the shareholders. Second, publication in the company register is a different matter. Someone who drew up the balance sheet but did not publish it will have trouble with the Federal Office of Justice and an administrative fine, but has not committed an insolvency offence. Conversely, administrative fine proceedings for non-publication often tell the prosecutor that the balance sheet was never drawn up either.

When the crisis began

The prosecution often takes the date of the crisis from the insolvency administrator’s report. That report, however, serves the insolvency proceedings, for example the assessment of claims to set aside transactions and liability claims. It tends to place the onset of insolvency early. In criminal proceedings the crisis must be established with certainty at the date the deadline expired. Where balance sheets are missing, the prosecution often lacks precisely the basis needed to prove over-indebtedness on that date. Then only Section 283b StGB remains, with its lower penalty.

No money for the tax adviser

In companies in crisis the balance sheet usually stalls because the tax adviser has unpaid invoices and stops working. The courts recognise that a managing director cannot be punished if he lacked the expertise to draw up the balance sheet himself and there was no money left for an adviser. Criminal law does not require the impossible.

That defence only works if it can be documented. The questions are whether funds were set aside for the balance sheet in good time, whether other invoices were still being paid during the same period, whether the managing director himself had bookkeeping knowledge and whether he tried to find a solution, for example an instalment arrangement with the tax adviser. Someone who paid suppliers and salaries but not the tax adviser at the same time will be told that the balance sheet simply did not matter to him. Bank statements, reminders and correspondence from that period are therefore what counts.

Several managing directors and the tax adviser

The duty to draw up the accounts rests on all managing directors jointly. An internal allocation under which one was responsible for technology and the other for finance does not fully relieve the technical director. He can, however, only be blamed for what he could notice and influence. If a tax adviser was instructed in good time and then failed to deliver, the question of intent arises. In such cases often only negligence remains.

Why intent or negligence makes such a difference

For many managing directors the penalty is not the biggest problem. Under Section 6(2) of the Limited Liability Companies Act (GmbHG), a person convicted of an intentional insolvency offence under Sections 283 to 283d StGB cannot be a managing director for five years from the date the judgment becomes final, regardless of the size of the sentence. That applies even to a small fine under Section 283b StGB. A conviction for negligence alone does not trigger this bar, and a discontinuance certainly does not.

Anyone running a new company, or planning to, should therefore know early that a penalty order which one “just accepts” can end the appointment. A prompt objection may be necessary. More on our page on the penalty order.

Connection with other allegations

The balance sheet allegation rarely comes alone. The prosecution usually examines delayed insolvency filing and withholding social security contributions at the same time. All three depend on the same date of crisis. A defence that looks at only one allegation can damage the position on the others.

What we do

We apply for access to the file, read the insolvency report for what it says about the date of crisis, and reconstruct with you the liquidity position on the dates on which the balance sheet deadlines expired. For that we need bank statements, correspondence with the tax adviser and documents on his invoices. Information you gave in the insolvency proceedings under Section 97(1) of the Insolvency Code may not be used against you in the criminal proceedings without your consent. We check whether the file relies on it. The aim is frequently a discontinuance under Section 153a of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which does not trigger a bar under the GmbHG, or at least a finding of negligence.

If you are not a German citizen

Many managing directors of German GmbHs live abroad or hold a residence permit tied to self-employment. A conviction can affect the renewal of such a permit. A discontinuance is not a conviction. If you live outside Germany, you may be asked to name a person in Germany authorised to accept service, and deadlines such as the two weeks for an objection to a penalty order then run from service on that person. More in our article on criminal proceedings and your residence status.

Frequently asked questions

Is it enough that the tax adviser had been instructed?

Not always. The duty stays with management. But someone who instructed in good time, supplied the documents and followed up generally does not act intentionally if the adviser fails to deliver.

Can I still draw up the balance sheet now?

The offence is complete when the deadline expires, and catching up does not undo it. It can, however, help with sentencing and with a discontinuance. Once insolvency proceedings have been opened, the records are usually with the administrator, and we clarify with him whether catching up is possible.

Am I still managing director of my new GmbH after a penalty order under Section 283b StGB?

Not if the penalty order finds an intentional offence and becomes final. The office then ends by operation of law. An objection to a penalty order can be lodged within two weeks.

You can reach us on +49 228 504 463 36.

This information is general in nature and does not replace advice in an individual case.

Share this post:

Helpful pages

Attorney Philip Bafteh

Written by attorney Philip Bafteh, criminal defense attorney in Bonn. Philip Bafteh publishes regularly on criminal and commercial law and defends accused persons in investigative and trial proceedings.

More about the attorney →

Last updated: November 2026

Questions about this topic?

If you are personally affected or need legal advice, please get in touch. An initial phone consultation of up to 10 minutes is free of charge.

Contact