At the end of the month there is not enough money for everything. The managing director pays the wages so that staff stay, the rent so that the landlord does not terminate, and the supplier who would otherwise stop delivering. The social security contributions are left unpaid, “just this month”. Six months later the health insurance fund files a criminal complaint, or after the insolvency the file reaches the prosecutor via the insolvency court. The managing director does not understand the allegation: he could not have paid anyway.
That very question is at the heart of most of these cases. The offence, the penalties and the typical situations are explained on our page on withholding wages and contributions (Section 266a StGB). In brief, the offence is committed by an employer who withholds the employee’s share of social security contributions from the collecting agency (Einzugsstelle), regardless of whether wages were paid. The penalty is imprisonment of up to five years or a fine.
Someone who cannot pay generally commits no offence
Section 266a(1) StGB is an offence of omission. It punishes those who fail to pay the contributions when due although they could. Contributions fall due at the latest on the third-last banking day of the month in which the work was done (Section 23(1) of Book IV of the Social Code). If on that day no funds were actually available, including through an unused credit line, it was impossible to perform the required act. There is then no offence.
That sounds simpler than it is. The courts restrict this defence in two directions, and many managing directors fail on one or the other.
Employee contributions come first
According to the case law of the Federal Court of Justice, the employee’s share must be paid in priority to other liabilities. Anyone who still paid suppliers, leasing instalments or himself on the due date or in the days before cannot claim that nothing was left for social security. The money was there; it was simply used for something else. Wages do not take priority either. If there is not enough for wages and contributions, the employer must cut the wages and pay the contributions on the reduced wages.
The duty to plan ahead
The second restriction concerns the period before the due date. If it becomes apparent that funds will not suffice on the due date, the employer must set money aside. According to the courts, anyone who fails to do so although the shortfall was foreseeable cannot rely on the later inability to pay. For the defence this means that what matters, besides the account balance on the due date, is how things developed in the weeks before. If the collapse came as a surprise, for instance because a major customer unexpectedly failed to pay or the bank withdrew the credit line at short notice, the allegation of failing to plan ahead does not hold.
Allocating partial payments correctly
Many managing directors make partial payments to the health insurance fund during a crisis. That is right, but often ineffective unless it is specified what the payment is for. Without an express designation, the collecting agency allocates the payment under the rules of the Contribution Procedure Ordinance (Beitragsverfahrensverordnung), and part of it is booked to employer contributions, late payment surcharges or older arrears. What criminal law protects, however, is precisely the employee’s share for the current month. Anyone who can only pay part should therefore state in writing that the payment is to be credited to the employee contributions for a specific month. Whether such a designation can be inferred from the circumstances without an express statement is often disputed after the event.
The notification under Section 266a(6) StGB
The statute offers a route of its own that hardly anyone uses in practice. If the employer notifies the collecting agency in writing, at the latest when the contributions fall due or without delay afterwards, of the amount withheld and explains why timely payment is not possible despite serious efforts, the court may dispense with punishment. If he then pays within the reasonable period set by the collecting agency, he is not punished in that respect.
The notification must therefore come promptly, state the amount and describe the efforts made, such as talks with the bank, reminders to customers or cuts in other expenditure. A line such as “We will pay next month” is not enough. Anyone who sent such a notification in time should keep it. It is one of the strongest arguments in the criminal proceedings.
A deferral (Stundung) is something different. If the employer agrees a deferral with the collecting agency before the due date, the contributions are not due on that date and are therefore not withheld. An instalment arrangement after the due date does not undo the offence, but it substantially mitigates the sentence.
During the insolvency filing period and afterwards
Once the company is unable to pay its debts, the period under Section 15a of the Insolvency Code for filing for insolvency is running. The Federal Court of Justice has resolved the tension between preserving the assets for creditors and paying contributions by holding that non-payment during that filing period is not punishable. Anyone who lets the period pass without filing, however, is fully responsible again, both for the contributions and for delayed insolvency filing. After the petition, the managing director often can no longer dispose of funds freely if the court has appointed a preliminary insolvency administrator whose consent is required. He then lacks the ability to pay.
Who in the company is responsible
Where there are several managing directors, the duty in principle applies to each of them. If another director is internally responsible for finance, the others need only intervene if they have indications of arrears. In a crisis that duty of supervision becomes stricter. Someone who learned of reminders from the health insurance fund at shareholders’ meetings will not be able to rely on being responsible for sales.
Cases in which staff were not registered at all, or were treated as self-employed, are different. They concern undeclared work or bogus self-employment, and the investigations are usually conducted by the customs authority’s Financial Control of Undeclared Work unit (Finanzkontrolle Schwarzarbeit). More on our page on undeclared work.
What we do
We apply for access to the file and go through the collecting agency’s statement of contributions month by month. Using your bank statements, we reconstruct for each due date which funds were available, what was paid to whom in the days before, and whether the shortfall was foreseeable. We check whether partial payments can be allocated to the employee contributions, whether there were deferrals or notifications under Section 266a(6) StGB, and which months fall within the filing period. Often only a fraction of the sum charged remains afterwards. We include your personal liability to the health insurance fund under Section 823(2) of the Civil Code in the discussions, because an instalment arrangement counts as compensation in the criminal case.
If you are not a German citizen
Many small businesses in Germany are run by managing directors without German citizenship, often with a residence permit for self-employment. A conviction under Section 266a StGB with a sentence of at least one year also bars the person from acting as managing director of a GmbH for five years. A discontinuance avoids both that and an entry relevant to residence status. You are entitled to an interpreter free of charge. More in our article on criminal proceedings and your residence status.
Frequently asked questions
May I pay wages if there is then nothing left for contributions?
In criminal law terms that is risky. If there is not enough for both, the courts require wages to be cut and the employee contributions to be paid on the reduced wages.
Does an instalment arrangement with the health insurance fund help?
If payment is deferred before the due date, nothing is withheld. An arrangement made after the due date does not remove criminal liability, but it has a significant effect on the sentence and on the prospects of a discontinuance.
What must a notification under Section 266a(6) StGB contain?
The exact amount of the unpaid contributions and a coherent explanation of why timely payment is not possible despite serious efforts. It must be in writing and reach the collecting agency no later than without delay after the due date.
You can reach us on +49 228 504 463 36.
This information is general in nature and does not replace advice in an individual case.
Questions about this topic?
If you are personally affected or need legal advice, please get in touch. An initial phone consultation of up to 10 minutes is free of charge.
Contact