A defence strategy does not come from gut feeling; it comes from the case file. The first question is almost always the same: make a statement or remain silent? And if a statement is made, in what form and with what aim? On top of that come the decisions that have to be taken afresh at each stage of the proceedings.
Statement or silence: what are the options?
Every accused person has the right to remain silent, and silence may not be used against them. Within that framework there are several options:
- Silence: nothing is said about the allegation. As long as the evidence is not fully known, this is often the safest course.
- Correction: specific wrong assumptions made by the investigators are corrected, for example about the time, the sequence of events or your own role, without making a confession.
- Partial admission: individual facts that are proven anyway are admitted and the rest of the allegation is disputed, for instance to take the edge off an exaggerated charge.
- Confession: the allegation is admitted in full. A confession can reduce the sentence, but it should only be made after careful thought and at the right moment.
Why should a statement be made through the defence lawyer?
As a rule, we submit statements on the facts as a written statement by the defence lawyer (Verteidigererklärung), after careful preparation. Such a statement is matched to what is in the file, free of spontaneous mistakes and emotional wording, and we decide when it is submitted. An ill-considered statement to the police is very hard to correct later. At the trial, the defendant usually has to confirm expressly that a statement made by the defence lawyer is his or her own, so that the court can treat it as the defendant’s account. We prepare you for that as well.
What is a statement meant to achieve?
A statement is not an end in itself. It should achieve something: prompt the prosecutor to drop the case, for example for lack of sufficient suspicion or in return for a condition, refute the allegation or put it into perspective, or lead to a milder legal classification. We only submit a statement when it genuinely helps the defence, never simply because one feels one ought to say something.
When is it advisable to remain silent?
Silence is advisable above all while the file has not yet been inspected and the evidence is unclear. The same applies when the investigators depend on a statement from the accused, or when a statement carries more risks than opportunities. At the beginning of proceedings, the right to remain silent is one of the most effective tools of the defence. Be careful with partial silence, though: if you talk about one part of the events but not about another, the court may draw conclusions from that gap. Whether and when to depart from silence is something we decide with you after reviewing the file.
Strategy at each stage of the proceedings
During the investigation (Ermittlungsverfahren), the main aim is usually to avoid an indictment. The goal is then a dismissal for lack of sufficient suspicion (§ 170(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, StPO), on grounds of minor guilt (§ 153 StPO) or subject to a condition such as a payment (§ 153a StPO). Where there is an injured party, victim-offender mediation (Täter-Opfer-Ausgleich) may make sense (§ 46a of the Criminal Code, StGB).
Once charges have been brought, the defence can raise objections and apply for evidence to be taken in the interim proceedings (Zwischenverfahren), within the time limit set by the court (§ 201 StPO). At the trial, the focus is on applications for evidence, the questioning of witnesses and, where appropriate, talks about a negotiated agreement (Verständigung, § 257c StPO). After the judgment there is one week to lodge an appeal on facts and law (Berufung) or an appeal on points of law (Revision) (§§ 314, 341 StPO). That decision is part of the strategy too.
How we agree the strategy with you
Once the file has arrived, we go through it with you, in person or by phone. Acquittal or conviction is only one question. For many clients it matters just as much to avoid a public trial, to keep a conviction out of the certificate of good conduct (Führungszeugnis), to keep their driving licence or to limit the consequences for their job and their residence status. If you are not a German citizen, we look at the possible effects on your visa or residence permit from the outset; see visa and residence in criminal proceedings. We show you the realistic options and their risks. The decision is yours.
Frequently asked questions
Can silence be treated as an admission of guilt?
No. A person who remains completely silent may not be penalised for it. The court may not draw any conclusions to their disadvantage from their silence.
Can I still make a statement later?
Yes. A statement is possible at any stage, even at the trial. If you remain silent at first, you do not lose that option.
Does a confession always reduce the sentence?
Usually, yes, but not always to the same extent. How much a confession is worth depends among other things on its timing and on whether it spares the court a lengthy taking of evidence.
Not sure whether to say anything? Do not make a hasty decision; talk to us first. Use our contact form or call +49 228 504 463 36; the first assessment by phone is free of charge for up to 10 minutes. How we obtain the file on which every strategy is based is explained on our page on file inspection.
This page gives general information and does not replace advice on your individual case.