Section 184b StGB CSAM charges: dismissal or penalty order since 2024

People accused of possessing or sharing child sexual abuse material usually ask two questions once the first shock has passed. Does this have to end in a public trial? And what will appear on my criminal record certificate? Since 28 June 2024 the answer to the first question is again: not necessarily. Most offences under Section 184b of the German Criminal Code (Strafgesetzbuch, StGB) are once more misdemeanours (Vergehen). That reopens two ways of ending a case without a trial: a dismissal under Sections 153 and 153a of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Strafprozessordnung, StPO) and a penalty order (Penalty Order). What the offence covers and which sentencing ranges apply is explained on our page on child sexual abuse material (Section 184b StGB). This article looks at when either outcome is realistic and what it means for your job and your record.

Why the reclassification matters

Under Section 12 StGB, a felony (Verbrechen) is an offence carrying a minimum sentence of one year’s imprisonment. Between July 2021 and June 2024 that applied to possession and distribution of such material. The procedural consequences were severe. Sections 153 and 153a StPO apply only to misdemeanours, and so does the penalty order under Section 407 StPO. Every case with sufficient evidence had to go to trial, even if it concerned a single forwarded image.

Today Section 184b(3) StGB provides for three months to five years for accessing, acquiring or possessing such content, and Section 184b(1) for six months to ten years for distributing it or making it available. Both are misdemeanours. Commercial or gang activity under subsection (2), with a minimum of two years, remains a felony. Nothing in this article applies to those cases.

Offences committed before June 2024

Many cases now pending with the public prosecutor in Bonn or the local courts in the district concern files that reached a device in 2022 or 2023. The forensic examination of seized devices often takes a long time. For these older cases Section 2(3) StGB applies: if the law changes between the offence and the decision, the most lenient law is applied. Here that is the law in force since June 2024. If you receive an indictment based on the old sentencing range, or the file still refers to a felony, have this checked. An appeal on points of law (Revision) can also rely on the change as long as the judgment is not final (Section 354a StPO). Final convictions handed down before the reform remain in place.

Dismissal under Section 153 or 153a StPO

A dismissal for minor guilt under Section 153 StPO requires that guilt would be regarded as minor and that there is no public interest in prosecution. In Section 184b cases this is rare, though not impossible. A dismissal subject to conditions and directions under Section 153a StPO is more common. It requires that the condition removes the public interest in prosecution and that the gravity of guilt does not stand in the way.

Because Section 184b StGB carries an increased minimum sentence, the prosecutor needs the court’s consent to dismiss. This is more than a formality. The judge at the local court has to support the proposal, and defence counsel should give the judge a sound basis for doing so.

A dismissal is realistic mainly in these situations:

  • a single file or very few files that arrived unsolicited in a group chat and were not searched for,
  • forwarding intended to warn others about an offender or to inform a school,
  • juveniles or young adults where the content circulated in class chats,
  • cases where attribution is uncertain, for example on shared devices, and a dismissal for lack of evidence under Section 170(2) StPO cannot be secured.

A systematically built collection, active exchange or content showing the most serious abuse will usually rule out a dismissal. The usual condition is a payment to a charity. Section 153a(1), second sentence, no. 8 StPO also expressly allows a therapy direction, an obligation to undergo psychotherapeutic treatment, for a period of up to one year. Anyone who has already started treatment of their own accord, for example with the prevention network „Kein Täter werden“ (Don’t offend), can raise this in discussions with the prosecutor.

The penalty order as a second route

If a dismissal cannot be achieved, the prosecutor may apply for a penalty order. The case then ends without a public hearing, but with a conviction. Possession and distribution differ markedly here.

For possession, the minimum sentence is three months. Under Section 47(2) StGB the court then generally imposes a fine instead of a prison sentence of less than six months. The minimum fine follows the minimum prison term, with thirty daily rates equivalent to one month. That means at least ninety daily rates. For distribution, the minimum is six months. Section 47(2) StGB does not apply and a fine is ruled out. A penalty order is still possible, but only with a suspended prison sentence of up to one year and only if the accused has defence counsel (Section 407(2), second sentence, StPO).

In both cases the storage media holding the files are confiscated (Section 184b(7) StGB). This can also be ordered in the penalty order.

What appears on the certificate of conduct

This is where dismissal and penalty order differ most. A dismissal under Section 153 or 153a StPO is not a conviction and is not entered in the Federal Central Criminal Register (Bundeszentralregister). A penalty order is a conviction.

For the standard certificate of conduct (Führungszeugnis), Section 32(2) no. 5 of the Central Criminal Register Act (BZRG) applies: a first fine of no more than ninety daily rates is not included. The extended certificate (erweitertes Führungszeugnis), which schools, nurseries, sports clubs, youth services and many other employers working with children require, follows a stricter rule. Under Section 32(5) BZRG, convictions under Section 184b StGB appear there regardless of the sentence. For a teacher, a nursery worker or a youth coach it therefore makes a considerable difference whether the case is dismissed or ends with the lowest possible penalty order. More in our article on the criminal record entry after a penalty order.

A dismissal does not rule out disciplinary or professional proceedings. Civil servants and members of the healthcare professions should keep this in mind from the outset.

You have received a penalty order: object or accept?

You can lodge an objection (Einspruch) within two weeks of service (Section 410 StPO). After that the order becomes final like a judgment. Whether to object depends on the evidence and on your goal. If a dismissal under Section 153a StPO was still under discussion, an objection can reopen that route, because the court can also dismiss after charges have been brought, with the consent of the prosecutor and the accused. Bear in mind that after an objection the court is not bound by the sentence in the penalty order (Section 411(4) StPO). If only the daily rate has been miscalculated, the objection can be limited to the sentence. How the procedure works after an objection is described in our article on objecting to a penalty order.

How we proceed

Before we discuss a dismissal with the prosecutor, we inspect the file and usually wait for the forensic report. Only then is it clear how many files are alleged, where they were stored and whether knowledge and intent to possess can be proven at all. A hasty statement made in the hope of a dismissal often does more harm than good.

On that basis we set out in writing why a dismissal, or at least a penalty order, is appropriate. This covers how the content was received, conduct after the event, personal circumstances and any treatment already under way. For clients who work with children we align the strategy with the consequences for the extended certificate. How to behave in the first days after a search is covered on our page on a house search over child sexual abuse material.

If you are not a German citizen

For foreign nationals, the choice between dismissal and penalty order also affects residence. A dismissal is not a conviction and usually has no consequences under immigration law. A penalty order is a conviction that the immigration office learns of and that can establish an interest in expulsion or affect the extension of a residence permit. For naturalisation, fines of up to ninety daily rates are generally disregarded under Section 12a of the Nationality Act; for possession that is exactly the minimum fine. You are entitled to an interpreter free of charge and to a translation of key documents. If you do not live in Germany, the prosecutor may require you to appoint a person in Germany to accept service (Section 132 StPO); the two-week objection period then runs from service on that person. More in our article on criminal proceedings and your residence status.

Frequently asked questions

Does a dismissal under Section 153a StPO appear on the certificate of conduct?

No. A dismissal is not entered in the Federal Central Criminal Register and appears on neither the standard nor the extended certificate. Public prosecutors do, however, keep the case in their own register of proceedings for a certain period.

Does the more lenient law apply if the offence was committed in 2022 or 2023?

Yes, as long as there is no final decision. Under Section 2(3) StGB the most lenient law applies, which is the version in force since 28 June 2024. Dismissal and penalty order are therefore legally possible in these cases too.

Will I get my devices back after a dismissal?

Devices and storage media without illegal content must be returned once they are no longer needed as evidence. Media holding the alleged files will not be returned. This is usually settled as part of the dismissal, for example by waiving any claim to those media.

You can reach us on +49 228 504 463 36. This article gives general information and does not replace advice on your individual case.

Share this post:

Helpful pages

Attorney Philip Bafteh

Written by attorney Philip Bafteh, criminal defense attorney in Bonn. Philip Bafteh publishes regularly on criminal and commercial law and defends accused persons in investigative and trial proceedings.

More about the attorney →

Last updated: November 2026

Questions about this topic?

If you are personally affected or need legal advice, please get in touch. An initial phone consultation of up to 10 minutes is free of charge.

Contact