- Legal Basis
- § 323c StGB
- Sentencing Range
- Imprisonment of up to one year or a fine (subsections 1 and 2)
- Summary
- Failing to give necessary and reasonable help in an accident, common danger or emergency, or obstructing a person who is helping or wants to help someone else
A road accident, a person lying motionless at the roadside, a fight breaking out in front of other people: anyone who walks on or drives away at such a moment may be committing the offence of failure to render assistance (unterlassene Hilfeleistung) under Section 323c of the German Criminal Code (StGB). Since 2017 the provision has also covered onlookers who obstruct helpers. Investigations often start from witness statements, videos or the reconstruction of an accident. We defend clients in Bonn and the surrounding region, and the first thing we look at is what the person actually knew in that situation and what they could have done.
What Section 323c StGB covers
Failure to render assistance is an offence that anyone can commit. Unlike the offences of omission that require a special duty of care, such as the duty of parents, treating doctors or someone who created a danger, no particular relationship to the victim is needed. It is enough to be in a situation where help is required. Under subsection 1, an offence is committed by anyone who fails to help in an accident or in a situation of common danger or emergency, although help is necessary and can reasonably be expected of them in the circumstances, in particular without significant danger to themselves and without breaching other important duties.
Accident, common danger, emergency
An accident (Unglücksfall) is a sudden event that creates a significant danger to people or property. Typical examples are road accidents, falls, sudden illness, fires and physical attacks on others. A crime against a third person can also count. Common danger means a danger to an indefinite number of people or to substantial property, as in a flood or a gas leak. An emergency in this sense is a situation of hardship affecting the public at large.
When help is necessary
Help is necessary if further harm is likely without it. The test is how a reasonable observer would have seen the situation at the time, not what is known afterwards. If enough helpers are already present, the ambulance and police have been called and the injured are being looked after, further help is not required. The law does not prescribe a particular kind of help; it requires the most effective help the person is able to give. Someone with no first aid training need not treat anyone, but should call the emergency services, secure the scene or fetch other people to help.
What can reasonably be expected
Nobody has to put themselves in serious danger. A person who calls the police rather than tackling an armed attacker has helped. Breaching other important duties can also make help unreasonable, for example where a doctor is already dealing with another emergency. Mere inconvenience, lost time, a missed appointment or the worry of being drawn into proceedings as a witness do not make help unreasonable.
Intent
Only intentional failure to help is punishable. The person must have realised that there was an accident and that help was needed, or at least considered this possible and accepted it. Someone who takes a person lying on the ground for a sleeping drunk, without seeing any sign of danger, does not act intentionally. Drawing the line is often difficult and depends on what the person was actually able to perceive.
Legal basis and penalties
Failure to render assistance carries imprisonment of up to one year or a fine. The same range applies under Section 323c(2) to obstructing people who are giving help. Whether the injured person later dies or survives does not change the sentencing range. In sentencing, however, the court considers what consequences the failure had and how easy it would have been to help.
Onlookers and obstruction of helpers (subsection 2)
Since 2017 it has also been an offence to obstruct, in these situations, a person who is helping or wants to help someone else. This targets onlookers who stop at an accident scene and block the way for ambulances or fire engines, or people who push first aiders aside. The protection covers professional rescue workers and members of the public alike.
Photographs and videos of injured or deceased people
Filming or photographing at an accident scene can also be an offence under Section 201a StGB. Under Section 201a(1) no. 2, it is an offence to make or transmit, without authorisation, an image that displays another person’s helplessness and thereby violates their most intimate sphere of life. Since 2021, no. 3 also covers images that display a deceased person in a grossly offensive manner. Each carries imprisonment of up to two years or a fine. Passing on such images, for example in messenger groups, is an offence under no. 4, and the court can confiscate the phone.
Acts done in pursuit of overriding legitimate interests, such as reporting on current events, are exempt. Offences under Section 201a are generally only prosecuted if a criminal complaint (Strafantrag) is filed, unless the prosecution considers there to be a special public interest. Where the images show a deceased person, the right to file a complaint lies with the relatives. See our page on the right to one’s own image.
Road accidents and leaving the scene
On the road, two allegations often come together. A person involved in an accident who leaves the scene without allowing the necessary details to be established commits the offence of leaving the scene of an accident (Hit and Run) under Section 142 StGB. That provision protects the other parties’ interest in evidence, not the health of the injured. If someone involved in the accident leaves an injured person without help, Section 323c may apply as well. Both offences can be committed together.
Drivers who were not involved and simply pass an accident scene can only be liable under Section 323c. Anyone who sees that nobody is helping and that injured people need care must stop, secure the scene and call the emergency services, as far as this can reasonably be expected.
If the person caused the accident, the position can become much more serious. Creating the danger gives rise to a special duty to look after the injured person. If the injured person dies or their condition worsens because no help came, investigators will consider bodily harm or homicide by omission, which carry far heavier penalties than Section 323c. In less serious cases, negligent bodily injury caused by the accident itself is often alleged as well.
How proceedings begin and unfold
Cases usually start with statements from witnesses, helpers or emergency services who saw who walked past, watched or filmed. After accidents, the police check number plates, dashboard cameras and videos posted on social media. At scenes with onlookers, the police take personal details and may seize phones if they suspect images were taken.
In Bonn, the case is handled by the public prosecutor’s office (Staatsanwaltschaft Bonn). Given the low sentencing range, it often ends with the case being dropped or a penalty order (Penalty Order). If charges are brought, the Bonn Local Court (Amtsgericht Bonn) hears the case. If you receive a police summons as a suspect, you do not have to go to the police and should not say anything before the file has been inspected. Spontaneous remarks such as “I thought someone else would deal with it” can supply the proof of intent that investigators would otherwise struggle to find.
Defence strategies
The focus is usually on intent and on what the person actually perceived. Visibility, distance, speed when driving past, darkness and the impression that others were already helping can all suggest that they did not recognise the emergency or did not think help was needed. Reasonableness is the other main issue, for example if the person was threatened, injured or had young children in the car.
Under subsection 2, the question is whether there really was an obstruction or whether the person was simply standing nearby. For images under Section 201a, it matters what the image shows, whether it displays helplessness and whether it was passed on. For first offenders, having the case dropped, with or without conditions, is often a realistic aim.
Further consequences
A fine of no more than 90 daily rates is generally not shown on a certificate of conduct (Führungszeugnis) if there is no other entry. The presumption in favour of withdrawing a driving licence under Section 69(2) StGB does not cover Section 323c. The position is different if the person also left the scene of an accident in which someone was injured. For doctors, nurses, paramedics and police officers, proceedings for failure to render assistance can have professional or disciplinary consequences, even if the criminal case is dropped.
If you are not a German citizen
The duty to help applies to everyone in Germany, whatever their nationality and whatever the rules in their home country. If your German is not good enough, you are entitled to an interpreter free of charge, including for discussions with your defence lawyer (Section 187 of the Courts Constitution Act, GVG). If you have no fixed address in Germany, the prosecution may require a security payment and the appointment of a person authorised to accept service of documents on your behalf (Sections 127a and 132 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, StPO). This is particularly relevant for people stopped while travelling through the region. A conviction can also affect your residence status or a later application for naturalisation. Our page on visas, residence and criminal proceedings explains how these questions interact.
Frequently asked questions
Is calling the emergency number enough?
Often, yes. Someone who cannot give first aid or would put themselves at risk by doing so usually meets their duty by calling for help and securing the scene. A person who is able to help effectively straight away may have to do more.
Should I be afraid of making mistakes when helping?
A person who helps in an emergency and makes a mistake is generally only liable in civil law for intent and gross negligence. Under criminal law, well-meant but imperfect help is very rarely a problem. Helpers are also covered by statutory accident insurance.
Is filming at an accident scene a criminal offence?
Not in every case. But if the images show an injured person’s helplessness or display a deceased person in a grossly offensive way, Section 201a StGB may apply. Anyone who gets in the way of helpers while filming also commits an offence under Section 323c(2).
How does this differ from leaving the scene of an accident?
Leaving the scene under Section 142 StGB only concerns people involved in the accident and protects the interest in clarifying what happened. Failure to render assistance concerns anyone who is able to help and protects the people in need.
If you are accused of failing to render assistance, call us on +49 228 504 463 36. The first call of up to 10 minutes is free of charge.
This page gives general information and does not replace advice on your individual case.
What to do now
Emergency help: Police summons: how to respond, Penalty order: check the deadline
Court: Proceedings at Bonn Local Court
Emergency help: Summons, House search, Detention
Local defense: Criminal defense attorney in Bonn, Cologne, All offences
Written by attorney Philip Bafteh, criminal defense attorney in Bonn. Philip Bafteh publishes regularly on criminal and commercial law and defends accused persons in investigative and trial proceedings.
More about the attorney →Last updated: November 2026
Free Initial Assessment
Have you received a summons or are you under investigation? Call us. The first assessment by phone is free for up to 10 minutes.
+49 228 504 463 36