In brief

A motion to take evidence (Beweisantrag) lets the defence oblige the court to hear a witness, obtain an expert opinion or read out a document. The court may reject it only on the grounds listed in the statute and only by formal decision. Errors in rejecting such motions are a frequent basis for an appeal on points of law.

What counts as a motion to take evidence

Since 2019, Section 244(3), first sentence, StPO defines the motion expressly. The applicant must seriously demand that evidence be taken on a specifically asserted, concrete fact relating to guilt or sentencing, by means of a specifically identified item of evidence. The motion must also show why that evidence is capable of proving the fact. If any of these elements is missing, it is merely a request for investigation or a suggestion. The court then decides solely on the basis of its duty to establish the truth under Section 244(2) StPO.

Grounds for rejection

If taking the evidence is inadmissible, the motion must be rejected. Otherwise, Section 244(3), third sentence, StPO permits rejection only where the fact is common knowledge, irrelevant or already proven, where the evidence is wholly unsuitable or unobtainable, or where an exculpatory assertion can be treated as true. Further grounds apply to experts and inspections under subsections (4) and (5), such as the court’s own expertise. Rejection requires a court order (Section 244(6), first sentence, StPO).

A motion may not be rejected merely because it is late (Section 246(1) StPO). Once the evidence planned by the court has been heard, however, the presiding judge can set a deadline. Motions filed afterwards may then be decided only in the judgment, unless filing in time was impossible (Section 244(6), third and fourth sentences, StPO). Where the defence has summoned a witness itself and the witness appears, the grounds for rejection are even narrower (Section 245(2) StPO).

In practice

We file motions in writing and read them out at the main hearing so that the fact, the evidence and the reasoning are fully recorded. The assertion has to be concrete. “The witness will confirm that the defendant is innocent” is not enough; that the witness saw the defendant in a particular restaurant at the time of the offence is a fact that can be proven.

Already during the investigation proceedings the accused can apply for exculpatory evidence to be gathered; it must be gathered if relevant (Section 163a(2) StPO). We examine rejection orders closely. If the court treats a fact as true, it may not assume the opposite in the judgment. A flawed rejection can be challenged by an appeal on points of law.

General explanation, not advice on an individual case. As of November 2026.