Withdrawals under a Power of Attorney: Breach of Trust (§ 266 StGB)

For years a daughter looked after her mother under a lasting power of attorney (Vorsorgevollmacht) that also covered the bank account. She paid bills, withdrew cash for shopping and the cleaner, and occasionally transferred money to her own account because her mother wanted it that way. After the mother’s death the siblings see the bank statements for the first time. A lawyer writes first; a little later a police summons arrives on suspicion of breach of trust (Breach of Trust).

This is one of the most common breach of trust cases outside the business world. The offence requires that someone breaches a duty to look after another person’s financial interests and thereby causes that person a loss. We explain the elements, penalties and defence on our page on breach of trust (§ 266 StGB). This article deals with the particular issues when relatives acted under a power of attorney.

Does the power of attorney create a duty of financial care?

Not automatically. A bank mandate initially only governs what the attorney may do externally. In criminal law the internal relationship is what counts. If the attorney was meant to manage the principal’s assets independently, with discretion and over a certain period, a duty of financial care (Vermögensbetreuungspflicht) is likely. If he merely carried out individual errands, for instance handing the cash to his mother after each withdrawal, it is doubtful.

Between close relatives such arrangements are rarely put in writing. Civil courts therefore quite often find that spouses and close relatives had no formal mandate with a duty to account, but a relationship of trust without bookkeeping. That is an important starting point for the criminal defence. Someone who was never asked to keep receipts and account for them cannot be convicted simply because receipts are missing.

What the principal wanted

Most cases turn on one question: was the individual payment covered by the mother’s wishes? If she gave her daughter money, promised her payment for care or reimbursed expenses, the payment is not a breach of duty. Valid consent by the owner of the assets rules out breach of trust.

Dementia makes this difficult. Consent requires that the principal could still grasp the significance of the decision. For later periods, what matters is the wish expressed earlier or the presumed wish. Letters, notes, a will providing for similar gifts, statements from the GP, care service or neighbours, and earlier gifts to other children all help. Where regular transfers to the attorney began before the illness, it is plausible that the principal wanted them.

Cash withdrawals without receipts

Almost every criminal complaint contains a table of cash withdrawals with no receipts. The other side adds them up as loss. That is too simple. A person in need of care needs cash for shopping, the hairdresser, chiropody, medicines and tips, and often for a home help paid in cash. We reconstruct the realistic need for the relevant period and set it against the withdrawals. The alleged loss often shrinks considerably as a result.

In criminal proceedings, moreover, the accused does not have to explain every withdrawal. The prosecution must prove, for each individual transaction, that it breached a duty and caused a loss. General suspicion is not enough.

Criminal complaint and the principal’s death

Under § 266(2) of the Criminal Code (StGB), § 247 StGB applies accordingly. If the principal is a relative of the attorney, breach of trust is only prosecuted upon a formal complaint (Strafantrag). During her lifetime only the principal herself could file it. After death the right passes to relatives only in the cases the law expressly provides for (§ 77(2) StGB), and there is no such provision for breach of trust. If the principal never filed a complaint, there is therefore much to suggest that acts during her lifetime can no longer be prosecuted to that extent. Complaints by co-heirs regularly ignore this, and it is one of the first points we examine.

Withdrawals after death are different, for example under a power that continues beyond death. They affect the estate held jointly by the heirs. If the co-heirs are the attorney’s siblings, they are his relatives. A complaint is then still required, and the siblings can file it within three months of learning of the act (§ 77b StGB) and later withdraw it (§ 77d StGB).

Then there is the limitation period. Breach of trust becomes time-barred after five years (§ 78(3) no. 4 StGB), separately for each transaction. Older withdrawals from a period of several years are therefore often already time-barred, even if the complaint still counts them.

Civil and criminal proceedings run in parallel

Co-heirs usually demand information, an account and repayment in civil proceedings at the same time. What is written there quite often ends up in the criminal file. Conversely, a criminal complaint can serve as leverage in an inheritance dispute. We therefore coordinate both proceedings. Information in the civil case should only be given once the criminal file is known and it is clear which account of events can be documented.

A settlement of the inheritance dispute is often also the way out of the criminal case. An agreement on the division of the estate, combined with withdrawal of a complaint or a statement by the co-heirs to the prosecution, frequently leads to discontinuation, if necessary under § 153a of the Code of Criminal Procedure (StPO).

What attorneys should do now

Say nothing to the police about the allegations. Collect everything that explains how the money was handled: bank statements, care contracts, invoices, calendars, messages from your mother, and witnesses who knew her wishes. Note what cash was regularly needed for. Do not reply to the other side’s lawyer without coordination. And do not repay anything before it is clear whether, and in what amount, a claim exists at all. A hasty payment can look like an admission.

Court-appointed deputies (Betreuer) are in a different position from attorneys. They are supervised by the guardianship court, must render annual accounts and have a statutory duty of financial care. The points above about the absence of a duty to account do not apply to them.

If you are not a German citizen

Families with members in several countries often only discover the statements after the funeral, and the criminal complaint can reach someone who lives abroad. If you do not live in Germany, the prosecution may require you to name a person in Germany to accept service and to provide security (§ 132 StPO). You are entitled to an interpreter free of charge. A discontinuation is not a conviction and usually has no consequences for residence status.

Frequently asked questions

My mother gave me money regularly. Do I now have to prove that?

Not in criminal law. The prosecution has to prove that the payments were made against your mother’s wishes. Documents and witnesses still help to end the case early rather than letting it go to trial.

Can my siblings still file a complaint now that our mother has died?

For transactions during her lifetime there is much against it if your mother did not file a complaint herself. For withdrawals after her death, the siblings as co-heirs are themselves entitled to file.

Does it help to repay the money immediately?

Not in every case. Repayment can make discontinuation easier, but it can also be read as an admission. It usually makes sense as part of an overall settlement with the co-heirs.

If you are accused of breach of trust after a relative’s death, you can reach us on +49 228 504 463 36. This article is general information and does not replace advice on an individual case.

Share this post:

Helpful pages

Attorney Philip Bafteh

Written by attorney Philip Bafteh, criminal defense attorney in Bonn. Philip Bafteh publishes regularly on criminal and commercial law and defends accused persons in investigative and trial proceedings.

More about the attorney →

Last updated: November 2026

Questions about this topic?

If you are personally affected or need legal advice, please get in touch. An initial phone consultation of up to 10 minutes is free of charge.

Contact