Every year in March, the number of cases goes up. The police check e-scooters still carrying the previous year’s sticker, and a forgotten contract renewal turns into criminal proceedings. Anyone who uses a vehicle that requires insurance without valid third-party liability cover commits an offence under § 6(1) in conjunction with § 30 of the Compulsory Insurance Act (Pflichtversicherungsgesetz, PflVG). This is not a regulatory offence (Ordnungswidrigkeit) but a criminal offence. We defend suspects in Bonn, Cologne and the Rhein-Sieg district.
Compulsory insurance and the insurance year
E-scooters do not need to be registered and you do not need a driving licence to ride one, but they must have motor third-party liability insurance. Proof of this is the insurance plate (Versicherungskennzeichen), which for e-scooters usually takes the form of a sticker (Versicherungsplakette). It is valid for one insurance year (Verkehrsjahr), running from 1 March to the end of the following February (§ 52(1) FZV). When the insurance year ends, the plate and the insurance certificate cease to be valid. The colour of the sticker changes every year so that the police can spot an expired plate at a glance. Anyone still riding with the old sticker on 1 March without having taken out a new contract is, as a rule, uninsured.
Rental scooters from sharing providers are insured through the provider. The cases therefore almost always concern privately bought scooters.
What is a criminal offence and what is not
The offence consists of using a vehicle for which the required liability insurance does not exist. What matters is the insurance contract, not the sticker. Someone who has a valid contract but has not yet attached the new sticker, or is not carrying the certificate, commits only a regulatory offence. In practice, this distinction can often only be made after checking with the insurer. Under § 6(4) PflVG, it is also an offence to allow someone else to use an uninsured vehicle. This affects, for example, parents who let their child ride their own scooter.
Penalties and further consequences
For an intentional offence, the penalty is imprisonment of up to one year or a fine (§ 30(1) PflVG); for negligence, imprisonment of up to six months or a fine of up to 180 daily rates (Tagessätze, § 30(2) PflVG). The vehicle can be confiscated if it belongs to the offender (§ 30(4) PflVG). As an e-scooter is a motor vehicle, the court can also impose a driving ban (Fahrverbot) under § 44 StGB. If there was an accident during the uninsured ride, the rider is personally liable for the damage. The compensation fund for road accident victims (Verkehrsopferhilfe) pays those who were harmed, but then seeks recourse from the rider.
Intent or negligence
Most cases do not involve a deliberate decision against insurance. The contract expired, the insurer’s reminder got lost, or someone believed the insurance would renew automatically. That is not intent. Whether there was negligence depends on what the rider ought to have known. When a used scooter is sold, the existing insurance in principle passes to the buyer (§§ 95, 122 of the Insurance Contract Act, VVG). It can, however, be terminated after the sale (§ 96 VVG) or end with the insurance year without the new keeper noticing. Whether the buyer should have realised this depends on the case. Someone who has been the keeper for a long time and still has last year’s sticker on the handlebars will find it hard to rely on not knowing. This is where the defence comes in, and this is where it is decided whether the lower penalty range applies.
Tuned scooters and models without type approval
Things get more complicated if the scooter can go faster than 20 km/h or has no type approval (Betriebserlaubnis), as is the case with some models ordered online. It is then no longer a small electric vehicle but a motorcycle (Kraftrad), for which a driving licence is required. On top of the insurance offence, an allegation of driving without a licence is then quickly on the table.
How cases end
The Bonn public prosecutor’s office (Staatsanwaltschaft Bonn) is responsible. For first-time offenders who missed the renewal only briefly and are insured again, dismissal under § 153 or § 153a StPO is possible. Otherwise, a penalty order (Penalty Order) is usually issued. For juveniles, and often for young adults under 21, juvenile criminal law applies; there, such proceedings often end with an educational measure and no judgment. We examine the file, obtain the contract documents and explain to the public prosecutor why there was no intent and why dismissal is appropriate.
If you are not a German citizen
Students and employees from abroad often buy a used scooter from someone who is leaving Bonn, or bring one with them. In both cases, check that a German liability insurance contract exists for that specific scooter; the seller’s sticker alone does not tell you whether that contract is still in force, and an insurance policy from your home country is no substitute. If you receive a penalty order, act quickly: the deadline for an objection (Einspruch) is two weeks. You are entitled to an interpreter free of charge in police questioning and in court (§ 187 GVG). Whether a conviction affects your residence status depends on the individual case; see our page on visa and residence in criminal proceedings.
Frequently asked questions
Is this a criminal offence or a regulatory offence?
Riding without existing liability insurance is a criminal offence under § 30 PflVG. If only the sticker is missing while a contract exists, it is a regulatory offence.
What if I simply did not notice that the sticker had expired?
Then there is no intent. Whether there was negligence depends on the circumstances, and this is an important starting point for the defence.
Can the case be dropped?
For first-time offenders, dismissal under § 153 or § 153a StPO is possible, particularly if the scooter is insured again.
Can my scooter be taken away?
Yes. If the scooter belongs to the offender, the court can confiscate it under § 30(4) PflVG.
Further reading: driving without insurance (§§ 6, 30 PflVG), false insurance plate on an e-scooter, emergency help in criminal proceedings, police summons as a suspect, penalty orders in Bonn, court-appointed defence lawyer in Bonn, criminal offences.
Received a questionnaire about riding without insurance? Use our contact form or call us on +49 228 504 463 36. The first assessment by phone is free of charge for up to 10 minutes.
This page gives general information and does not replace advice on your individual case.