A year’s subscription to a streaming service for six euros, a gaming account with rare items for a fraction of their value, “lifetime” access to a piece of software. Offers like these appear on marketplaces, in Telegram channels and in forums. Months later the buyer receives a summons as a suspect, and the allegation is handling stolen data (Handling Stolen Data). Usually there is a case against the seller behind it, in which investigators have gone through his customer list. The question people then ask is a simple one: have I committed an offence just because I bought something?
The answer turns on details the summons does not mention. The offence, the penalties and the defence in general are explained on our page on handling stolen data (Section 202d StGB). In short, an offence is committed by anyone who obtains data that are not generally accessible and that someone else acquired through an unlawful act, in order to enrich themselves or a third party or to harm another person. The penalty is imprisonment of up to three years or a fine.
Where did the account come from?
Without an unlawful predicate offence there is no handling of stolen data. With cheap accounts that is often an open question. The logins can come from very different sources. Frequently they were obtained through credential stuffing: offenders try email and password combinations from earlier data leaks at other services and take over accounts whose holders used the same password more than once. A predicate offence is then likely, usually data espionage under Section 202a StGB. Phishing, or accounts paid for with stolen credit card details, are also possible.
But there are also sellers who split their own properly paid family or multi-user plan into slots and resell them, or who offer credit from regions with lower prices. That breaches the provider’s terms of use, but it is not an unlawful act through which data were obtained within the meaning of Section 202d StGB. The prosecution has to show the source of the specific account. The fact that the seller dealt in stolen accounts overall is not automatically enough for every individual sale.
What did the buyer know?
Only someone who knows of the unlawful origin, or at least accepts it as possible, commits the offence. This is the second focal point. Investigators like to base intent on the price: anyone buying a year’s access for a fraction of the normal price must have known something was wrong. That is an indication, not proof. Many buyers assume they are getting a shared family slot or a subscription that is cheaper in another region, and that is often exactly how the offers are advertised.
It is different where the listing itself refers to “cracked” accounts, “combos” or “hits”, where the buyer is told not to change the account’s password or email address, or where the origin was discussed openly in the chat with the seller. Messages of that kind are often found in the seller’s seized data. That is why it matters so much to know what the investigators actually have before saying anything.
Intent to enrich and the criminal complaint
The buyer must also act in order to enrich himself or a third party or to harm someone else. Investigators usually see the enrichment in the fact that the buyer uses access he would otherwise have had to pay a lot more for. By contrast, someone who downloads a leaked data set only to check whether their own data are included acts without that intention.
Under Section 205(1) StGB, handling stolen data is prosecuted only on a formal criminal complaint (Strafantrag), unless the public prosecutor affirms a special public interest. The person entitled to file it is the injured party, in the case of a hijacked account primarily the account holder. In mass proceedings against a seller’s customers these people have often not even been identified. Without a complaint, the prosecutor has to justify the public interest. For a single streaming account bought at a low price, there are good arguments against it. What the withdrawal of a complaint achieves is explained in our article on the criminal complaint in data espionage cases.
Penalty limits and further allegations
Under Section 202d(2) StGB the penalty may not be more severe than the one that applies to the predicate offence. Where the predicate offence is data espionage, the limit is also three years. Anyone who then logs into someone else’s account with the purchased credentials may additionally commit data espionage under Section 202a StGB if he thereby gains access to protected data. How this is to be assessed is not uniformly settled. More on that on our page on data espionage.
Matters become considerably more serious where the case is not about streaming access but about credit card details or bank logins that were then used to buy things. Computer fraud under Section 263a StGB is then in issue, and handling stolen data moves into the background.
Typical mistakes after a summons
Many people want to get it over with and write to the police that they bought the account “cheaply online” and “didn’t know it was illegal”. The first part confirms the purchase. The second does not help, because what matters is not knowledge that it was prohibited but knowledge of where the data came from. Others delete their chats with the seller or the account itself. That changes nothing about the data already seized from the seller and can be interpreted unfavourably. You are not required to attend a police interview, and without access to the file you should not.
What we do
We notify the authorities that we are acting for you and apply for access to the file. We then see what the link to you is based on, whether there is any information on where the specific account came from, whether a criminal complaint has been filed and what the messages with the seller say. In most buyer cases involving individual accounts a discontinuance is possible, either under Section 170(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure for lack of evidence or under Sections 153 and 153a for minor guilt. Which route is open depends on the evidence. We discuss with you whether a statement makes sense and, if so, submit it in writing through us.
For people working with personal data, in the public sector or with a security clearance, even an open investigation can be awkward. We take that into account when choosing the approach.
If you are not a German citizen
Many buyers in these mass proceedings are students or young employees from abroad. A discontinuance is not a conviction and is generally not relevant to your residence status. You are entitled to an interpreter free of charge if you are questioned. If you have since left Germany, the proceedings can continue, and documents may be served on a person you have authorised to accept them. More on this in our article on criminal proceedings and your residence status.
Frequently asked questions
Is buying a shared family slot already an offence?
Not under Section 202d StGB, if the seller is splitting his own paid plan. That usually breaches the terms of use, but there are no data obtained through an unlawful act.
Is the low price enough to prove intent?
Not on its own. The price is one indication. What matters is how the offer was described, what the seller told you and what other circumstances the file contains.
Should I cancel the access or delete the account now?
Stop using the access. But do not delete messages or accounts before you have spoken to us. What exists can also work in your favour.
You can reach us on +49 228 504 463 36.
This information is general in nature and does not replace advice in an individual case.
Questions about this topic?
If you are personally affected or need legal advice, please get in touch. An initial phone consultation of up to 10 minutes is free of charge.
Contact