These investigations almost always start the same way. Authorities in several countries take down a so-called booter or stresser service, a website where anyone can order flooding attacks on an IP address or server for a few euros. The customer database is seized in the process: usernames, email addresses, IP addresses used to log in, payments via PayPal or cryptocurrency, often the list of targets as well. Months or years later, users in Germany receive a summons, a written hearing letter or a visit with a search warrant. Many of them were at school at the time and booked the service to knock an opponent offline in an online game or to take down the server of a rival community.
Whether that is punishable as computer sabotage (Computer Sabotage) depends less on the technology than on two requirements that in these cases are often simply asserted. The offence, the penalties and the defence in general are explained on our page on computer sabotage (Section 303b StGB). In short, an offence is committed by anyone who substantially disrupts data processing that is of material importance to another person, in a DDoS attack by transmitting data with the intention of causing someone a disadvantage (Section 303b(1) no. 2 of the Criminal Code).
Ordering the attack makes you more than a customer
A common misconception is that only the operator of the service commits an offence. Whoever books the attack, enters the target and starts it decides the timing, the duration and the victim. He is therefore generally treated as a perpetrator himself, even though the technical means come from someone else’s servers. Attempt is punishable (Section 303b(3) StGB). An attack that fizzles out because the target was well protected does not go unpunished for that reason alone.
Providers often advertise their services as “load testing” for your own servers. Anyone who genuinely tested only their own infrastructure has not disrupted anyone else’s data processing. The customer database, however, usually lists the IP addresses attacked. If they do not belong to the suspect, the testing explanation will not get far. Conversely, the prosecution has to show that the stored target was actually attacked and whom it belonged to at the time.
An opponent in an online game: material importance?
This is the heart of many defences. Section 303b(1) StGB protects only data processing that is of material importance to the person affected. For private individuals, not every device qualifies. What is meant is data processing central to the way they live, for example for work, education or important communication. The games console of another player whose connection drops for a quarter of an hour is, on the prevailing view, generally not covered. It then has to be examined whether there is data tampering under Section 303a StGB, which can also be doubtful where there was only flooding and no interference with stored data.
The position is different where a business is affected. The server of a commercial games provider, an online shop or a company website is of material importance to another’s business. Section 303b(2) StGB then applies, with a penalty of up to five years. Between these two extremes lie many cases in which the investigation file says almost nothing about the victim: a privately run game server financed by donations, a Discord server, a school network. Assuming the aggravated offence across the board is too easy.
Substantial disruption or a brief delay?
The disruption must be substantial. An attack automatically absorbed by the target’s host, or an outage of a few seconds, is not enough. The customer database of a stresser service shows only that an attack was ordered and for how long. It does not show whether the attack reached the target or what it did there. Often the file contains no statement from the victim at all, because the victim was never identified. At most an attempt remains, and even that requires that the suspect intended a substantial disruption of materially important data processing.
Criminal complaint and public interest
Under Section 303c StGB, computer sabotage under Section 303b(1) to (3) is prosecuted only on a formal criminal complaint (Strafantrag) by the victim, unless the public prosecutor considers that there is a special public interest requiring action of its own motion. In the mass proceedings that follow the takedown of a service there is often no one to file a complaint, because the victims are unknown. The prosecutor must then affirm the special public interest. Where the case concerns a single attack on another player years ago, there are good arguments against it.
Reading the database does not identify a perpetrator
An account with a booter service leads to an email address and IP addresses, not to a person. Siblings using the same computer, a shared family internet connection, a throwaway email address, an account passed around among friends: such situations are common, particularly among young people. Providers store which connection an IP address was assigned to at a given time only for a short period, so older matches often succeed only through payment data. And if the PayPal payment came from a parent’s account, that says little about who carried out the attack.
Juveniles and young adults
If the suspect was aged 14 to 17 at the time, juvenile criminal law applies. For those aged 18 to 20, Section 105 of the Youth Courts Act (JGG) asks whether, in terms of development, they were still comparable to a juvenile. Juvenile law has its own routes for ending a case without a judgment under Sections 45 and 47 JGG, for example after an educational talk or community work. For a one-off attack without any identifiable damage, that is the outcome we aim for. It usually requires that the young person does not dispute the allegation. Whether that is advisable we decide only after inspecting the file, because a confession cannot be taken back if the evidence later turns out to be thin.
Searches, devices and damages
In these cases the young person’s bedroom is often searched and every device taken, including those of parents and siblings. You do not have to disclose passwords. Devices that belong to other family members and have nothing to do with the allegation should be reclaimed as quickly as possible. Computers used for the offence can be confiscated by the court as instruments of the offence. That too can be negotiated as part of a discontinuance.
Affected companies sometimes bring civil claims for damages, for example for the costs of mitigation and lost sales. Such claims are often generously quantified in criminal complaints. We examine which loss can actually be traced to the specific attack and include any compensation in the negotiations on a discontinuance.
What you should do now
Do not attend the police interview and do not make any statement, not in writing either and not “just to clarify”. Do not delete anything, neither chat histories nor accounts. That could be treated as destroying evidence and would not help, because the service’s data are already with the authorities. Write down who had access to the computer, the internet connection and the payment account at the time. Parents of under-age suspects should know that they can be questioned as witnesses themselves and, as relatives, may refuse to testify.
We apply for access to the file, check against the database extracts what is actually proven about the target, the effect and the attribution, and work towards a discontinuance where the case allows it. Where the analysis of devices matters, we bring in our own experts.
If you are not a German citizen
Students and young professionals from abroad are often unsure whether such a case affects their visa or residence permit. A discontinuance, including one under juvenile law, is not a conviction. A conviction is reported to the immigration authorities and is assessed according to the sentence. You are entitled to a free interpreter at any interview and at trial. More in our article on criminal proceedings and your residence status.
Frequently asked questions
Is a DDoS attack on another player always computer sabotage?
No. Another player’s console or home connection is usually not data processing of material importance, and a brief loss of connection is not a substantial disruption. Whether another provision applies depends on the individual case.
The attack was years ago. Is it not time-barred?
For Section 303b(1) and (2) StGB the limitation period is five years (Section 78(3) no. 4 StGB). It is interrupted, among other things, by the first interview or by notification that an investigation has been opened. We check whether an attack is time-barred using the date recorded in the customer database.
Do my parents have to pay for the damage?
Parents are not automatically liable for their children’s acts. Liability can arise where they breached their duty of supervision. That is a civil law question, assessed separately from the criminal case.
You can reach us on +49 228 504 463 36.
This information is general in nature and does not replace advice in an individual case.
Questions about this topic?
If you are personally affected or need legal advice, please get in touch. An initial phone consultation of up to 10 minutes is free of charge.
Contact