A post in a Telegram group after a demonstration: “Tomorrow we go in and clear the shop out.” A comment under a newspaper article about a politician: “Someone should give him a proper message.” A call to block the access road to a power station. Remarks like these now regularly end up with the public prosecutor, often followed by a house search in which phones and laptops are seized. The allegation is public incitement to commit offences (öffentliche Aufforderung zu Straftaten) under Section 111 of the German Criminal Code (Strafgesetzbuch, StGB). Whether it holds depends on where punishable incitement ends and protected expression of opinion begins, and that line is narrower than many people assume.
What Section 111 StGB covers
The offence is committed by anyone who publicly, in a meeting or by disseminating content calls on others to commit an unlawful act. A statement is public if it can be perceived by a group of people that is not limited in number and not linked by personal relationships. A public social media account meets that test without difficulty, and so, as a rule, does a large open Telegram group. A message in a small private chat among friends does not.
Calling on others to act is more than approving of an act. What is required is a statement recognisably aimed at getting others to commit an offence. Saying that you find a particular act good or understandable is not incitement. It may, however, fall under Section 140 StGB, approval of offences (Billigung von Straftaten), which since 2021 also covers certain serious offences that have not yet been committed, provided the approval is liable to disturb the public peace. The incitement must also relate to an unlawful act that is defined at least in its main features. According to the case law, a general call for “resistance” or an “uprising” is usually not enough.
Penalties
The sentence depends on whether the incitement succeeds. If the offence called for is actually committed, the person who incited it is punished like an instigator under Section 111(1) StGB, that is, within the range for the offence committed. If the incitement has no effect, subsection 2 provides for imprisonment of up to five years or a fine. The sentence may not, however, exceed the range that would apply had the incitement succeeded, and the statute expressly applies the mitigation rule in Section 49(1) no. 2 StGB, which caps the maximum at three quarters of that range. Anyone calling for criminal damage, which carries up to two years, therefore faces at most eighteen months if nobody acts on the call.
Related offences
Section 111 StGB overlaps with a number of other offences. Incitement to hatred (Volksverhetzung) under Section 130 StGB covers, among other things, calls for violent or arbitrary measures against sections of the population or particular groups. Where a call is directed at such groups, Section 130, with its higher minimum sentence of three months, is usually the focus of the case. See our page on incitement to hatred (Section 130 StGB). Disturbing the public peace by threatening to commit offences under Section 126 StGB concerns announced offences, whether one’s own or those of others. Threatening behaviour (Threatening Behaviour) under Section 241 StGB is directed at a specific person. Section 130a StGB, instructions for committing offences, covers content capable of serving as a guide to certain serious offences. And anyone who disparages another person in a comment without calling for an offence is in the territory of insult (Insult, Section 185 StGB).
Freedom of expression as the yardstick
The Federal Constitutional Court requires criminal courts to interpret ambiguous statements in light of freedom of expression under Article 5 of the Basic Law. Where a statement admits of several reasonable readings, the court may not simply adopt the punishable one. It must rule out the others with convincing reasons. Polemic, exaggeration, irony and satire are protected in principle. Context counts for a great deal. A sentence written in a debate on climate policy can be meant and understood differently from the same sentence in a group planning specific actions.
With calls to protest actions such as sit-in blockades, the question is whether the action itself would be an offence. A blockade can amount to coercion (Coercion) under Section 240 StGB, but it need not. Whether it is reprehensible within the meaning of Section 240(2) StGB has to be assessed case by case, and a call to take part in an action that is not punishable is not incitement to commit an offence.
Defence strategy
Distinguishing incitement from opinion
Was the statement an appeal to others to act, or was it an assessment, a wish, an outburst of anger? This distinction is often the heart of the defence, and it can be supported by the context: the thread the comment replied to, earlier posts, how other users reacted.
Is the offence sufficiently defined?
Which offence, exactly, was being called for? If that cannot be identified at least in outline, Section 111 StGB does not apply.
Intent and context
Statements that are recognisably ironic or satirical are not serious calls to action. An emoji, an exaggeration or a well-known quotation can change the meaning.
Authorship and attribution
Who wrote the post? Accounts are shared, hacked and used by others. Someone who merely shares another person’s post may be disseminating it, but only incites if they recognisably adopt the content as their own.
Aiming for a discontinuation
With one-off comments written in the heat of the moment and without consequences, proceedings can often be discontinued (Einstellung) under Section 153 or Section 153a of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Strafprozessordnung, StPO), particularly where the post has been deleted and the person concerned has distanced themselves from it.
How investigations are conducted
In North Rhine-Westphalia, online hate speech and calls to action are handled centrally by the Cybercrime Central and Contact Office (ZAC NRW) at the Cologne public prosecutor’s office, which works closely with reporting centres and platforms. Platforms supply subscriber data, investigators link accounts to individuals, and more serious allegations are followed by searches. Nationwide action days with dozens of searches on a single morning have become routine. If you are affected, here too you should say nothing about the allegation and not disclose any passwords.
How proceedings end
Many cases about individual comments end without a conviction. Repeated, unambiguous calls for violence, particularly against individuals or groups, can lead to fines and, for those with previous convictions, to prison sentences. Where the incitement actually led to an offence, for instance to rioting, the sentence is determined by that offence.
Consequences of a conviction
Besides the sentence, phones and computers may be confiscated as instruments of the offence. Civil servants, soldiers and public sector employees also face disciplinary consequences, because statements of this kind can cast doubt on their loyalty to the constitution.
If you are not a German citizen
Prosecutors and courts inform the immigration authority of proceedings and convictions. A conviction can establish an interest in expulsion and affect the extension of a residence permit; calls for violence against groups of people are viewed particularly critically. A discontinuation is not a conviction and usually has no such effect. You are entitled to an interpreter free of charge (Section 187 of the Courts Constitution Act, GVG) and to a translation of the key documents. If you do not live in Germany, the prosecutor may require you to provide security for the expected fine and costs and to appoint a person in Germany to accept service on your behalf (Sections 127a and 132 StPO). More in our article on criminal proceedings and your residence status.
Frequently asked questions
Is an angry comment on social media already a criminal offence?
Not automatically. What matters is whether others are recognisably called upon to commit a specific offence. Insults or threats can, however, amount to other offences.
I only shared someone else’s post. Am I liable?
That depends on whether you adopted the content as your own, for example through approving comments. Sharing without comment for information purposes is assessed differently.
Does it help to delete the post?
The offence is complete once the post is published. Deleting it does count in your favour at sentencing and when a discontinuation is being considered. Do not destroy evidence, though; take advice first.
If your home has been searched because of an online post or you have received a summons, you can reach us on +49 228 504 463 36. This article gives general information and does not replace advice on your individual case.
Questions about this topic?
If you are personally affected or need legal advice, please get in touch. An initial phone consultation of up to 10 minutes is free of charge.
Contact