- Legal Basis
- §§ 185, 188, 130 StGB
- Sentencing Range
- Imprisonment of up to one year or a fine; up to two years or a fine if committed publicly or by disseminating content (Section 185 StGB)
- Summary
- Insulting, inciting or threatening statements on social networks, in comment sections and in messenger groups, in particular insult, insult of persons in political life and incitement to hatred
A comment under a newspaper article, an angry post about a mayor, a voice message in a parents’ group chat: criminal proceedings over things people write online have become common in Germany. Many people only find out when the police turn up one morning with a search warrant and take their phone. We defend people under investigation in Bonn and the surrounding region, and we start with two questions: is the statement a criminal offence at all, and can it actually be attributed to our client?
What this is about
“Hate posting” is not a term found in the German Criminal Code (StGB). It describes online statements that may amount to an offence. The most common is insult (Insult) under Section 185 StGB. Others are insulting persons in political life (Section 188), incitement to hatred (Volksverhetzung, Section 130), threats (Threatening Behaviour, Section 241) and, where facts rather than opinions are asserted, malicious gossip and defamation (Sections 186 and 187).
Typical cases involve comments on Facebook, Instagram, X, TikTok or YouTube, posts in forums and in the comment sections of news sites, and messages in Telegram or WhatsApp groups. Sharing, forwarding or approvingly commenting on someone else’s content can also be an offence where the user clearly adopts it as their own. Whether a simple “like” is enough is disputed.
Legal basis and penalties
Insult (Section 185 StGB)
Insult carries up to one year’s imprisonment or a fine. If it is committed publicly, in a meeting, by disseminating content or by means of physical assault, the maximum rises to two years or a fine. A publicly visible post will usually fall within the higher range. With messages in closed groups, it depends on the size and make-up of the group whether the statement counts as public or as dissemination.
Persons in political life (Section 188 StGB)
An insult made publicly or by disseminating content against a person in the political life of the nation carries up to three years’ imprisonment or a fine. The motive must be connected with the person’s public position, and the act must be capable of making their public work considerably more difficult. Since 2021 the statute has expressly stated that political life extends down to local government, so councillors and mayors are covered too.
Incitement to hatred (Section 130 StGB)
Stirring up hatred against national, religious or ethnic groups, or attacking the human dignity of their members, in a manner capable of disturbing the public peace, carries between three months’ and five years’ imprisonment. Disseminating such content or making it publicly accessible is punishable under Section 130(2) by up to three years or a fine. Our page on incitement to hatred covers the offence in more detail.
Threats (Section 241 StGB)
Announcing violence in a comment can lead to proceedings for making a threat. Where this is done publicly or by disseminating content, the penalty is up to two years’ imprisonment, or up to three years if a felony is threatened, in each case alternatively a fine.
When a criminal complaint is required
As a rule, insult is only prosecuted if the victim files a criminal complaint (Strafantrag, Section 194(1) StGB). The complaint must be made within three months of the victim learning of the act and the offender’s identity (Section 77b StGB). Online, though, the exceptions often apply. Under Section 188 the prosecution may act without a complaint if it considers there to be a special public interest, unless the victim objects. Insults disseminated against members of a group persecuted under National Socialism or another tyranny, where the statement is connected with that persecution, are also prosecuted without a complaint. If a public official is insulted in connection with their duties, their superior may file the complaint (Section 194(3)). Incitement to hatred is always prosecuted by the authorities of their own motion.
How investigations start
Unlike a row in the street, the person insulted is often not the one who reports it. Tips come from reporting centres where users can flag criminal content, from media companies and state media authorities passing on comments from their own sites, and from the platforms themselves. Under Article 18 of the EU Digital Services Act, hosting providers, which includes the large social networks, must notify the authorities of content suggesting a criminal offence that threatens someone’s life or safety.
In North Rhine-Westphalia some of these reports go first to the Central Cybercrime Unit (Zentral- und Ansprechstelle Cybercrime, ZAC NRW) at the Cologne public prosecutor’s office. Once a suspect has been identified, the case is usually passed to the prosecutor’s office where the suspect lives, which for Bonn means the Staatsanwaltschaft Bonn. Where a statement appears politically motivated, the police state security division (Staatsschutz) usually investigates. There are also nationwide action days on which police forces in many federal states search homes and question suspects at the same time.
When the investigation is complete, the prosecutor decides whether to drop the case, apply for a penalty order (Penalty Order) or bring charges. Trials are usually held at the Bonn Local Court (Amtsgericht Bonn). The Regional Court (Landgericht Bonn) normally deals with such cases only on appeal.
Identification through accounts and IP addresses
Where a post appears under a pseudonym, investigators try to link the account to a person. They ask the platform for subscriber data and the IP addresses used to log in, and then ask the internet provider who was assigned a particular IP address at a particular time (Section 100j of the Code of Criminal Procedure, StPO). This only works if the data still exists. Often open sources are enough: profile pictures, real names, linked phone numbers, earlier posts that mention a home town or an employer.
For the defence, this chain is a key point. An IP address leads to a connection, not to a person. Several people in a household share the same Wi-Fi, accounts are shared, devices are lent, login details are stolen. The case file shows how the link was made and where the gaps are.
Searches and seizure of phones
Once the account holder has been identified, the prosecution often applies to the local court for a search warrant (Search Warrantsbeschluss). The police look for the device used to write the post and for evidence that the suspect uses the account. Phones, laptops and tablets are seized and analysed, which can take months. Whether a search over a single insult is proportionate can be assessed on the basis of the warrant and, if necessary, challenged in court.
During a search, say nothing about the allegations, do not hand over passwords or PINs, object to the seizure and ask for a copy of the warrant. Our page on house searches explains the details.
Deleting posts once you know about the investigation
Many people want to delete their posts straight away. Deleting your own post is not in itself an offence, and taking content down of your own accord stops it from spreading further. It does not undo what has happened, though. Screenshots or data secured from the platform are usually already in the file.
It becomes delicate if whole accounts, chat histories or device storage are wiped after you have learned of the investigation. That can be seen as an attempt to destroy evidence and, in a bad case, raise questions about a risk of tampering with evidence (Verdunkelungsgefahr). Material that would help you, such as the conversation a remark was responding to, is often lost as well. Secure the full context first and agree the next steps with your defence lawyer.
Defence strategies
Freedom of expression under Article 5(1) of the Basic Law (Grundgesetz) protects sharp, polemical and exaggerated criticism, particularly in political debate. Whether a value judgement is punishable is, as a rule, only decided after weighing freedom of expression against the personality rights of the person concerned. Courts may skip that balancing exercise only for pure vilification (Schmähkritik), formal insults and attacks on human dignity, and the Federal Constitutional Court reads these exceptions narrowly. Investigation files often contain no such weighing at all.
Context is decisive. A sentence that looks insulting as an isolated screenshot may, within the conversation, be a reply to a provocation, ironic, or plainly directed at a factual issue. Satire is judged by its core message, not by its packaging. Section 193 StGB also protects statements made in pursuit of legitimate interests.
We also examine how the account was attributed, whether the complaint was valid and filed in time and, under Section 188, whether the statement was really capable of considerably hampering the person’s public work. With incitement to hatred, the question is whether the content targets a protected group and could disturb the public peace. Many cases about a single insult end with the proceedings being dropped under Section 153 or 153a StPO, others with a penalty order. The general rules are set out on our page on insult.
Further consequences
A fine of no more than 90 daily rates is generally not shown on a certificate of conduct (Führungszeugnis), provided no other sentence is recorded. The phone may be confiscated as the instrument of the offence (Section 74 StGB). For civil servants, soldiers and public sector employees, proceedings for incitement to hatred or politically motivated statements often have disciplinary consequences, sometimes even before any conviction. Gun licence holders should expect their reliability to be reviewed.
If you are not a German citizen
If your German is not good enough to follow the proceedings, you are entitled to an interpreter free of charge, including for discussions with your defence lawyer (Section 187 of the Courts Constitution Act, GVG). If you have no fixed address in Germany, the prosecution may require a security deposit and the appointment of a person authorised to accept documents on your behalf (Sections 127a and 132 StPO). A conviction for incitement to hatred or for politically motivated offences can count against you in decisions on residence permits and naturalisation. Our page on visas, residence and criminal proceedings explains how these issues interact.
Frequently asked questions
Can a comment in a private WhatsApp group be an offence?
An insult can be committed there too. Whether the higher penalty for public statements applies depends on how large the group is and who belongs to it. In small family or friends’ groups that is usually not the case.
Does the person insulted have to file a complaint?
In principle yes, within three months. With politicians, however, the prosecution can investigate without a complaint if it finds a special public interest. Incitement to hatred is always prosecuted regardless.
How do the police find my name if I post under a pseudonym?
Through information from the platform and the internet provider about IP addresses and login data, and often through details visible on the profile itself. Whether the attribution holds up only becomes clear from the case file.
If you have received a summons or your home has been searched, call us on +49 228 504 463 36. The first call of up to 10 minutes is free of charge.
This page gives general information and does not replace advice on your individual case.
What to do now
Emergency help: Search and seizure of devices, Police summons received
Court: Proceedings at Bonn Local Court
Emergency help: Summons, House search, Detention
Local defense: Criminal defense attorney in Bonn, Cologne, All offences
Written by attorney Philip Bafteh, criminal defense attorney in Bonn. Philip Bafteh publishes regularly on criminal and commercial law and defends accused persons in investigative and trial proceedings.
More about the attorney →Last updated: November 2026
Free Initial Assessment
Have you received a summons or are you under investigation? Call us. The first assessment by phone is free for up to 10 minutes.
+49 228 504 463 36