Insurance Fraud: criminal defence in Bonn

Legal Basis
§ 263 Abs. 3 S. 2 Nr. 5, § 265 StGB
Sentencing Range
Imprisonment of up to five years or a fine (Section 263(1)); presumptive aggravated case under subsection 3 sentence 2 no. 5: six months to ten years
Summary
Deceiving an insurer to obtain a payment that is not owed (Section 263), or damaging, hiding or handing over an insured item in order to obtain insurance benefits (Section 265)

German criminal law has no single offence called insurance fraud. The term covers two provisions: fraud (Fraud) against an insurer under Section 263 of the German Criminal Code (StGB), and insurance misuse (Versicherungsmissbrauch) under Section 265 StGB. Allegations range from an inflated water damage claim to a staged road accident involving several people. We defend accused persons in Bonn and the surrounding region and coordinate the criminal defence with the dispute that usually runs alongside it with the insurer.

Two offences: fraud and insurance misuse

Fraud against an insurer (Section 263 StGB)

Anyone who states false facts to an insurer, or conceals true ones, in order to obtain a payment they are not entitled to commits fraud. The deception must lead an employee of the insurer into error, which in turn leads to a payout and therefore to financial loss. The basic offence carries imprisonment of up to five years or a fine. Attempted fraud is also punishable (Section 263(2) StGB), so a claim that is submitted but rejected does not go unpunished.

The aggravated case in Section 263(3), sentence 2, no. 5 StGB

In especially serious cases the range rises to imprisonment of six months to ten years. Under number 5, such a case is presumed where the offender pretends that an insured event has occurred after they or someone else, for that purpose, set fire to an item of significant value, destroyed it wholly or partly by fire, or caused a ship to sink or run aground. This is about deliberate fires for the insurance money and similar cases, not about every deception of an insurer.

This is a presumptive example (Regelbeispiel), not a fixed aggravated offence. The court may decide that the case is not especially serious even where the conditions are met, if the circumstances justify it. Conversely, other examples may apply, such as acting on a commercial basis or causing a loss of great magnitude. A member of a gang who commits fraud on a commercial basis falls under Section 263(5) StGB, a felony carrying one to ten years. See our article on aggravated fraud.

Insurance misuse (Section 265 StGB)

Section 265 StGB applies at an earlier stage. It is an offence to damage, destroy, impair the usefulness of, hide or hand over to someone else an item insured against loss, damage, impairment, destruction or theft, in order to obtain insurance benefits for oneself or a third party. No claim needs to have been made. A typical example is a car taken abroad so that it can then be reported stolen.

The penalty is imprisonment of up to three years or a fine, and attempts are punishable. The provision only applies if the act is not punishable under Section 263. Once the loss is reported and there is therefore attempted or completed fraud, Section 265 gives way. Because it refers to insured items, it does not cover life, accident or health insurance.

Typical situations

Staged and induced accidents

In a staged accident, those involved deliberately collide and claim the damage from the liability insurer of one of them. In an induced accident, an unsuspecting driver is made to run into the back of a car, for example by sudden braking without reason. Insurers look out for older high-value vehicles with previous damage and for claims settled on the basis of an expert’s estimate rather than actual repair. Because several people are usually involved, investigators routinely consider whether there was commercial or gang activity.

Simulated theft

The smartphone supposedly taken from a jacket, the expensive bike from the cellar, the car that vanished overnight: insurers normally require a police report before paying out. Anyone who invented the theft therefore also faces proceedings for simulating an offence under Section 145d StGB.

Inflated claims

Often the loss is real but the claim is exaggerated. Older damage is added to a water damage claim, the list of stolen items grows, purchase prices are overstated. If receipts or invoices are created or altered for this purpose, forgery is added to the charges.

Setting fire to one’s own building or vehicle

Where someone sets fire to their own house, business or vehicle to collect the insurance money, arson offences come into play alongside the aggravated fraud provision. Serious arson of a residential building is a felony regardless of who owns it (see arson).

How insurers and investigators work

Many cases begin with the insurer rather than the police. Insurers check claims for anomalies, use experts and their own claims investigators, and compare data through the insurance industry’s information and alert system (HIS). If the suspicion hardens, the insurer files a criminal complaint and hands over its documents.

The police then use the usual tools: analysis of bank statements, mobile phones and chat histories, accident reconstruction by experts, interviews with witnesses and repair shops. Where several people are involved, searches are also carried out. The public prosecutor’s office (Staatsanwaltschaft) in Bonn then decides whether to drop the case, apply for a penalty order (Penalty Order) or bring charges. Depending on the expected sentence, the Bonn Local Court (Amtsgericht Bonn) hears the case with a single judge or with lay judges. Large cases involving substantial losses may be brought before the Bonn Regional Court (Landgericht Bonn).

A common mistake concerns dealings with the insurer itself. Insurance contracts require you to provide information about the claim, and what you tell the insurer often ends up in the investigation file. Statements to the insurer and to the police should therefore be consistent and, where possible, made only after your lawyer has inspected the file.

Defence strategies

The defence starts with whether there was any deception about facts at all. Estimates of the value of used items, vague memories of purchase dates or the classification of earlier damage are not automatically false statements of fact. Intent must also be proved.

In alleged staged accidents, the prosecution often relies on circumstantial evidence: the parties know each other, the type of vehicles, the location, the way the claim was settled. Each point on its own can often be explained. Accident reconstruction reports can be tested against the facts they are based on, and sometimes it makes sense to commission our own expert.

If nothing has been paid yet, the most that can be alleged is an attempt. Someone who voluntarily withdraws the claim before the insurer pays may escape liability by withdrawing from the attempt under Section 24 StGB. Whether this works depends on the case, above all on whether the offence had already been discovered. Where money has already been paid, repairing the damage and acting early in a coordinated way both count in sentencing. For modest amounts, this can open the way to the case being dropped subject to conditions.

Civil and further consequences

Quite apart from the criminal case, an insurer that has been deliberately deceived about a claim can usually refuse to pay anything at all, including for the genuine part of the loss. It will reclaim money already paid, possibly together with further damages. The policy will be terminated, and obtaining new cover may become difficult.

In the criminal proceedings, the court orders confiscation of what was obtained, unless the money has already been repaid to the insurer. A sentence of more than 90 daily rates appears on a certificate of conduct (Führungszeugnis). For people working in finance or insurance, civil servants and holders of trade licences, a fraud allegation often has professional consequences.

If you are not a German citizen

If you do not speak German well enough, you are entitled to an interpreter free of charge, including for discussions with your defence lawyer (Section 187 of the Courts Constitution Act, GVG). If you have no fixed address in Germany, the prosecution may require a security payment and the appointment of a person authorised to accept court documents on your behalf (Sections 127a and 132 StPO). A fraud conviction can weigh heavily in residence matters, including the renewal of a permit and naturalisation. Our page on visas, residence and criminal proceedings explains the connections.

Frequently asked questions

Is exaggerating a genuine loss already insurance fraud?

Yes, if false information is given deliberately in order to obtain more than is owed. Inaccurate estimates and gaps in memory are not fraud.

What is the difference between Section 263 and Section 265 StGB?

Section 263 covers deceiving the insurer. Section 265 already punishes tampering with the insured item, such as hiding a car, and gives way as soon as fraud is established.

Do I still have to answer the insurer’s questions while I am under investigation?

Contractual duties to provide information continue, but what you say can be used in the criminal case. Agree every statement with your defence lawyer beforehand.

Can the case be dropped?

Where the loss is small, the accused has no previous convictions and the damage has been made good, dismissal under Section 153a of the Code of Criminal Procedure (StPO) is possible. In staged accident cases with several participants this is less common.

If an insurer has accused you of fraud or you have received a police summons, call us on +49 228 504 463 36. The first call of up to 10 minutes is free of charge.

This page gives general information and does not replace advice on your individual case.

Attorney Philip Bafteh

Written by attorney Philip Bafteh, criminal defense attorney in Bonn. Philip Bafteh publishes regularly on criminal and commercial law and defends accused persons in investigative and trial proceedings.

More about the attorney →

Last updated: November 2026

Free Initial Assessment

Have you received a summons or are you under investigation? Call us. The first assessment by phone is free for up to 10 minutes.

+49 228 504 463 36