In brief
Anyone accused of an offence is presumed innocent until the conviction becomes final. The accused does not have to prove innocence; the prosecution and the court must prove guilt. If doubts remain, the accused must be acquitted.
Legal basis
The presumption of innocence (Unschuldsvermutung) is laid down expressly in Article 6(2) of the European Convention on Human Rights: everyone charged with a criminal offence is presumed innocent until proved guilty according to law. Article 48(1) of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights contains the same guarantee. The German Basic Law does not state the principle in so many words; the Federal Constitutional Court derives it from the rule of law.
The Code of Criminal Procedure gives effect to it in many places. The public prosecutor must also investigate the circumstances that exonerate the suspect (Section 160(2) StPO). The accused may remain silent and must be told so before every interview (Section 136(1), second sentence, StPO).
What follows from it
The presumption gives rise to the rule “in dubio pro reo”: where there is doubt, the decision goes in favour of the accused. The court decides according to its free conviction formed at the main hearing (Section 261 StPO). If reasonable doubt about the accused’s guilt remains after the evidence has been taken, it may not convict. Silence is not an admission. Anyone who exercises the right to remain silent must not be treated less favourably for doing so.
The presumption applies until the judgment acquires legal force. A first-instance conviction that has been appealed does not displace it.
Limits in practice
The presumption of innocence does not prohibit investigative measures. A search, a seizure or pre-trial detention requires suspicion, not proof of guilt. That is precisely why the law demands a proportionality test for such measures, and pre-trial detention must never become an anticipated punishment. Authorities must also exercise restraint in their public statements: a press release may not present a suspect as a convicted offender.
The presumption binds the state. Employers, landlords and neighbours are not directly bound by it and often draw their own conclusions long before any judgment.
For our work the principle has a very practical consequence. We do not have to prove our clients’ innocence. It is enough to expose the gaps in the prosecution’s case. Where it is one person’s word against another’s, the court must assess the incriminating statement with particular care.
Related terms
General explanation, not advice on an individual case. As of November 2026.