In brief

A person who, because of a serious mental disorder, could not recognise the wrongfulness of the act or could not act in accordance with that recognition acts without guilt and is not punished. That does not mean the proceedings have no consequences: instead of a sentence, committal may be ordered, and it has no fixed end date. The decisive step is usually a psychiatric expert report.

Section 20 StGB names four conditions: a pathological mental disorder, a profound disturbance of consciousness, an intellectual disability, or another serious mental disorder. In addition, the offender must for that reason have been unable, at the time of the act, to appreciate its wrongfulness or to act in accordance with that appreciation. A diagnosis alone is not enough. What matters is the person’s condition at the time of the offence.

Children under 14 always lack criminal capacity (Schuldunfähigkeit) under Section 19 StGB. For juveniles, criminal responsibility must be established in each individual case under Section 3 JGG (juvenile criminal law).

If the capacity to appreciate wrongfulness or to control one’s conduct was only substantially diminished, the sentence may be mitigated under Section 21 in conjunction with Section 49(1) StGB. Mitigation is at the court’s discretion and is often refused where the intoxication was self-induced.

Alcohol and drugs

Intoxication can exclude or diminish criminal capacity. There are no fixed blood alcohol thresholds; the blood alcohol level is one indication alongside the person’s behaviour before, during and after the act. Anyone who intentionally or negligently becomes intoxicated and in that state commits an unlawful act for which they cannot be punished because they lacked capacity is liable for drunkenness under Section 323a StGB. The penalty is imprisonment of up to five years or a fine and may not exceed the penalty provided for the act committed while intoxicated.

Consequences and procedure

Instead of a sentence, the court may order committal to a psychiatric hospital (Section 63 StGB) or to an addiction treatment facility (Section 64 StGB) (measures of rehabilitation and security). Even during the investigation, provisional committal under Section 126a StPO is possible where there are strong grounds and public safety requires it. If the lack of capacity is established, the public prosecutor can apply for preventive measures in separate proceedings under Section 413 StPO instead of bringing charges.

Relying on a lack of criminal capacity is therefore double-edged. An acquittal is of little use if committal without a fixed end follows instead, whereas a prison sentence has a date on which it ends. Nobody is obliged to cooperate with the expert’s examination. We discuss with clients beforehand whether and on what they will speak, and we examine expert reports for their factual basis.

General explanation, not advice on an individual case. As of November 2026.