Proceedings for citizen’s income or child benefit fraud are well known. Alongside them is a group of smaller cases that follow the same pattern and still catch people unprepared: BAföG (student financial aid), housing benefit (Wohngeld) and social assistance under Book XII of the Social Code. The amounts are often modest, investigations almost always start with an automated data comparison, and the authority reclaims the money in parallel with the criminal case. We explain what matters in each area and what they have in common. Detailed information on the benefits themselves is available at sozial-betrug.de, for example on BAföG and housing benefit.
BAföG: the cut-off date and the savings account
For BAföG, the student’s own assets count to the extent they exceed the allowance. Since the 2022/23 winter semester the allowance has been 15,000 euros, or 45,000 euros from the age of 30 (§ 29 BAföG). What counts is the assets at the time of application (§ 28(2) BAföG). Anyone who omits a savings book, building savings contract, securities account or an account opened by grandparents risks proceedings.
Such cases are uncovered through the data comparison under § 41(4) BAföG. The offices compare the information with the tax exemption orders reported to the Federal Central Tax Office. An exemption order reveals that there were capital gains, and thus an account. In the early 2000s this comparison led to tens of thousands of cases nationwide. Today it runs routinely.
Three questions arise for the defense. Did the student know about the assets? With accounts opened and managed by parents or grandparents in the child’s name, often not. Whom did the money really belong to? Trust arrangements with parents are scrutinised critically but are not irrelevant per se. And would the grant have changed at all? Only the amount actually overpaid is damage in the sense of fraud. Without intent, an administrative offense under § 58 BAföG may apply instead of a crime.
Housing benefit: the size of the household
Entitlement to and amount of housing benefit depend on the number of household members, their total income and the rent. Since the 2023 Wohngeld-Plus reform considerably more households are eligible, and the number of cases has risen. Most allegations revolve around two points: a person lives in the flat who is not listed in the application, usually a new partner; or income was not declared or understated, such as a mini-job, a pension or maintenance.
Recipients must report changes without delay (§ 27 WoGG). Failing to report a change can constitute fraud by omission, as the reporting duty is widely held to create a duty to act. Housing benefit offices compare their data under § 33 WoGG with other bodies, including the pension insurance, the Federal Employment Agency and the Federal Central Tax Office.
Disputes about household size often turn on whether someone really lived in the flat or was just there frequently. A new partner who still has their own flat is not automatically a household member. A shared household requires more than overnight stays. The office often relies on registration data or tips from neighbours, both of which can be checked.
Social assistance: the most far-reaching data comparison
For social assistance under SGB XII, mainly basic income support in old age and for reduced earning capacity and subsistence assistance, the data comparison reaches furthest. § 118 SGB XII allows regular automated comparisons with the pension insurance, the Federal Employment Agency, the Federal Central Tax Office and other bodies. This mainly uncovers undeclared pensions, employment and capital income.
Those affected are often elderly or disabled. In many cases a relative or legal guardian filled in the application. The question is then who knew anything at all. A guardian who overlooks a small foreign pension usually does not act intentionally, nor does an elderly person who forgets an old savings book. With early-stage dementia, criminal responsibility (§ 20 StGB) and fitness to stand trial also become issues. A medical certificate from the relevant period is then often the most important document in the file.
What all three have in common
In criminal law the issue is fraud under § 263 StGB, which requires intent: knowing that information is false or incomplete and relevant to the benefit. Negligence is not enough. A misunderstanding about a form, a forgotten account with a small balance or a wrong assumption about what counts as income are not acts of fraud. The file usually contains nothing on intent except the overpayment itself, which is not enough for a conviction.
The administrative procedure always runs alongside. The authority revokes the decision under §§ 45, 48 SGB X and reclaims the benefit under § 50 SGB X. The deadline for an objection is one month. What you write in the objection can be used in the criminal case; conversely, a final recovery decision does not bind the criminal court. We coordinate both proceedings.
Cases often end without a conviction. For small amounts and first offenders, discontinuance under § 153 or § 153a StPO is common, especially if the repayment has been made or an instalment plan agreed. If convicted, a fine is the rule; below 91 daily rates it does not appear in the certificate of good conduct for first offenders.
How the damage is calculated
The authority usually reclaims the entire benefit for the period concerned. That may be permissible in administrative law, but it is not the damage in criminal law. For fraud, only the difference between what was paid and what would have been due with correct information counts. With BAföG and assets just above the allowance, this may be a fraction of the reclaimed amount. For housing benefit, an additional household member reduces entitlement but does not necessarily eliminate it, as the maximum amounts change with household size. For social assistance, allowances for earned income and protected assets must be deducted. We recalculate entitlement month by month, which affects sentencing, the chance of discontinuance and sometimes whether charges are brought at all.
Frequently asked questions
I have already repaid the money. Is the case closed?
No, repayment does not remove criminal liability. But it is the most important factor for a discontinuance and clearly mitigates any sentence.
Do I have to attend the police interview?
No. As an accused you do not have to follow a police summons. Where useful, we submit a written statement after file access.
When the questionnaire arrives
A police hearing form or a letter from the authority mentioning criminal proceedings is no reason for a quick explanation. Personal details are mandatory, statements on the facts are not. We apply for file access, review the data comparison, the application and the decisions, and then decide whether a statement makes sense. At the same time we check the recovery decision and the objection deadline. You can reach us at +49 228 504 463 36. This information is general and does not replace advice in an individual case.
Questions about this topic?
If you are personally affected or need legal advice, please get in touch. An initial phone consultation of up to 10 minutes is free of charge.
Contact