A voluntary disclosure (Selbstanzeige) under § 371 of the Fiscal Code (Abgabenordnung, AO) is the only way to put right a tax evasion that has already been committed without being punished for it. It only works, however, if it is complete, made in time and formally correct. A failed disclosure can do harm, because it reveals the facts to the tax authorities without bringing immunity from prosecution. We handle voluntary disclosures in Bonn and throughout Germany, in coordination with your tax adviser and with a risk assessment before anything reaches the tax office.
Requirements for an effective disclosure under § 371 AO
Immunity is only granted to someone who, in full and towards the tax authorities, corrects incorrect information, completes incomplete information or supplies omitted information for all tax offences relating to one type of tax. The disclosure must cover all offences concerning that type of tax that are not yet time-barred, and at least those of the last ten calendar years (§ 371(1) AO). On that basis the tax office must be able to assess the tax without lengthy investigations of its own.
If the tax evaded exceeds 25,000 euros per offence, or if there is an especially serious case under § 370(3), second sentence, nos. 2 to 6 AO, immunity does not apply (§ 371(2), first sentence, nos. 3 and 4 AO). The authorities will, however, refrain from prosecution under § 398a AO if an additional sum is paid on top of the tax and interest. It amounts to 10 per cent of the evaded tax where the amount evaded is up to 100,000 euros, 15 per cent up to 1 million euros and 20 per cent above that. A voluntary disclosure is therefore not a form to fill in. It requires a precise record of amounts, periods and types of tax.
Grounds for exclusion: when it is too late
Under § 371(2) AO, immunity is excluded, among other cases, if a tax audit order has been notified (to the extent of the announced audit), if an official has appeared to carry out a tax audit or to investigate a tax offence, if an official has appeared for a VAT or wage tax inspection (Nachschau) and shown identification, or if the initiation of criminal or regulatory fine proceedings has been notified. A disclosure is also barred if the offence had already been discovered and the offender knew this or should have expected it.
This last ground is the hardest to assess. Purchased data carriers, the automatic international exchange of financial account information (Common Reporting Standard, CRS) and control notifications between authorities mean that foreign accounts are often “discovered” earlier than those affected assume. We check whether a ground for exclusion applies before every submission.
The completeness requirement and back payment
Since the Act to Combat Undeclared Income (Schwarzgeldbekämpfungsgesetz) of 2011, partial disclosures no longer give immunity. Anyone who only declares what is about to come to light anyway loses immunity for the entire type of tax. The courts only tolerate minor deviations. There is an exception for advance VAT returns and wage tax returns: here a correction gives immunity to the extent that it covers (§ 371(2a) AO).
Immunity also requires you to pay the evaded tax and the interest on evaded tax (Hinterziehungszinsen) within the deadline set by the tax office (§ 371(3) AO). This interest is 0.5 per cent per month, which is 6 per cent a year (§§ 235, 238 AO). We calculate the total burden in advance so that the disclosure does not fail at the payment stage.
Procedure: defence lawyer and tax adviser together
The figures are usually prepared by the tax adviser; the defence lawyer sets the criminal law framework. We determine the scope of the declaration, coordinate communication with the tax office and, where necessary, with its unit for fines and criminal tax matters (Bußgeld- und Strafsachenstelle), and keep an eye on deadlines and form. Where old bank records are missing, we work with reasoned estimates and a safety margin so that the disclosure is still complete. If you wish, we coordinate the whole engagement through our office, so that you only have one point of contact.
If you have income or accounts abroad
Many people in the Bonn area have ties to other countries: a bank account in their home country, a flat that is let out, investments or a foreign pension. Anyone resident in Germany is generally liable to German tax on their worldwide income. Whether a double taxation agreement gives the right to tax to the other country, and whether the income must still be declared in Germany, depends on the agreement and on the type of income. Staff of international organisations often have a special tax status for their salary, which does not automatically extend to other income. Before a disclosure, we clarify with your tax adviser which income was taxable in Germany at all, because that defines what has to be disclosed.
If the disclosure fails or comes too late
If a ground for exclusion has arisen or the disclosure was incomplete, the defence is not over. A failed disclosure together with the back payment usually reduces the sentence considerably. We then defend you in the criminal tax proceedings, from a search by the tax investigation service (Steuerfahndung) and the question of whether and how you make a statement, up to a possible negotiated agreement. Our page on tax evasion (§ 370 AO) explains the offence itself, and the section on consequences of a conviction covers the effects on the certificate of good conduct (Führungszeugnis), on a business or on civil servant status. A short definition can be found in our glossary under voluntary disclosure.
Frequently asked questions
Until when is a voluntary disclosure possible?
As long as no ground for exclusion under § 371(2) AO has arisen, in particular before a tax audit order has been notified, proceedings have been initiated or the offence has been discovered. Whether the offence has already been discovered can hardly be seen from the outside. The earlier you act, the lower that risk. We assess your situation in the first consultation, before anything reaches the tax office.
Will my employer find out about the disclosure?
After an effective voluntary disclosure there is no conviction and therefore no entry in the certificate of good conduct. The proceedings are also protected by tax secrecy (§ 30 AO). For civil servants and certain professions, special reporting and disciplinary rules may apply; we clarify this in advance.
Is a partial disclosure possible?
As a rule, no. Since 2011, an incomplete disclosure leads to the loss of immunity for the type of tax concerned; only minor deviations are harmless. Exceptions apply to advance VAT returns and wage tax returns (§ 371(2a) AO). The first step is therefore always to work through all accounts, income and periods.
A confidential first consultation, before the tax office takes action.
A ground for exclusion can arise at any time. Call us in confidence: +49 228 504 463 36. The first assessment by phone is free of charge for up to 10 minutes. Alternatively, use the contact form.
This page gives general information and does not replace advice on your individual case.