Coercion in Road Traffic: criminal defence in Bonn

Legal Basis
§ 240 StGB
Sentencing Range
Imprisonment of up to three years or a fine (subsection 1)
Summary
Forcing other road users into particular conduct by force or threats, for example by tailgating, brake-checking or blocking, in a reprehensible manner.

Tailgating with flashing headlights, deliberately braking in front of another car or blocking the overtaking lane regularly leads to a criminal complaint for coercion (Coercion) under Section 240 of the German Criminal Code (StGB). The complaint usually comes from the other driver, often backed by dashcam footage and a noted registration number. For the accused, more than a fine is at stake: a driving ban or the withdrawal of the driving licence may follow. We defend clients in traffic criminal cases in Bonn and the surrounding region.

Typical situations

These cases follow familiar patterns. On the motorway (Autobahn), a driver follows very closely over a longer distance, flashes the headlights or sounds the horn, and tries to push the car ahead out of the lane. Conversely, a driver brakes hard without any traffic reason to teach the driver behind a lesson or to force them to stop. Then there is deliberate blocking, for instance by driving side by side across two lanes, by preventing someone from merging or by obstructing an exit. Disputes over parking spaces form their own group: a pedestrian stands in the space to keep it free, and a driver edges slowly towards them.

There is almost always a back story, such as an overtaking manoeuvre, a lane change or a moment in which someone felt pressed. The complaint rarely tells that part in full.

Legal basis and penalty

Under Section 240(1) StGB, anyone who unlawfully forces another person by force or by threat of serious harm to do, tolerate or refrain from something commits an offence. The penalty is imprisonment of up to three years or a fine, and the attempt is also punishable. First offenders will mainly face a fine, quite often combined with a driving ban.

What counts as force on the road

According to the case law, force requires a compulsion that the victim experiences physically. Psychological pressure alone is not enough. With tailgating, the question is whether the conduct was so intense in duration, distance and speed that the driver in front felt it as physical compulsion and moved over for fear of a rear-end collision. Briefly closing up or a single flash of the headlights will not normally suffice. Brake-checking comes closer to force, because the following driver is physically made to brake. What matters then is whether they really had to brake hard.

Intent is also required. The driver must want to force the other person into a particular action. Someone who follows too closely through inattention, or who brakes because of an obstacle, coerces nobody.

Reprehensibility (Section 240(2) StGB)

Not every act of coercion is a crime. It is unlawful only if the use of force or the threat is reprehensible (verwerflich) in relation to the aim pursued. The courts weigh means against ends and look at how much danger was created. Wanting to discipline another driver who was allegedly too slow, or who had tailgated first, is no justification. Nobody is entitled to punish other road users. On the other hand, a brief and minor obstruction, such as blocking a gap for a moment without endangering anyone, may not be reprehensible. This balancing exercise lies at the heart of most defences.

Distinguishing administrative offences and Sections 315b, 315c StGB

Following too closely is not always a crime. A driver who fails to keep the necessary distance without intending to force anyone to do anything commits a breach of Section 4(1) of the Road Traffic Regulations (StVO). That is a regulatory offence (Ordnungswidrigkeit) dealt with by a fine and, depending on the degree, penalty points and a driving ban. The same applies to braking sharply without a compelling reason, which Section 4(1), second sentence, StVO prohibits. Since 1 July 2026 the limitation period for prosecuting road traffic regulatory offences has been six months (Section 26(3) of the Road Traffic Act, StVG). Whether a case ends as a crime or as a regulatory offence often depends on whether intent to coerce can be proved.

At the more serious end, coercion borders on the road endangerment offences. Endangering road traffic under Section 315c StGB covers, among other things, overtaking wrongly and driving wrongly during overtaking, where the driver acts in a grossly improper and reckless way and thereby creates a concrete danger to another person’s life or limb or to property of significant value. Dangerous interference with road traffic under Section 315b StGB concerns cases in which the vehicle is deliberately used as an obstacle or weapon, for example braking in order to cause a collision. For conduct in moving traffic the case law requires at least conditional intent to cause harm. Both offences carry up to five years’ imprisonment. Under Section 315c StGB the withdrawal of the driving licence is the rule (Section 69(2) StGB).

Dashcam footage and other evidence

Complainants increasingly hand in dashcam footage. Whether it may be used in criminal proceedings is decided by the courts on a case-by-case balancing of interests. Permanent recording without any specific reason raises data protection concerns but does not automatically make the footage inadmissible. Objections to its use should be raised in good time at trial.

Its content is often the bigger issue. Wide-angle lenses distort distances, and gaps or speeds can only be reliably determined from a video with the help of an expert. The back story is frequently missing because only an excerpt was saved. We therefore request the complete original file and consider whether an expert report is worthwhile. Investigators also rely on witness statements, which after a drive at high speed are bound to be imprecise.

The registration number only identifies the registered keeper. The prosecution has to prove who was driving. Keepers are not obliged to name the driver, and close relatives may refuse to give evidence.

Driving ban and withdrawal of the licence

For many accused, the licence matters more than the sentence. Alongside a fine or imprisonment, the court can impose a driving ban (Fahrverbot) of one to six months under Section 44 StGB. The licence itself remains valid, but the document is held by the authorities for the duration of the ban.

The withdrawal of the driving licence (Entziehung der Fahrerlaubnis) under Section 69 StGB goes further. It requires that the offence shows the driver to be unfit to drive. Coercion is not among the standard cases listed in Section 69(2) StGB, so unfitness has to be established on the facts of the individual case. Courts do find it where driving was particularly aggressive and dangerous. The licence then lapses when the judgment becomes final, and the court sets a period before a new licence may be issued. A provisional withdrawal under Section 111a of the Code of Criminal Procedure (StPO) is possible during the investigation and can be challenged by way of complaint.

How the case proceeds in Bonn

After the complaint, the police identify the keeper and send a questionnaire (Anhörungsbogen) or a summons. The file then goes to the Bonn public prosecutor’s office (Staatsanwaltschaft Bonn). In traffic cases it often applies for a penalty order (Penalty Order), which can include a fine and a driving ban. An objection must be lodged within two weeks. The case is then heard by the Bonn Local Court (Amtsgericht Bonn), and any appeal by the Bonn Regional Court (Landgericht Bonn).

Discontinuation under Section 153 or 153a StPO is possible where guilt is regarded as minor. If intent to coerce cannot be proved, the criminal case can be closed and the matter passed to the regulatory authority as an administrative offence.

Lines of defence

We first check whether the identity of the driver is established. Then we turn to what actually happened. How long did the tailgating last, what was the real distance, what speeds were involved, and was there a reason to brake? The allegation often rests on a single estimate by the complainant. Where the facts point to a regulatory offence, we work towards discontinuation of the criminal case. As regards the licence, we argue against a finding of unfitness and against provisional withdrawal.

Further consequences

A conviction for coercion is entered in the Federal Central Criminal Register. Fines of no more than 90 daily rates generally do not appear on a certificate of good conduct (Führungszeugnis) if there is no other entry. Depending on the outcome, entries in the driving aptitude register (Fahreignungsregister) may follow. For professional drivers, field staff and anyone who depends on a car for work, even a driving ban can have serious consequences.

If you are not a German citizen

If your German is not sufficient, you are entitled to an interpreter free of charge (Section 187 of the Courts Constitution Act, GVG). Drivers without a permanent residence in Germany, including those just passing through, may be required to provide security for the expected fine and costs and to appoint a person authorised to accept service (Sections 127a and 132 StPO). A driving ban imposed by a German court is noted in a non-EU licence; holders of an EU licence with their normal residence in Germany must hand it in. Criminal convictions can also matter for residence permits, as we explain on our page on visa, residence and criminal proceedings.

Frequently asked questions

Is tailgating always coercion?

No. Following too closely for a short time is normally a regulatory offence under Section 4 StVO. Coercion only comes into question where the driver in front is pressed hard over a certain period in order to make them move over.

Can dashcam footage be used against me?

That depends on a balancing of interests in the individual case; there is no general bar on using it. Quite apart from that, it has to be checked what the footage actually shows and what it leaves out.

Will I lose my licence?

A driving ban of one to six months is possible, and in serious cases the withdrawal of the licence. For coercion, withdrawal is not the standard outcome and requires specific reasons.

Do I have to say who was driving my car?

No. As an accused person you need not say anything. As a witness you may refuse to answer if you would incriminate yourself or a close relative.

If you have received a questionnaire or summons concerning coercion on the road, you can reach us on +49 228 504 463 36, also at night and at weekends. The first telephone assessment is free of charge for up to 10 minutes.

This page gives general information and does not replace advice on your individual case.

Attorney Philip Bafteh

Written by attorney Philip Bafteh, criminal defense attorney in Bonn. Philip Bafteh publishes regularly on criminal and commercial law and defends accused persons in investigative and trial proceedings.

More about the attorney →

Last updated: November 2026

Free Initial Assessment

Have you received a summons or are you under investigation? Call us. The first assessment by phone is free for up to 10 minutes.

+49 228 504 463 36