An e-scooter clips the wing mirror of a parked car as it passes, a pedestrian is bumped on the pavement, and the rider keeps going. A few days later, a questionnaire (Anhörungsbogen) arrives concerning unauthorised leaving of the scene of an accident (unerlaubtes Entfernen vom Unfallort) under § 142 StGB, usually called hit and run (Hit and Run). Many people are surprised how seriously this is taken. An e-scooter is a motor vehicle, so apart from a fine, your car driving licence may also be at stake in the proceedings. We defend in hit-and-run cases in Bonn, Cologne and the Rhein-Sieg district.
The e-scooter as a motor vehicle
E-scooters are small electric vehicles (Elektrokleinstfahrzeuge) within the meaning of the Small Electric Vehicles Ordinance (eKFV) and therefore motor vehicles. You do not need a driving licence to ride one, but you do need third-party liability insurance with an insurance sticker. This classification has legal consequences that many people are not aware of. For alcohol, the same limit of absolute unfitness to drive applies as for cars, and an offence committed on an e-scooter is an offence “in connection with driving a motor vehicle”. That opens the way to withdrawal of the driving licence under § 69 StGB.
The requirements of § 142 StGB in brief
An offence is committed by anyone who leaves the scene after a road traffic accident before enabling their identity, their vehicle and their involvement to be established, or before waiting for a reasonable time. An accident requires damage to someone else that is not completely trivial. There must also be intent: the rider must have noticed the accident or at least considered it possible. The penalty is imprisonment of up to three years or a fine. A more detailed account of the elements of the offence is on our page on hit and run (§ 142 StGB).
Typical evidential issues with e-scooters
With e-scooters, it is often unclear who was actually riding. Rental scooters are hired through an app account, and investigators ask the provider who was logged in at the time and where the scooter went. But the account does not always belong to the person standing on the board. With privately owned scooters, the insurance sticker leads to the keeper, not necessarily to the rider. Witnesses often describe no more than “a young man with a rucksack”.
The second question is whether the contact could be noticed at all. Someone who brushes a mirror with the handlebar does not always feel it, especially in traffic noise or while wearing headphones. Whether the contact must have been noticed can sometimes only be settled with an expert report. Finally, the amount of damage is often disputed. What the injured party claims on the basis of a repair estimate is not automatically the damage attributable to the rider.
Driving licence, disqualification period and driving ban
For a hit and run with serious consequences, withdrawal of the driving licence is the rule, namely where the offender knows or could know that a person has been killed or more than slightly injured, or that significant damage has been caused to someone else’s property (§ 69(2) no. 3 StGB). This applies even if the offence was committed on an e-scooter. The court can provisionally withdraw the licence while the investigation is still under way (§ 111a StPO). Someone who does not hold a licence can be given a stand-alone disqualification period (isolierte Sperrfrist, § 69a(1) sentence 3 StGB) and may not obtain a licence during that time. Below the threshold for the standard case, a driving ban (Fahrverbot) of up to six months remains possible (§ 44 StGB). How to respond to a provisional withdrawal is described on our page on emergency help with licence withdrawal.
If alcohol was involved, there is usually an additional allegation of drink-driving (Drink Driving). The driving licence is then almost always at risk.
Reporting afterwards and active repentance
Someone who has left the scene can still enable the necessary details to be established afterwards by contacting the injured party or a nearby police station (§ 142(3) StGB). For accidents outside moving traffic that caused only minor property damage, § 142(4) StGB allows the court to reduce the sentence or dispense with punishment if the report is made voluntarily within 24 hours. With an e-scooter this can cover parking or manoeuvring at the roadside, for example. A report should not be made in a hurry, though: whatever you say ends up in the file.
If you are not a German citizen
Many e-scooter riders in Bonn are students, interns or visitors from abroad. If you hold a foreign driving licence, a German court cannot cancel it, but a withdrawal takes away your right to use it in Germany. If the licence was issued in another EU or EEA state and you normally live in Germany, it is confiscated and sent back to the issuing authority (§ 69b StGB). In police questioning and in court, you are entitled to an interpreter free of charge (§ 187 GVG). If you are about to leave Germany, the authorities may require a security deposit and a person authorised to accept court documents for you (§§ 127a, 132 StPO). Talk to us before you leave, so that the case does not continue without your knowledge.
What we do as defence counsel
We apply for access to the file and examine how the investigators identified our client, what the witnesses actually saw and how the damage was quantified. If provisional withdrawal of the licence is threatened, that is where we start. Where the damage is small and it is unclear whether the contact could be noticed, dismissal under § 153 or § 153a StPO is a realistic aim. If it cannot be established who was riding, the proceedings can also be dropped under § 170(2) StPO.
Frequently asked questions
Does § 142 StGB apply to e-scooters?
Yes. The provision covers everyone involved in an accident, including e-scooter riders, cyclists and pedestrians.
Can I lose my car driving licence?
Yes. Because an e-scooter is a motor vehicle, the court can withdraw your driving licence if significant damage was caused or someone was injured, even though you were not driving a car at the time.
What if I did not notice the accident?
Then there is no intent. Whether that is credible depends on the type of contact, the speed and the circumstances, and can only be assessed after inspecting the file.
Does reporting it afterwards help?
It can work in your favour, and in certain cases it leads to a reduced sentence or to no punishment at all. You should agree on what to say with a defence lawyer beforehand.
Further reading: emergency help in criminal proceedings, police summons as a suspect, penalty orders in Bonn, court-appointed defence lawyer in Bonn, criminal offences.
Received a questionnaire or police summons about a hit and run with an e-scooter? Use our contact form or call us on +49 228 504 463 36. The first assessment by phone is free of charge for up to 10 minutes.
This page gives general information and does not replace advice on your individual case.